"IDF stole organs from 'Palestinians'" claim proven false.

Status
Not open for further replies.
You think a gunshot wound in the chest would make it possible to answer questions [see the location of the bullet wound in the chest]? Maybe the autopsy provided the answers? Or were they written on his teeth?
 
Slysoon said:
The statement was published by the Halachic Organ Donor Society itself. Whether they were obfuscating the issue or not has never been disclosed by the European Union.
Click to expand...

What is there exactly? That Israel was kicked out of the EU or some other organization?
 
S.A.M. said:
I would assume that the EU would trade organs on a need basis not a regional basis. Is this a false assumption? Do European organ donation networks only supply organs to people in the EU?
Click to expand...

Most nations have organizations that donate organs on a regional basis. You do know that organ transplants are time related once its been removed? You either have to move someone to a different region and remove the organ there or transport it. Can you imagine transferring an organ from NY to Berlin for example? Or Asia or Africa? Think of the time and the quality of the organ.

"Generally, where organs can not be bought or sold, quality and safety are high, but supply is not adequate to the demand. Where organs can be purchased, the supply increase somewhat, but safety declines"

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Organ_donation
 
Last edited:
StrawDog said:
Of course, but it reveals a distinct Israeli predilection for such activity, and thus ANY allegations involving organ plundering from ANY one, including Palestinians, should be taken seriously.
Click to expand...

Even if its untrue. I guess then that ethnic profiling is also justified since some groups reveal a predilection for certain activities.

I'll be sure to let the LAPD and Homeland security know of this.
 
Lucysnow said:
Even if its untrue. I guess then that ethnic profiling is also justified since some groups reveal a predilection for certain activities.

I'll be sure to let the LAPD and Homeland security know of this.
Click to expand...
Are you saying US prisons are full of Negroes?
 
StrawDog said:
Are you saying US prisons are full of Negroes?
Click to expand...

Prisons? Blacks? Where did you get all that from. I'm saying that you cannot say that some groups have a predilection for particular activities and that this is evidence enough for 'serious investigation' without running into a theme whereby all groups become a victim of their stereotypes, that's what I'm saying.
 
Lucysnow said:
Prisons? Blacks? Where did you get all that from. I'm saying that you cannot say that some groups have a predilection for particular activities and that this is evidence enough for 'serious investigation' without running into a theme whereby all groups become a victim of their stereotypes, that's what I'm saying.
Click to expand...
Ah. OK. Lets say the Israelis (including the Israeli authorities) have a proven track record of dealing in organs. That is a good reason to take claims of organ trafficking involving Palestinians seriously.
 
India, among others, has a proven track record of dealing with organs but it doesn't mean that every and any allegation is true. This same principle should be held in regards with the IDF allegations. If it is true then wait until there is enough evidence to warrant the charge.
 
quadraphonics said:
No it doesn't. None of the references you gave cite any examples of any organs being stolen from anyone.
Click to expand...
Testimony in a court of law, (yes, even in Brazil) is solid information that should be considered. And yes, I agree, until such evidence surfaces, this remains unclear.
 
Lucysnow said:
India, among others, has a proven track record of dealing with organs but it doesn't mean that every and any allegation is true. This same principle should be held in regards with the IDF allegations. If it is true then wait until there is enough evidence to warrant the charge.
Click to expand...
Yes, I agree. Let the evidence speak for itself. If it ever sees the light of day.
 
S.A.M. said:
Maybe, but there hasn't been a single denial of the autopsies from Israel. And the Swedish reporter saw the autopsied body, so that is no conspiracy.
Click to expand...

Autopsied bodies are not evidence of any conspiracy of any kind.

And neither is the Israeli organ trafficking ring since arrrests have been made in Brazil and New York and testimonies given by retired IDF officers.
Click to expand...

You'll find trafficking in body parts conducted by people of many nationalities, if only you care to look.

S.A.M. said:
More:[/quote[

From O Globo, I note, an organization with some fascinating ties to military dictatorship. Sounds faintly fascist to me.

Seems to me like the Swedish reporter is being shouted down to suppress what is really going on.
Click to expand...

Seems much more like he's being called on to back up his story with evidence and can't.

StrawDog said:
Of course, but it reveals a distinct Israeli predilection for such activity
Click to expand...

That was a shockingly bigoted comment. Israelis like to steal organs? Really? National pastime? Is there an amateur league?
Click to expand...
 
This thread belongs on ********** or some other anti-Semitic hate site. What's next? Jews steal babies and eat them?

Thread closed and cesspooled.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top