Chat GPT makes some mistakes about the theory of relativity

Here we are the observers,
We can be on A, or we can be on B. We can also be neither on A nor B, we are just observers.
It looks like you're going to tell us where we think about this problem will affect the time speed of A and B, great James R, we start to look forward to your analysis.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide all adverts.

Your answer is equivalent to saying nothing. Please give a clear and clear answer. GPT's thinking is clear, and talk with GPT is smooth and logical. GPT is a good assistant, GPT is not a god, but its honesty can bring us closer to the truth. Of course, sophistry humans can cover up the facts by denying GPT.

James R, the greatest SRT scientist in sciforums, I hope you will pay attention to my question, carefully analyze my question, and then give your answer. Who's time is slower, A or B?

 

Log in or Sign up to hide all adverts.

GPT is an assistant at your service at any time, it is very honest, but it is not a god, it also has flaws, so we define it as an assistant. The knowledge of GPT in many fields has surpassed many independent humans, such as physics professors, mathematicians, doctors, financial workers and so on. GPT will let those sophistry show his tail.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide all adverts.

My conversation with GPT about SRT has been shared with you. If you can patiently read the conversation between me and GPT, you will realize that SRT is a fallacy. The West has made outstanding contributions to natural science. Although SRT and GRT have plunged the world into darkness, this still cannot conceal the great achievements the West has made in the past few hundred years. I still believe that the West will continue to lead the development of world science , the West has scientific soil.
James R, chemist, etc. You are all lovely people. Freedom, democracy, and equality are the best soil for scientific development.

 

It is much, much worse than that. Google will not plain fabricate information. ChatGPT will.

It is not at all honest.

Again, if you are basing your beliefs on what ChatGPT tells you, you are just as wrong as that lawyer that was punished for the false information it gave him.

 

Well done James R, you gave a solid answer.
Now let's go back to the twin paradox experiment.
Can you use your conclusion just now to explain the twin paradox experiment? According to your statement, A on the earth acts as an observer, and B's time slows down, so B will be younger.
But if B acts as an observer, A's time will also slow down, and A should be younger.
But the final conclusion of this experiment is that brother A on earth will be older than brother B on the spaceship.
Can you explain it based on your previous analysis?

 

I can tell you that your answer is almost the same as GPT. So let's forget about twins for a moment.
OK, on to our questions.
As an observer, A catches up with B, so when they meet, does A see a younger B?
As an observer, B was caught up by A, so when they met, did B see a younger A?
If there is a C at the place where A and B meet, may I ask C as an observer, in the eyes of C, is A younger or B?

 

What do these questions, what does this analysis of relativity, have to do with the accuracy or otherwise, and reasons thereof, of ChatGPT? Is this a physics thread, or one about ChatGPT?

 

GPT is like Google, but GPT is smarter. Don't you guys use GPT to help with some of your work?
We should keep an open mind about GPT, we can use it or refuse it. This is the freedom of everyone, and this is the embodiment of the free society we aspire to.

 

Don't you think it's ridiculous if you think that your answer can win the support of others? Your answer is almost identical to GPT's answer, but we can talk to GPT to make it realize that there is a problem with its answer, but for you James R, I think it would be better to leave this topic on hold.

 

OK, both A and B start from the earth, and A and B have exactly the same age when they set off. (I hope you stop asking me which astronaut looks younger because of regular facials).
Are they resting together, why ask this question? Do you still need to know if they live in the same room and sleep in the same bed?
They have their own speed, I think they have either actively accelerated or passively accelerated, your question still looks very strange.
Do they have to be at the same speed when they meet? Bolt raced against the great James X, Bolt started slow, but he caught up to James X, Bolt gave James X a 0.1 second smile. I don't think anyone thinks they have the same speed when they meet.
In the same way, there is no relationship between meeting and whether you are accelerating.
James R gave so many constraints, and added N constraints to a simple physics problem. Hope my answer satisfies you.
There is a saying in China: "Get shot while lying down", GPT is innocent. But it became a victim. GPT is just an honest assistant, it doesn't quibble like some humans do.

 

There is a saying in China: "Get shot while lying down", GPT is innocent. But it became a victim. GPT is just an honest assistant, it doesn't quibble like some humans do.

“Chat GPT makes some mistakes about the theory of relativity”
Is this the title of my post? Can James R modify the title of our post at will? Today's Western society places great emphasis on human rights and freedom. Did James R come from the Middle Ages in Europe?
James R, did you travel from the Middle Ages under the guidance of Einstein's SRT?

 

Chatgpt said it was a real case, but it wasn't. Chatgpt lied!

 

The meaning of James R has been clearly presented. The dilation of time does not only depend on the speed of A and B, but also depends on the acceleration of A and B. James R, is my understanding correct?
James R told us that the initial velocity of A and B is very important, and the acceleration of A and B is also very important. James R, when you talk about velocity and acceleration, do you consider reference objects?
James R From your description, we can see that you take the earth as a reference object, and you endow A and B with an initial velocity of 0. Do you agree with me?
When we observe A and B, we must understand the acceleration and deceleration process of A and B from the beginning to the present. Only in this way can we know who will be younger between A and B. If A comes from the earth, and B comes from a planet that James R does not know, does that mean that James R can never know the initial velocity of B, nor can he know the acceleration process of B, nor can he know the total time dilation on B? ?
For the two brothers in the twin paradox experiment, the elder brother left the earth in a spaceship, and the elder brother has acceleration and deceleration processes, so according to James R's point of view, the elder brother will be younger. But did James R notice that our earth has been accelerating relative to the sun? This acceleration is obviously different from that of his brother. How does James R think about the impact of the acceleration of the earth on his brother's time dilation?
As the great James R who came from the Middle Ages and was proficient in SRT, did you teach Einstein the great SRT? Or are you and Einstein the twins?