Black Holes .

[DaveC426913]

If that were to happen then the wave would cease to manifest .

Because the wave would never be more than a wave . Because it would never have anything on which to focus its energy . To gather . So to speak . The wave would be a wave for infinity .

You are just making stuff up. You have no idea what you are talking about.

Go back to asking questions.

 

[river]

river said: ↑
If that were to happen then the wave would cease to manifest .

Because the wave would never be more than a wave . Because it would never have anything on which to focus its energy . To gather . So to speak . The wave would be a wave for infinity .

You are just making stuff up. You have no idea what you are talking about.

Go back to asking questions.

No I thought it through .

 

[DaveC426913]

No I thought it through .

You can think it through all you want. You aren't scientifically adept.

This is called "word salad":
"... it would never have anything on which to focus its energy..."
This is not how science works.

Read some books. Ask questions. Accept the answers.

 

[river]

New
↑
No I thought it through .

You can think it through all you want. You aren't scientifically adept.

This is called "word salad":
"... it would never have anything on which to focus its energy..."
This is not how science works.

Read some books. Ask questions. Accept the answers.

Science works by understanding .

 

[DaveC426913]

Science works by understanding .

Exactly. And you don't.

I'm not going to keep going over this just to feed your willful ignorance. You've been given answers - even to questions you don't have the vocabulary to express.

You can do this river. Read some books. Ask questions. Avoid making assertions about things you know little about.

 

[river]

river said: ↑
Science works by understanding .

Exactly. And you don't.

I'm not going to keep going over this just to feed your willful ignorance. You've been given answers - even to questions you don't have the vocabulary to express.

You can do this river. Read some books. Ask questions. Avoid making assertions about things you know little about.

I have been given no answers .

I asked what form of matter is the singularity based . No answer .

 

[DaveC426913]

I have been given no answers .

You have; they're just not answers you understand.

Imagine trying to explain how your phone works to a caveman.
He simply lacks the groundwork of education to even understand what he's being told.

Halfway through this discussion you thought black holes preceded the Big Bang. You don't know the relationship between stars, black holes, and the galactic core. You've asked what form a thing takes before it exists. You think rotation of a massive body is what gives it its gravity.

You won't be able to grasp the answers until you at least have a working knowledge of the concepts. That's why these answers make no sense to you. I'm explaining cellphone electronics and you're complaining that banging two rocks together won't let two people talk to each other.

Read some basic science books. Ask questions. Accept the answers you're given.

 

[river]

You have; they're just not answers you understand.

Imagine trying to explain how your phone works to a caveman.
He simply lacks the groundwork of education to even understand what he's being told.

Halfway through this discussion you thought black holes preceded the Big Bang. You don't know the relationship between stars, black holes, and the galactic core. You've asked what form a thing takes before it exists. You think rotation of a massive body is what gives it its gravity.

You won't be able to grasp the answers until you at least have a working knowledge of the concepts. That's why these answers make no sense to you. I'm explaining cellphone electronics and you're complaining that banging two rocks together won't let two people talk to each other.

Read some basic science books. Ask questions. Accept the answers you're given.

I asked what form of matter is the singularity of a BH based . No answer .

 

[DaveC426913]

I asked what form of matter is the singularity of a BH based . No answer .

This question has been answered multiple times.
Please review the thread before making such a demonstrably false claim again.

 

[river]

river said: ↑
I asked what form of matter is the singularity of a BH based . No answer .

This question has been answered multiple times.
Please review the thread before making such a demonstrably false claim again.

Ah I see , this star stuff .

What form of matter , (from the star , which does not rotate , but explodes ) , forms its BH ? Happy ?

But I'm sure it won't still answer my question .

Oh we don't know because the physics breaks down . At a BH .

No kidding . Because it never made sense in the first place . Period . And never will .

What ever they want to believe . Dave .

BH , the existence of , is the belief in mathematical theory . Nothing more .

 

[James R]

This avoidance of an explaination towards galactic core BH is concerning . All responses focus on stars not the galactic core . Why is that ?

Ah.. so black-holes came before BB .

In order for the singularity to have any truth to it , what physical form did the singularity have before it formed ?

Disagree

A singularity has a fundamental form based on something that is physical .

As I said before , all energy and matter forms have always existed .

Enough is enough.

river is banned from posting in our science sections precisely because of these nonsense claims he makes about science and scientific facts.

As for his questions, he constantly fails to read responses, and fails - or perhaps pretends to fail - to understand the responses he is given. Often we see him assuming the opposite of what he has just been told - sometimes in his very next post.

This thread, since it contains questions about known science, properly belongs in our Science sections, despite the naivete of the questions being asked (feigned or real doesn't much matter). river cannot post in these sections, so it is pointless to keep this thread open for his benefit. In any case, it seems very likely that he is simply trolling to keep the discussion going.

So, closed. And while we're at it, river is also warned for trolling.