What is the best band ever?

Status
Not open for further replies.
No excuse. Even if every other type of music fan is arrogant, no excuse for anyone to think Paige is the best guitarist. It'd be like thinking J. K. Rowling the greatest author of all time.

Even if you asked me to forget Trey there are a good 20 guitarists I could put ahead of Jimmy. And I do love Jimmy, and played in a Zeppelin cover band. But he's simply not that talented in any area. You could say you like hte music the most, but crowning Jimmy best guitarist makes no sense.

And sorry for the jackass rant, it's my frustration coming out.
 
I would like to also acknowledge that Deep Purple, The Doors, Cream and The Rolling Stoned, Led Zepplin as well as Jimi Hendrix were great rock bands.
 
Xerxes:
If only she could rip through the screen and kick your face in....Xerxy

Weezer is not emo. While they have been credited as influences by most 'emo' bands for 1996's 'pinkerton,' they are far from it.

Could you be a little more specific with what it is that you don't like about them? (curious)
I guess if alternative music is your thing there is nothing I can say to you.

Weezer and all these other punk bands- the Blink182's, Sum41's, Greendays and Linkinparks- all resemble the kind of people Dr. Lou would hang out with: prematurely angry and idle.
There is something in this type of music that sounds manufactured and false, would any of them be able to sit still for a sec and absorb the subtleties of Bach or Grieg?
Not saying "old music" is the mark of a good palate- you can find me bashing to Manson and I hate him- but music like Weezer seems careless.
It fluctuates between 2 or three different chords, chorus, 2 or three different chords, chorus, finale.
Easy to follow, easy to duplicate, easy to swallow.

Now something more striking even silly- Anal Cunts 'Art Fag' for example- or poetic and mellow in beauty as Emperor (when Faust was still drummer)- at least makes one stir.

Weezer is bubble gum.

And Tenacious D is for fluffy married men with three kids.
 
gendy, my sweet pooky :eek:

I was hoping for that response.

I guess if alternative music is your thing there is nothing I can say to you.
would any of them be able to sit still for a sec and absorb the subtleties of Bach or Grieg?


You might not have noticed, but the record that got them their 'emo' reputation- Pinkerton - was a rock opera based around Puccinis Madame Butterfly. This gets even better...

Its a little known fact that their followup record, 2001's The Green Album, was written based around Nietzsches idea of 'pure music' in N. Contra Wagner.


We owe this to Rivers Cuomo- Weezers very own deranged genius songwriter who fits your description of an intellectual musician. Currently, he is attending Harvard to finish off his degree in creative writing. He has a little website-> http://riverscuomo.com -> on which he lists one of his musical influences as your beloved bach ;)
ABBA, am Radio, Bach, Beach Boys, Beatles, Bee Gees, Beethoven, Billy Joel, Burt Bacharach, Chet Baker, Chopin, Dusty Springfield, Fate's Warning, France Gall, Francoise Hardy, Gregg Alexander, Jay Z, Jesus Christ Superstar, Joao Gilberto, Kate Bush, KISS, Les Miz, Metallica, Mozart, Neil Diamond, Nirvana, Notorious B.I.G., Oasis, Ozma, Prince, Puccini, Schubert, Schumann's "Dichterliebe", Stravinsky, Tchaikovsky, The Cure, Van Morrison, West Side Story

-Before writing the green album, Rivers spent a month living in a 1 room apartment under a busy LA intersection, in which he sealed off the windows with fiberglass, painted the walls black and did without a phone or electricity.

-For the upcoming album 5 (before going off to harvard this fall,) he sold all of his possesions, with the exception of a few comic books at a storage facility on the east coast, lost 15% of his body weight while medidating with a bunch of monks, and moved into Rick Rubins poolhouse. (most fans found this to be hilariously typical of him.) There's even a picture of Rivers indulging in the Tao te Ching and a diet coke while his bandmates practice a few demos..

All done for the creative process. And I won't even get into the 3 binder encyplodia he wrote on this history of pop..

My point is -Aside from a few catchy Green Day songs,- I've never been into 90's 'alternative'. Weezer is truly a different band. They have a kind of shell with 'superficial music,' and 'passing trend' written on it. But there's an amazing group of musicians underneath with actual chemistry.

Maybe you drew these conclusions from the keep fishin video where, on the surface, they dance around with the muppets like a bunch of retards. In reality, thats just them having fun, mocking the teeny bandwagon fans whom they affectionately refer to as 'Little Bitches' OTR.

It fluctuates between 2 or three different chords, chorus, 2 or three different chords, chorus, finale.
Easy to follow, easy to duplicate, easy to swallow.
Hmm..You know, Weezer is mostly power chords, but I can tell you for a fact theres a lot more to music than how many keys you can hit- Melody, crescendo, pitch, distortion, creative use of instruments (ie moog.) Pinkerton has some pretty awesome and diverse guitar work on it... 'Across the sea', The good life, falling for you.

When you get down to it, the simplicity is more of an asset; Anybody can play, recognize and enjoy Weezer songs with a simple acoustic guitar or a full instrumental set (There has ev been a classical music cover album http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/t...=sr_1_15/103-8275928-0522229?v=glance&s=music)

Weezer is bubble gum.
I would have to agree for most the music they produced after the summer songs of 2000 (a year after rivers moved away from the intersection.) and before the recent album 5 work (when Rivers began meditating again). Some of their best material is still unreleased, or unavailable to the average listener (you have to know where to get it.)

And Tenacious D is for fluffy married men with three kids.

Agreed, along with the Dr Lou statement.
 
I was going to say the Beatles, then realised I would be voting for the song-writing of Lennon and McCartney and the production of George Martin, not for a band.
So it has to Queen. Great individual talent; tremendous in combination; brilliant live performance in general, and the greatest ever live performance of any band, at Live Aid, where Freddy Mercury took the definition of charisma, ripped it apart and re-assembled it across time and space in an unforgettable fashion.
 
Nebula said:
And fuck the beatles. THey were luck. They weren't that innovative, they just happened to fill a gaping void at the right time.

Time to resume the medication.
 
The reason I like the D so much is that at some point in the last few years, all music basically became completely ridiculous to me. I started seeing it all as a spoof of itself. It started to annoy me. "alternative rock" has started to seem all the same and I've heard every "classic rock" song so many times I could hurl.

The D personifies my annoyance and re-charged me in a way. As far as I'm concerned, they really embody what a joke the entire rock genera can be viewed as, depending on your perspective..

Pink Floyd however, was alway my favorite band in the universe because David Gilmour is freakin dripping with soul.
 
Dark side of the moon is brilliant LP

I´m with you Wes somewhat, older I get more older music I seek, havent bought anything new stuff in ages. There are good songs here and there in new stuff too, but rarely not worth for spending money.
 
space-falcon* said:
the best of pink floyd has to be time, money, and another brick in the wall

For whatever reason, Meddle, Wish You Were Here and Animals are my favorite floyd albums. I love dark side and the wall, but the others are more uhm... I don't know. Maybe it's just that dark side and the wall were over-commercialized.
 
Well, i would have really hard times if forced to pick between Wish you were here & Dark side of the moon...
 
Most complete Floyd album from start to finish is probably Wish You Were Here, although Dark Side Of The Moon I believe still likely holds the record for longest run on Billboard's Top 100. Meddle was awful good though (particularly if you were doing a little Purple Haze at the time), as well as Obscured By Clouds, although I'm still partial to Piper At The Gates Of Dawn, their '67 debut, when Syd Barrett, who Gilmour later replaced, was still the significant influence in the group. Best overall song though by Floyd...'Comfortably Numb'.
 
My favorite band of all time is Incubus. You could take out any member of the band, have him start his own band and it would be awesome. I particularly like their older albums, Fungus Amongus, Enjoy Incubus and SCIENCE. What I love about them is their ability to play any kind of music (Jazz, soul, funk, rock, metal, etc...) and not sound contrived.
 
Oh Sarge, I never meant for all those things to be representing you. I think you misread.

Or I mis-wrote, more likely.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top