Unbiased Poll for Proud_Muslim

Should Proud_Muslim be banned?

  • Yes.

    Votes: 35 41.7%

  • No.

    Votes: 49 58.3%
  • Total voters
    84
Status
Not open for further replies.
I' m not desperate about it either, a poll was presented, I know the guy did not follow the rules often and so I voted based of logic alone.

As for a comment about me being a loser and a idiot: it looks like your the one that has emotion about this, so much so that you can't even write a valid argument.
 
No not a valid argument in the eyes of logic and philosophical reasoning. Look up ad hominem: Its not valid to say someone is wrong because of traits they might or might not have, You can only say someone is wrong based of evidence against their argument not character.
 
Come now children, lets play nicely. The issue at hand is this; should PM be banned? If he were banned then we wouldn't have the discussions we have now about him or his threads. We can all learn either from him or each other by introducing new ideas and thoughts that other wise would never be born (if he were to be banned). All we have to do then is to simply take it or leave it. Okay? :)
 
The arguemtn against Proud Muslim's banning seems to be fairly weak, in that it consists only of "we all break the rules sometimes."

I agree.
Once in awhile we all make posts trying to push our ideas on others and not even attempting to actually converse with anybody.
Once in awhile some of us threaten the lives of someone/group (although usually jokingly... I hope).
Once in awhile some of us post the same basic thing over an over.
Once in awhile we all jump to unfounded conclusions.
Once in awhile we are all assholes.

The key issue here is 'once in awhile...'

Proud Muslim seems to be much more consistent in his lack of conversation then anyone else on this board. At no time have I actually seen this person hold a discussion with anyone. For PM, this board appears to only to serve as a place for him to advertise his ideas.

He shouldn't be banned because he breaks 'community standards'/rules.
He should be banned because he does so consistently.
 
I' m not desperate about it either, a poll was presented, I know the guy did not follow the rules often and so I voted based of logic alone.
Click to expand...
Do you do everything on the basis of 'logic alone' Fetus?

Your sex life must suck.
Mind you, where's the logic in sucking?

Dee Cee
 
Even a broken clock is right twice a day. He definitely presents a contrasting view.
 
You don't even take this seriously.

All this guy does is arrogantly espouse his own agenda.

If you need him to remind you that you're normal, you're probably not normal.
 
"All this guy does is arrogantly espouse his own agenda."
That is just too funny. Ban on the grounds of being too arrogant and opinionated. I arrogantly assert your stupidity!
 
thefountainhed said:
That is just too funny. Ban on the grounds of being too arrogant and opinionated.
Click to expand...

Oh, come on, man. We can all be arrogant and impervious to persuasion sometimes, but PM is consistent in both that and his dragging 'his agenda' into every single thread in which he posts.

Has he ever written a post that did not refer to Allah, Mohammed, or Zionists/Jews?
 
DeeCee,

I use logic on arguments mainly…

My sex life sometimes involves bondage (well just that on time, but I'm trying to get a girl friend willing to do that again.)
 
No not a valid argument in the eyes of logic and philosophical reasoning. Look up ad hominem: Its not valid to say someone is wrong because of traits they might or might not have, You can only say someone is wrong based of evidence against their argument not character.
Click to expand...

Based on your argument, which indicated your desperation to ban PM, godknows why, i have asserted my assumption. PM can express his own point of view if he wants to. Why're you so eager to shut him down?
Hahahaha. Philosophical reasoning in a ban PM thread?
 
You can't ban someone because you disagree with their ideology or beliefs. Sure he can be a pain in the butt sometimes (aren't we all?), but think of all the others who are just like him, if not worse. Hell, I can think of several others who deserve the boot more than PM. He has his (many) ranting moments, but he also questions the status quo and he's come out with some good points which have led to many many discussions on here.

If he breaks the fundamental (bannable) rules of the forum, then yeah, he should be banned, like all of us if we also break the rules. However just banning him because he's in your face about his beliefs is wrong. If he's that bothersome to you, it's easy. Put him on ignore.
 
Ok so he rants about his views, big deal so do others, you just gotta learn whats a valid point, and whats just bias crap, he wont be a problem once you can distinguish between the good points he makes, and his pointless rants against others, besides if you ban him he'll come back with a different name, why bother?
 
If his religon is the lens which he views his life through it is still a rational if extreme view point. As long as he does not break the rules, we should allow him a voice.
 
laughing weasel and others,

But he did break the rules repeatedly that’s why we want him banished, not because he's a Muslim fanatic.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top