Tach:
JamesR has made the
claim that
this file contains errors. Despite repeated challenges, he has avoided pointing out the errors. I challenge JamesR to prove his claim or to withdraw it.
You posted this as a Debate thread in the Formal Debates subforum.
I have not agreed to such a Formal Debate, and there has been no Proposal that we have such a debate.
Please read the thread in the Formal Debates forum titled "How the Formal Debates forum works", since it seems you are unfamiliar with the rules here.
Secondly, I notice that you titled your thread "Rebuttal of JamesR claims". But I have made no claims (other than that your claim is wrong). The current Debate proposal is about YOUR claim that "I can prove this quite easily, there is no Doppler shift of a moving mirror."
If you think that your file proves your claim, then you will have no trouble agreeing to debate me on the topic flagged in the current thread. And yet, you seem to be doing everything in your power to avoid debating me formally on a topic which can include discussion of your file. In any Formal debate on the current topic, you may present your file as "proof" of your claim that there is no Doppler shift from a moving mirror, ever. I will then have to rebut that claim.
This would seem on its face to be no stretch at all, since you previously presented the same file to Pete in another thread, asserting that it proved your claim that "there is no Doppler shift of a moving mirror".
So, why are you so keen to avoid debating me here? If you were right in your assertion against Pete, you'll be equally right making the same assertion against me.
There are several possibilities:
(a) you have read some of my other debates and are afraid of my debating prowess, and thus you are reticent to take me on.
(b) you know your claim was false and overblown and you know you would lose any debate on the topic.
(c) you think that by stretching out the discussion of the debate for long enough, you can avoid ever actually debating the topic. You hope that people will forget this latest in a long string of errors of yours.
---
I'll give it another day or so to see if you will wimp out or not.
My bet is that you will continue to avoid debating me at all costs, because
you know you're wrong again.