Moderator note: this thread is for on-topic discussion of Max Tegmark's "Mathematical Universe" hypothesis.

Some of the posts here can also be found in the following thread, which is more for discussion of a certain member's obsession with Tegmark's hypothesis:

---

Write4U:

In one of your many threads about Tegmark and his MUP (mathematical universe hypothesis), I linked the following articles:

https://www.math.columbia.edu/~woit/wordpress/?p=6551&cpage=2

https://www.science20.com/rationally_speaking/mathematical_universe_i_ain’t_convinced-127841

There are substantive objections to Tegmark's hypothesis here. Bear in mind, by the way, that the fact that I previously mentioned these makes a lie of your claim that I only ever make

How do you respond to the objections raised? You ignored these, last time.

For the historical context of our previous discussion about this, see the following thread. The link is to where I first pointed you to these review articles, back in December 2020:

https://www.sciforums.com/threads/t...ematical-construct.163837/page-2#post-3657387

Some of the posts here can also be found in the following thread, which is more for discussion of a certain member's obsession with Tegmark's hypothesis:

__We need more discussion of Tegmark's mathematical universe hypothesis__---

Write4U:

In one of your many threads about Tegmark and his MUP (mathematical universe hypothesis), I linked the following articles:

https://www.math.columbia.edu/~woit/wordpress/?p=6551&cpage=2

https://www.science20.com/rationally_speaking/mathematical_universe_i_ain’t_convinced-127841

There are substantive objections to Tegmark's hypothesis here. Bear in mind, by the way, that the fact that I previously mentioned these makes a lie of your claim that I only ever make

*ad hominem*attacks on you and never provide specific scientific objections to what you post.How do you respond to the objections raised? You ignored these, last time.

For the historical context of our previous discussion about this, see the following thread. The link is to where I first pointed you to these review articles, back in December 2020:

https://www.sciforums.com/threads/t...ematical-construct.163837/page-2#post-3657387

Last edited: