How much would you charge to teach me some "personality and attitude"?
Ha! You see, that's the problem right there. I speak of personality and attitude and you immediately think that I'm saying that I have it whereas you don't. On the contrary, you have personality and attitude and I cannot teach you mine. All I can do is judge your personality and your attitude from the posts that I have seen you make and I have done so.
As I say, I have become a bit acerbic in my old age and this is none of my business and I'll just butt the fuck out. But what you don't realise is that while you are cruising about feasting on the wit of this place, you are a symptom of it's pitfalls. Instead of 'intelligent conversation' we get 'witty chat' (or not so witty at times, not saying that you aren't witty, but there are those who are not, myself included... perhaps...). Granted this thread is not exactly intellectual and as long as you keep your chat to chatty threads I shouldn't bitch. And perhaps I'm judging a bit too soon and too harshly. But, I'm feeling a bit grumpy over the slump this place is in lately and am taking it out on you (and a couple others here and there.) Normally, I'm not so acerbic, but the romance I once felt for this place is dying and it's somewhat sad and embittering.
Anyway, back to topic: I agree with Gendanken, I don't like the photoshop quality. Can you use painter? While it doesn't have quite the same feel as real paint and canvas, it comes close. And it's getting better.
Also, to Gendanken, I recall that these pictures (at least one of them, the one with the upraised glass) began as a hand-drawn picture. So, it's not all copy-and-paste. I suspect that this is the 'look' that it is supposed to have. Somewhat hokey. Like South Park.
As to which is best... Hmmm. I don't really like them. But, if I had to choose, I'd go with number two because of the tree. I like the textures. It's a bit simple yet, but it is more alive than the others. More interesting. But, the shadows are all kinda... hmm.
Edit: The grass is nice in #2 as well. The grass and the trees are the best things you have there.