DaveC426913
Valued Senior Member
Have you allowed for the possibility that the problem is ambiguously defined? Perhaps the answer is right but not what you think the question is.Neither got it right.
Have you allowed for the possibility that the problem is ambiguously defined? Perhaps the answer is right but not what you think the question is.Neither got it right.
Geometry problem: Semi-circle inside triangle: Triangle with known length sides a, b, c where a is the longest. Place inside the triangle a semi-circle with entire diameter resting on side a, which is horizontal. The arc of the semicircle is maximum possible inside the triangle.
Known - triangle dimensions. Unknown r (semi-circle arc radius) and x (distance along a from left end of a to center of diameter). Find equations for r and x In terms of all possible triangles.
----------------------------------------------------------
Above is my latest attempt ro check AI. It was submitted to both BingChat and Chatgpt. Neither got it right.
Have you tried to illustrate it with a picture? Were these AIs trained in geometry?
If you asked the same question from a human scholar in literature, would he/she get it right?
AIs must be trained in the scientific discipline, just like people. If it takes 6 years to earn a doctorate in a specific discipline, allow an AI 6 years to earn its doctorate and then compare its knowledge and processing speed to its human counterpart.
GPT is not brute computing power. It is a learning system that must be taught just like a human mind.
I think what I keep coming up against is how can you tell it's the AI that is failing?The description should allow a picture making by AI.
Is that any different for humans?The description should allow a picture making by AI. Solving the problem requires high school math including analytic geometry. I would hope AI can do better than a literature scholar.
Right. If you look up the word for "two mathematical lines that are on top of each other" you get "coincident".AI (Skype) appears to see a meaning problem. 'diameter restin on a' was interpreted to mean coincidence, which was NOT the intent. Does 'rest' have such a precise math. definition? I Tried the question with 'placed' instead of 'resting'. BingChat seemed to understand it, but could not come up with an an answer. ChatGPT just gave up.
Can AI produce like the Beatles; https://www.cnn.com/2023/06/13/entertainment/paul-mccartney-ai-beatles-song/index.html