Star Wars vs Star Trek

Which universe would win?

  • Star Trek

    Votes: 227 35.5%
  • Star Wars

    Votes: 268 41.9%
  • Spaceballs

    Votes: 47 7.3%
  • Farscape

    Votes: 12 1.9%
  • Dune

    Votes: 50 7.8%
  • Stargate

    Votes: 36 5.6%

  • Total voters
    640
Status
Not open for further replies.
The Centerpoint can let Star Wars use a good strategy, they can use a fleet of small frigates controlled by droids, and droid controlled old and battle scared Accalmators I-class to draw the attention of UFP ships then use Centerpoint to eliminate the decoy fleet as well as the UFP fleet. It would be a nice way to reuse, reduce and maybe recycle :). See, the Republic think about the environment. They use the 3Rs in a new way that helps the war effort. Star Wars is so environmentally friendly. I somehow think that the UFP won't like that deal at all.

Centerpoint? YOU ARE JOKING right? The station that ONLY a handful of people can use? The same CENTERPOINT STATION that was obliterated and CANNOT be rebuilt because nobody knows how?

Seeing that the balance of power would tip greatly in favor of anyone who possessed its enormous destructive force, Grand Master Luke Skywalker and the New Jedi Order carried out a raid upon the station in order to finally destroy it. Jedi Master Kyp Durron led the raid, with Toval Seyah, a Galactic Alliance scientist and former spy who had worked on the station in the past. Seyah was able to modify Centerpoint's galactic data reserves in such a way that all coordinates in the galaxy were altered to become those of the station.

During the pitched battle between Confederation and Galactic Alliance forces, a technician named Rikel who had lost his wife on the galactic capital of Coruscant to the Galactic Alliance Guard was left in charge of the station's fire controls. He set the coordinates to target Coruscant itself. When he fired Centerpoint, the massive construction targeted itself. The resulting gravitic pulse detonated the station, wiping all traces of the enigmatic structure from the system, killing all on board, and destroying countless vessels in its blast radius.

From Wookiepedia...
 
Also, the sun crusher is WEAKER than the Intrepid class light cruiser from Star Trek:

To redeem himself, Kyp had to destroy the Sun Crusher. He destroyed it during the Battle of the Maw Installation, where it was sucked into one of the Maw's black holes along with the Death Star prototype. Kyp survived by escaping in a message pod, though he suffered serious injuries in the process.

Voyager, an Intrepid class starship, has escaped more than one black hole... AFTER passing thru the Event Horizon...
 
An asteroid never took out a SD, it simply disrupted its communications. They stayed in the asteroid field for days. They never thought a Starfighter posed a threat. It is an exhaust port, it supposed to let matter out. They have particle shields too. Katarn armor is armor wore by the Republic Commandos, only a laser cannon that hit it square on the chest and even put a dent in it, but it is not as good as Mandalorian armor. They all have reasons why it is never shown on the movies, for example we never saw a Republic Commando on the screen so we never got to see their armor. Commandos can snipe very well. You are using Clone Wars as reference umm. Ever saw the Malevolence series, yeah that ion cannon got to do the job. There is no turbolaser that ever fired on endor, those are light laser cannons. Katarn armor probably have enough power to power a personal shield generator, and besides commandos can fight well even if there is a 40 kilo pack on his back ( without tech help ). Katarn armor can withstand hard vacuum, so air is no problem. And plus the Republic might let the commandos try out Alpha Red on the UFP.
 
Simple...

1) There is a MAX SPEED you can send any wave based medium thru a vacuum.

2) SD's are very weak in that FIGHTER CRAFT pose a serious threat. It'd be like a P-51 Mustang downing a WW2 Battleship with it's machine guns...

1) HoloNet is transmitted through Hyperspace
2) No it is no threat to a SD unless there is a capital ship backing it up and the shields are already pretty much offline.
 
Droids that run ships into planets and have trouble hitting STATIONARY targets? (reference, Clone Wars)
They didn't run it into a moon, Skywalker hacked the computer. I think the seps will be low on supplies, because the commandos and ARCs keep sabotaging the factories and supplies. Plus the Republic Navy will not let seps transport supplies without a fight.
 

Again,an asteroid never destroyed a SD, it damaged it, and they were in that asteroid field for days. They kill the admirals, because they have better ones. It is not like they didn't try to make the HTL smaller. I said it would be EASIER to pack more firepower into a larger ship. They have starfighters to the chasing.
 
Centerpoint? YOU ARE JOKING right? The station that ONLY a handful of people can use? The same CENTERPOINT STATION that was obliterated and CANNOT be rebuilt because nobody knows how?

Seeing that the balance of power would tip greatly in favor of anyone who possessed its enormous destructive force, Grand Master Luke Skywalker and the New Jedi Order carried out a raid upon the station in order to finally destroy it. Jedi Master Kyp Durron led the raid, with Toval Seyah, a Galactic Alliance scientist and former spy who had worked on the station in the past. Seyah was able to modify Centerpoint's galactic data reserves in such a way that all coordinates in the galaxy were altered to become those of the station.

During the pitched battle between Confederation and Galactic Alliance forces, a technician named Rikel who had lost his wife on the galactic capital of Coruscant to the Galactic Alliance Guard was left in charge of the station's fire controls. He set the coordinates to target Coruscant itself. When he fired Centerpoint, the massive construction targeted itself. The resulting gravitic pulse detonated the station, wiping all traces of the enigmatic structure from the system, killing all on board, and destroying countless vessels in its blast radius.

From Wookiepedia...

Only a handful of people can use, because of the AI won't perimit other people it is not like they didn't know how. They can trick the Centerpoint into thinking Anakin Solo is using it. They had to destroy it from the inside, or they would of just pounded it to dust.
 
An asteroid never took out a SD, it simply disrupted its communications. They stayed in the asteroid field for days. They never thought a Starfighter posed a threat. It is an exhaust port, it supposed to let matter out. They have particle shields too. Katarn armor is armor wore by the Republic Commandos, only a laser cannon that hit it square on the chest and even put a dent in it, but it is not as good as Mandalorian armor. They all have reasons why it is never shown on the movies, for example we never saw a Republic Commando on the screen so we never got to see their armor. Commandos can snipe very well. You are using Clone Wars as reference umm. Ever saw the Malevolence series, yeah that ion cannon got to do the job. There is no turbolaser that ever fired on endor, those are light laser cannons. Katarn armor probably have enough power to power a personal shield generator, and besides commandos can fight well even if there is a 40 kilo pack on his back ( without tech help ). Katarn armor can withstand hard vacuum, so air is no problem. And plus the Republic might let the commandos try out Alpha Red on the UFP.

Wrong. The bridge is GONE. Caput! The proof is in the pudding:

IMAPCT
HDC5-bta02sm.jpg


AFTERMATH
HDC5-bta05sm.jpg



Quite obvious that the bridge is GONE...
 
An asteroid never took out a SD, it simply disrupted its communications. They stayed in the asteroid field for days. They never thought a Starfighter posed a threat. It is an exhaust port, it supposed to let matter out. They have particle shields too. Katarn armor is armor wore by the Republic Commandos, only a laser cannon that hit it square on the chest and even put a dent in it, but it is not as good as Mandalorian armor. They all have reasons why it is never shown on the movies, for example we never saw a Republic Commando on the screen so we never got to see their armor. Commandos can snipe very well. You are using Clone Wars as reference umm. Ever saw the Malevolence series, yeah that ion cannon got to do the job. Against a SW ship and it's pitiful shields, yes... There is no turbolaser that ever fired on endor, those are light laser cannons. blaster cannon, turbolaser, whatever... stands to reason the blaster CANNON would be more powerful, no?Katarn armor probably have enough power to power a personal shield generator, and besides commandos can fight well even if there is a 40 kilo pack on his back ( without tech help ).And Data can fight well while carrying a 200 kilo PERSON on his back... Katarn armor can withstand hard vacuum, so air is no problem. And plus the Republic might let the commandos try out Alpha Red on the UFP. Alpha Red would have ZERO effect on the UFP... it killed VONG

In red...
 
It is the Sun Crusher come on. Ha! you are using comics that proves your point, and say everything else is non-canon, what a hypocrite.

I dont' say it's NON cannon, I said LESSER cannon. SunCrusher is never in the movies, thus comics are as cannon as the books... duh?
 
Also, the sun crusher is WEAKER than the Intrepid class light cruiser from Star Trek:

To redeem himself, Kyp had to destroy the Sun Crusher. He destroyed it during the Battle of the Maw Installation, where it was sucked into one of the Maw's black holes along with the Death Star prototype. Kyp survived by escaping in a message pod, though he suffered serious injuries in the process.

Voyager, an Intrepid class starship, has escaped more than one black hole... AFTER passing thru the Event Horizon...

It supposed to be a prototype. Plus if they didn't destroy it they are not crazy enough to go get it back.
 
1) HoloNet is transmitted through Hyperspace
2) No it is no threat to a SD unless there is a capital ship backing it up and the shields are already pretty much offline.

1) uhhuh... yet hyperspace requires a hyperdrive... tell me... does a radio wave have a hyperdrive?

2) Uhm... then why do they bother LAUNCHING X-Wings and Y-Wings vs SD's?
 
They didn't run it into a moon, Skywalker hacked the computer. I think the seps will be low on supplies, because the commandos and ARCs keep sabotaging the factories and supplies. Plus the Republic Navy will not let seps transport supplies without a fight.

OKay... let me get this straight:

Yes, anikin hacked it... the droids were STUPID ENOUGH to not CHECK to see if repairs had been completed... then were DUMB enough to go ahead and just GO... and THEN were unable to fix the bloody thing? REALLY NOW?
 
It supposed to be a prototype. Plus if they didn't destroy it they are not crazy enough to go get it back.

What are you getting at? It's GONE... POOF. can't use it now... buh bye... just like the DS1 and 2... and the Executioner... and other super-weapons.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top