Star Wars vs Star Trek

Okay first of all Dune technology is barely more advanced than 21st century technology in most cases. Second a few fremen on the Death Star? Well only if they survived their planet being blown to dust in less than ten seconds or warning. As for Boba Fett, he has hunted down and fought some of the remaining Jedi and defeated them in hand to hand combat. He has fought Noghri and Wookies and won. Even Stilgar would be outclassed. As for Paul or young Leto, Luke would walk all over them after what I have read.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide all adverts.

"The two clashed briefly, and though Vader's skills with the lightsaber greatly out-matched Fett's, Boba's brute force, ferocity, and pure determination allowed him to hold his own."

Please Register or Log in to view the hidden image!

 

Log in or Sign up to hide all adverts.

just two words pure and simple but overruling all : STAR WARS

 

Log in or Sign up to hide all adverts.

femen are bred fighter melee ranged doesn't matter they own. and whats that about dune's tech not being much high than are own you have an inflated veiw of our technogly cause we have nowhere near the tech in dune and why would they blow up dune its just a sandy ball it would be veiwed as no threat right up until fremin started gutting people we are talking about people who can see the bloody future they would kick the crap out of star wars people

 

IG-100 MagnaGuard, Wookiee, jedi, sith, Noghri, Emperor's Royal Guard, Grievous, Durge, Vader, Luke, Obi-wan, Yoda, Maul, Mandalorians, boba, Malak, Reven, Darth Nihilus, Mace, and the the Epmeror just to name a few that could beat your fremen

 

and you would never get the chance to get into the DS the Imp fleet would just blast your out of date ships into dust and why not blow up dune you say...the empire would do it for fun, or maybe they would send down hundreds of thousands of Stormtroopers and walkers and if that fails Base Delta Zero bye bye Dune

 

its just a simple fact SW has more numbers more powerful weapons better ships and the Mandos are equal or better than fremen. now i'm not saying Dune is bad its just facts that SW would win. the ground battles would be good but SW has the numbers and firepower to win

 

Fremen are bred survivors and part of that is combat, but they don't have nearly the same combat capabilities of Noghri, Wookies, or Vong. And even those groups have respect for Stormtroopers.

Let's see most powewrful weapon in Dune is a nuclear weapon. Same as 21st century earth. Some of their technologies are a century ahead, but they have ZERO computer technology, just Mentats. Theirs shields have horrible reactions to laser weaponry and can't stop most melee weaponry.

Are you kidding the Imperial captial world. Gone as an example.

They can see only so far, and even then it can be confused easily. Besides would Leto believe what he saw of a super weapon destroying Dune until he was dead and at the pearly gates?

 

And BTW nuclear weapons are not considerd superweapons in SW

 

TIE's... Ties... OH! Those unshielded pieces of junk you call fighters and bombers?

ANd As for your Asteroid thing- if they could do that, then why was an ISD stopped from pursuing the Falcon by a few medium sized asteroids?

And your "paratroopers" would be sizzled by automated defense grids.

Be prepared to loose on a full frontal Assault Vasago- you would simply run straight for earth, taking small losses along the way until you have no force left. Trek would be relentless and unyeilding!

 

Aren't like, 90% of those DEAD?

Whoo, what are they going to do, haunt us?

Keep it to the LIVING please!

 

They may not have ray Shielding, but they do have particle shielding.

Some of those asteroids were 800 meters plus.

Provided your defense systems weren't already bloown offline and could penetrate the ECM

You must be kidding there would a grand total of a five minute warning between hyperspace breakout and the attack on Earth. You can't stop the vessels in Hyperspace, can't detect them and certainly can't travel as fast as them. And one ISD is equal to 976 Galaxy class starships (more if we go by canon 25 isoton firepower)

 

Then I choose to use the Black sun and the Empire during a new hope up until the ROTJ and yes the black sun did work for the empire

 

You want something that can go Hand to Hand vs a Wookie?

Take Calhoun, a Xenexian. Take a wookie, double it's strength, give it armor plated skin, and that's a xenexian.

You want to defeat wookies? Use a flamethrower- burn bitch!

 

And after ROTJ what happened to them?

If at the end of the CURRENT TIMELINE (books or what have you- the latest canon source of timeline) if it is presumed lost, destroyed, etc, don't use it.

You don't see us bringing back some of the super-ships. Otherwise we'd simply dyson sphere your ass

Please Register or Log in to view the hidden image!

Big big sphere made of neodinium... good luck breaking through that.

 

force storm

 

Actually Mandalorians and Wookies are still alive as are Jedi and Sith, Luke and IG-88, Magnaguards can be rebuilt. Of course he forgot Noghri, who on on one can match most wookies, despite the Wookies superior strength and ability to shrug off damage.

 

Scott cant Force storm destroy whole fleets or am i thinking of something diffrent?

 

the fremin also can alter their oppents mind and your forgeting personal shields no sand worms around them the fremin would have shields so it would either stop there weapons or a lightsaber might react like a laser to the sheild and boom huge explosion so either the fremin wins or everyone loses

 

they have computers they just don't think for themselves you don't seem to be up to date on your dune lore