A colour without its own wave length

How is this different than the case of yellow? We don't have yellow sensors either.
Aren't they the same in that they are both combinations and isn't the only reason you don't see
magenta in a rainbow because red and blue don't appear near each other?

The green sensors in your eyes are the most sensitive, the blue is the least sensitive with red in the middle regarding sensitivity. Look at a green laser at night compared to a red laser and then a blue laser. Green appears much brighter.

Magenta has a wavelength in the same sense that yellow has one. They are both combinations so I don't think there is anything unique about Magenta other than our eyes are less sensitive to red and blue when compared to red and green.
 
Last edited:
Seattle said:
How is this different than the case of yellow? We don't have yellow sensors either.
Aren't they the same in that they are both combinations and isn't the only reason you don't see
magenta in a rainbow because red and blue don't appear near each other?

The green sensors in your eyes are the most sensitive, the blue is the least sensitive with red in the middle regarding sensitivity. Look at a green laser at night compared to a red laser and then a blue laser. Green appears much brighter.

Magenta has a wavelength in the same sense that yellow has one. They are both combinations so I don't think there is anything unique about Magenta other than our eyes are less sensitive to red and blue when compared to red and green.
Click to expand...
No, there is yellow light in the spectrum, e.g. the sodium D lines are in the yellow region.

We don't have yellow frequency receptors: yellow light excites both our red and green receptors, which we interpret as yellow. But there are no magenta lines or bands in the spectrum of light.
 
Interesting that magenta is one of the primary colors used in 4 color process printing. Magenta, Cyan, Yellow and Black.
 
Pinball1970 said:
Colour is a dynamical system not just a wavelength.
In terms of
Colours are made up of different wavelengths interacting with cells in our retina if you are talking about pigments and dyes.
Click to expand...

Colours are made up of different wavelengths interacting with cells

So does that change the fact that Magenta has no wave length of its own?

:)
 
Michael 345 said:
Colours are made up of different wavelengths interacting with cells

So does that change the fact that Magenta has no wave length of its own?

:)
Click to expand...
No. As previously explained, the colour magenta is produced by a mix of wavelengths from the red end of the spectrum and from the blue end, which stimulate both our red and blue receptors and thus creating the sensation in our brains of magenta.
 
The best magenta is a mix of red and violet.

The absolute best is to use two prisms in a shaft of sunlight. Tilt the prisms until the red of one mixes with the violet of the other.

FANTASTIC!
 
Yes Dave, there is a worst magenta, just add brown and it becomes the color of mud.

Yes Dave, there is a scale, color grading like for gemstone amethyst, consisting of hue, tone, saturation, etc.
 
el es said:
Yes Dave, there is a worst magenta, just add brown and it becomes the color of mud.

Yes Dave, there is a scale, color grading like for gemstone amethyst, consisting of hue, tone, saturation, etc.
Click to expand...
That’s fair. How does rosaniline compare with the spectral mix approach? Do you know?
I found this colour wheel : https://i.pinimg.com/originals/48/bc/72/48bc72c32dfb9274c898d2ae94a5e1aa.png

which includes a tone called “aniline” which could be it. It can’t mean actual aniline as that is colourless, so I guess it refers to an aniline dye. Magenta is shown as being a bit redder. Amethyst is also shown.

P.S. in fact “aniline” on that colour wheel might instead refer to Perkin’s original aniline dye, which became known as mauveine, I think. Rosaniline seems to be a bit pinker, so indeed more magenta-like.
 
exchemist said:
That’s fair. How does rosaniline compare with the spectral mix approach? Do you know?
I found this colour wheel : https://i.pinimg.com/originals/48/bc/72/48bc72c32dfb9274c898d2ae94a5e1aa.png

which includes a tone called “aniline” which could be it. It can’t mean actual aniline as that is colourless, so I guess it refers to an aniline dye. Magenta is shown as being a bit redder. Amethyst is also shown.

P.S. in fact “aniline” on that colour wheel might instead refer to Perkin’s original aniline dye, which became known as mauveine, I think. Rosaniline seems to be a bit pinker, so indeed more magenta-like.
Click to expand...
I worked for Clayton Aniline for 10 years, dyes and chemicals. They were actually CIBA by the time I got there. Happy memories.
 
Pinball1970 said:
I worked for Clayton Aniline for 10 years, dyes and chemicals. They were actually CIBA by the time I got there. Happy memories.
Click to expand...
Really. In what capacity?

My first girlfriend’s dad was MD of their operation near Horsham. Back in the 1970s.
 
exchemist said:
Really. In what capacity?

My first girlfriend’s dad was MD of their operation near Horsham. Back in the 1970s.
Click to expand...
They sold dyes and chemicals and the techs (us) provided formulations to apply them.
So recipes and a dye profile to achieve a colour or an application to achieve an "effect"

Our customers were the UK dye houses, sadly they have mainly moved abroad now.
Or rather the clients that bought from those dye houses use producers abroad now.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top