Does rebirth exist ?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Seriously?

I mean, are you serious?

Reproduction is proven. Reincarnation is not. How do you propose we test this theory? I mean, you couldn't just kill something and expect it to be reborn immediately. I'm sure there would be a waiting list. No cutting in line. You know. Unless you're the son of a god or something, then I suppose you get special treatment.

But no. I really don't think it exists. If it does, I really don't think you'll get an answer here. At least, not one that would lend credibility to the theory.
 
original said:
Seriously?

I mean, are you serious?

Reproduction is proven. Reincarnation is not. How do you propose we test this theory? I mean, you couldn't just kill something and expect it to be reborn immediately. I'm sure there would be a waiting list. No cutting in line. You know. Unless you're the son of a god or something, then I suppose you get special treatment.

But no. I really don't think it exists. If it does, I really don't think you'll get an answer here. At least, not one that would lend credibility to the theory.
Click to expand...


apparently dragon just proved you wrong .

peace.
 
Yes, rebirth exists....the many-minds interpretation is true, this is just our own personal reality/universe/space-time, after death you simply enter into a deep-sleep like state then into an entirely new universe....

If Quantum Immortality is true, there CANNOT be any type of death.....but Quantum Immortality is only true to a certain extent, although its true that you can never not-exist, you can still die, at what we call death you enter into a new reality...
 
Intuition, instinct and intelligence are proof of reincarnation, you just don´t see it, how we learn from past lifes.
The thing is that your mind creates a barrier, and it does not show you images thay may disturb you. It is the same mechanism of a trauma, the mind blocks the trauma, and makes you forget because otherwise you would be disturbed by it. Same happens with past lifes, your brain does not show you the stuff you cannot handle.
We first got to stop judging others, and stop judging ourselves. If we manage to do this from our hearts, past life memories are going to start flowing throw your mind, because your brain will determine you are ready for it.

An easier way is hipnosis, they even make you speak in your past lifes tongues you know.

So yeah, hipnosis is a proof of past lifes.
 
plakhapate said:
If rebirth exist, is it possible to prove ?

Share your knowledge and experience if any.

P.J.LAKHAPATE
plakhapate@rediffmail.com
Click to expand...

Of course rebirth exists.
An animal dies, its atoms mix with the rest of the planet, new animal is born from the same atoms, etc, ad infinitum.
So our planet is constantly giving rebirth.

The atoms of this planet are largely the same as when the planet formed roughly 4billion years ago.
 
in some part of the multi-verse I'm being born in relative time now yust like I'm proberly dieng somewhere and I care surprisenly little...
 
Posted by Avatar
An animal dies, its atoms mix with the rest of the planet, new animal is born from the same atoms, etc, ad infinitum.
So our planet is constantly giving rebirth.
Click to expand...

That's the only respectable answer thus far. I agree that this is how the cycle of life perpetuates itself. But they are not the exact same atoms. They break down or bond with other elements. The atoms of my decomposing body are not going to become a newborn human child.
 
No, but some of them might. And there are no exact atoms of the body, I meant exact atoms from which everything else is made.
Every time I inhale, eat and the like my body acquires new atoms,
and through sweat, etc., I lose atoms.
On an atomic level, imho, there's no real strict border between the body and the rest of the environment.
 
Search for Dr.Ian Stevenson on the web and read his articles.
I'm still a skeptic to your question though, but am open to any new facts on the issue.
 
I can give you two proofs...

1. The Perfect Irrefutable Proof: YOUR logic says "before I was born, I didn't exist", and yet somehow you started existing. So if you become non-existent when you die, the Perfect Logic says that you have to start existing again.

2. The Idiot Proof: if the universe is infinite, after a googolplex years atoms will gather together and make an exact copy of "you" (this proof is idiotic because you can't explain why you are that body instead of my body).

The soul is a spiritual body which controls the physical body. We are not so stupid that we come to the physical world without a backup-body.
 
My logic says before I was born I didn't exist and after I die I will cease to exist.

The above two don't prove anything whatsoever.
 
How do we explain the behaviour of twins ?

When twins are borned, how one is more fortunate than other ?

Unless each has history why do they behave totally different way right from the childhood ?

Is it due to carryover of previous birth ?

Why some persons are very rich throughout the life where as some are extremely poor throughout the life.
How can we justify this?

P.J.LAKHAPATE
plakhapate@rediffmail.com
 
Proof of rebirth: if we could stop existing forever, we wouldn't exist now either, because eternity can't start somewhere.

Another proof: I don't remember my birth, therefore I was never born.

Yet another proof: The only reality is the present moment where nothing has time to exist, and so, because we don't really exist, we can't stop existing.
 
Does it effect baby's complexion and features, if a woman from pre to post pregnant stage keep any photograph in her room and see/think about it constantly?

Is it ok, colour/spectrum is alike spirit of substance?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top