And yet again you use a lot of words without actually proving your point anywhere, dismiss my hard evidence, and still offer none of your own. I don't owe you any further explanation. The proof is there.
I just didn't say what you wanted to here.
I'm elated you're actually giving up...excellent.
Recall that I told your that if you offered even a shred of proof that an Artoo unit has ever taken control of a fighter from a pilot?
Yes...you must recall because you never found one.
That means that the fighters are no where near a match for a Federation starship in any amount of numbers.
Artoo's direct hits...
No canon rebutal there either. And while you're obviously capable of posting visuals you obviously are too lazy to do so. So you hand that one two me too.
And it looks like you wanted to make your stand on Star Trek Canon Policy. Flapped your gumms about what was canon or quasi canon...and you had to be set straight. Didn't know quite as much as you thought, did you? Silence afterwards confirmed that you were humbled by greater knowledge...and the stand you were planning on taking...never happened.
As well as the Galaxy Class Starship to vaporize hundreds of tons of alloy metal in an instant. Nothing to say on that front either...Why? because it's canon and it out classes a Imperial Star Destroyer several fold...which means Wong's numbers are incredibly wrong or the Galaxy is boasting power we never knew...turnabouts fair play right Sian? It's canon...
How much twisting am I doing now?
Lets keep it up. The movie clearly show that fighters flew through the Executors shields to hit targets which in the moivies are implied to be shield generators...movie is superior canon to all else and contradiction can included what is included....
As a result canon inisist that they are shield generators, movie prevails despite the original design plans. There fore since small shielded ships can manuver through shields of large ships so can an even smaller shielded object...a torpedo...
Further evidence shows that Jaina and Jagged Fel and Kyp Durron would frequently overlap their shields in what were called in the New Jedi Order "shield trio's showing that shields do not conflict with shields.
That combined with the Millenium Falcon's landing on the control tower of the Star Destroyer Avenger after it's shields went up is a clear indication that small objects such as live grutchins, fighters, and large freighter clearly are not repelled by Star Destroyer shields. And there seems to be consensus in the EU that proton torpedoes don't strike shield but actually strike hull bypassing shields.
In Timothy Zahns book Spectre of the Past and Visions of the future several republic fighter and bombers preformed a tactial manuver on a Star Destroyer. The fighters drawing their fire and the bombers penetrating like an arrow to the star Destroyer and the making their escape. This damaged the ship it's self and not the shields...I' believe this is the Chimera herself...In this case it was strategy on strategy.
The EU as I've said before clearly outlines that the ships use lasers and not a particle beam or plasma weapon...The Vong using Plasma geysers on the star destroyer repeated pummled them with broad sides...
The entries do not show there was anything special about the plasma and the Star Destroyers showed a resistance to that plasma but that it was the one time I noted that something was steadily wearing down a star destroyer's shields.
Defiant using contained warp plasma with it's rapid phaser nadion effect combined with the layering that occurs right before it is relased is obviously a more extensive weapon than spewing geyers...Defiant therefor has proven it's effectiveness aswell against the Imperial Star Destroyer class.
PS...Jan...the EU repeated refers to the Star Destroyer as an Imperial Class star destroyer not the Imperator class star destroyer. I know because as I was going through books and highlighting ships I wanted to use in the novel they refered in Dark TIDE II NJO the Right to Rule as one of two Imperial class Star Destroyers of Grand Admiral Pellaeon that had dropped in to save the day.
I think on the whole here we have a significant different between design and story. The writters and movies seem to going by a different set of rules and I doubt any of them consulted the ICS books to show they're dedication to them as canon books.
In Law there are what are termed Legal Prescendents. Even though they are not actual laws in many cases they establish what was is allowed. In cases where there is law the presence of a legal prescedent allows for acknowledgement that a law can be circumvented for some reason or by the allowance of Law Enforce in failure to uphold the law.
The EU has thus established a consistent Prescendent of bypassing the ICS books established fire power ratings. Sian due to your lack of reliance of canon in the face of these Prescendents I can only concluded that it is permited that Star Wars can be viewed in this fashion. You have a ICS based understanding of Star Wars while I've interrogated the actual occurences and it is clear that the authors and the movies have felt free to disregard what can only be considered by you as "LAW". However the movies are actually the Lay of the Star Wars universe making the ICS judgments substandard. I believe I have what I need to construct a fair representation of both sides...shields, weapons, ranges and speed.