Perpetual Bliss
One of the interesting things about picking up the latest trend in young liberal political commentators is how easy conservatives are making it.
Similarly, one of the curiosities of American politics in recent generations is how stupid we must believe Republicans are while never criticizing or even mentioning this point.
Dinesh D'Souza, for instance, is stupid. At this point, that's the only explanation still standing.
Consider recent political noise in which the swatstika-bearing, "roman" saluting, genocidal authoritarians complain that anybody notices; you know, like the conservative complaint that liberals use words like Nazi or fascist to describe people wearing swatstikas, declaring plenary authority for ethnic cleansing, and so otherwise making it obvious.
And if, for some American observers, the south-Asian-American relationship with the Republican Party in recent years has always seemed something of a headscratcher, the second Trump presidency ought to have made certain things clear: When the white supremacists went after J.D. Vance's wife and kids, he didn't stand up for his family. We're not even a year into the term and we're supposed to pretend people like Harmeet Dhillon, Dinesh D'Souza, or even Kash Patel never knew, had no idea, are shocked to learn.
So, there's the backstory. The setup for the moment starts with former congressman Joe Walsh (R-IL)
denouncing↱ Trump's unchecked destruction of the White House; Dinesh D'Souza
responded↱ on brand, pitching a mix of pride and racism in his compalint about Biden and Democrats tearing down walls; at that point, alt-chan Ribbert assailed D'Souza in a typal
racist rant↱, and D'Souza is
shocked, shocked I tells ya↱: "In a career spanning 40 years," he laments, "I have never encountered this type of rhetoric." And then he goes on to say, "The Right never used to talk like this," and people who have been around long enough know just how full of shit that is.
But the younger generation sees it differently; they don't necessarily know about the past, so some of them are reading this like it's D'Souza's first dance: Twentysomething podcaster Adam Mockler
expressed surpriseȑ, suggesting, "D'Souza realizes in real time that the GOP has been completely consumed by racism."
But then something else clicked, and the thing is, Dinesh D'Souza really is exemplary of something. In addition to the King's College episode, and the campaign finance felony conviction Trump pardoned, there was also the time D'Souza produced a conspiracy theory into a movie, and even the writers of the discredited conspiracy theory rebuked his irresponsibility. And maybe Mockler hasn't caught up on those parts, yet, because it's a lot and it's buried in noise, and it's kind of unbelievable except it really did happen.
Thus, a few minutes after expressing his surprise, Mockler followed up with another obvious point. Conservative cartoonist Antonio Branco depicted a 9/11-style attack, with an airliner labeled, "Mandami" flying toward a Trade Center building labeled "NY City". It's a rough cartoon, as it is, but D'Souza posted it with the comment, "The difference is this time New York might be asking for it."
Thus, as Mockler pointed out, "Dude, you literally tweeted this right after." That is to say, per Dinesh—
In a career spanning 40 years, I have never encountered this type of rhetoric. The Right never used to talk like this. So who on our side has legitimized this type of vile degradation? It's a question worth thinking about.
—and, let's be honest, it was about six hours later that D'Souza had sufficiently recovered from his shock to justify terrorism as a response to electoral outcomes he doesn't like.
And there's nothing new about that. Mockler was seven when Sarah Palin marked her political opponents with crosshairs; going on eight years old when Sharron Angle suggested Second Amendment remedies for Republicans unhappy with election results; he was all of eight when Jared Lee Loughner made good on all that conservative tough talk.
A diligent student of history will eventually find a lot of that history, but, for the moment, it's worth considering how
easy Republican glass jaws make it for liberal critcis to hit them. I'm pretty sure Mockler is aware of the Southern Strategy. That we should pretend D'Souza doesn't know is about on course for a man whose career arc describes a professional idiot.
But it does remind the question: Do we really think these conservatives don't know?