What Will Be, Will Be
TBT: Hey, remember when this was a joke about a conspiracy theory?
The Trump administration is about to link autism to the use of paracetemol / Tylenol by pregnant women.
While there are some studies that suggest a slight link, the overwhelming data suggests otherwise. But, you know, RFK Jr promised they would find the "cause" of autism, and, well, this will undoubtedly be it.
It's not just that the data suggests otherwise; autism was identified before acetaminophen, by decades.
The thing I'm waiting for is the Kenvue lawsuit in response. HHS is going to have to provide their experts, and their experts will lose their careers¹, and then they will complain of cancel culture, and then some science-y pretenders online are going to have to either further abandon science or give up the pretense.
It'll go even worse for them than the don't-call-them-Nazis complaint that leads to the adaptation of Nazi speeches at an ostensible memorial service.
(Seriously, the people who defended this movement along its way are so thoroughly and embarrassingly discredited by now, and maybe we ought to have that discussion, so they can stop pretending and just get on with life. It either hurts them to be so wrong or chafes them to be seen as wrong, so we need to find out if the problem is that they don't support Nazis or maybe the Nazis have gotten so bad at Naziing that it's just that much harder to support them without actually saying so.)
(Okay, fine, let me make a brief point about that;
see the
Rowling thread #192↗:
Compared to the constant baby-killer rhetoric, it was always easy enough to wonder what kind of doctor would do that, and we did in our time find an answer. To pretend every doctor is a closet Kermit Gosnell, as the anti-abortion movement generally presumes, is just a bit silly.
To the other, analogies only go so far. If, for instance, we know what kind of doctor would improperly prescribe puberty blockers, well, you wouldn't believe, except you would.
The thing is, the discredited doctor everyone thinks is about to blame Tylenol for autism lost his authorization to practice on children because he was improperly prescribing gender-affirming drugs to children in pursuit of his anti-vaccine crackpottery. It's one of those things; when you ride with bigotry, you find strange allies.)
Then again, how many anti-trans crackpots are really going to be so worried about RFK Jr.'s pseudoscience, especially given that liberal cancel culture might try to silence David Geier by disagreeing with him, noting his license suspension, or even getting so extreme as to call his life's work quackery.
And, you know, you can't call someone a quack or a pseudoscientist just because they disagree with you. And if I'm not wishing good luck to whoever might attempt that defense of such dangerous crackpottery, the reason has to do with crackpottery, not political labels.
Oh, right, they don't support the crackpottery, but, rather, the crackpot's free-speech right to impose and inflict it on others. (Isn't that how it goes?)
Point being, while it's unclear exactly when who among these innocent supporters of the supporters was supposed to know what, the fact that we were dealing with anti-fluoridation grade crackpottery and tinfoil probably should have been apparent when they started defluoridating local water supplies.
Conspiracist antivax crackpottery? Remember, this bogey has bounced around GOP respectability, legitimized by Republican Party imprimatur, at least since 2013.
And, given the overlap, no, it would be insufficient to plead that one missed it because they were too busy scolding their liberal neighbors to stop
upsetting conservatives↗ by challenging rightist arguments.
That is to say, this multi-pronged phenomenon is not the result of two independent forces just happening to coincide in certain ways. Rather, both the crackpottery and the fascism expressed by Republicans and conservatives² are two forks of the same tongue.
____________________
Notes:
¹ Well, otherwise respectable scientists who aid and abet will lose prestige, at least; RFJ Jr.'s sort of expert, though, can probably expect some sort of career advancement in the political sector.
² And better-than-thou "independents", and Pepe pilltards, and whatever remains of reactionary antiliberalism, and so on, and so forth, &c., i.e., rightists in denial.