(continued...)
Well, the guy already take for granted the assumed gravitational lens.
Nope. The point is to numerically compare the
precise behaviour predicted by the General Theory of Relativity with mathematically quantified observational data. No assumption is made in advance as to whether the predictions of the theory will match the observations. That is the
result that emerges at the end of the analysis.
This is why the study provides evidence that the General Theory is correct.
Understand?
Tell him to replace his title with atmospheric lens, or refraction by cosmic dust, and so forth. My guess his numbers will be the same.
You should have read the paper. But you didn't. Right?
CAn nyou notice that these guys are pushing a lot other kind of measures when the simplest way is to send another expedition to same locations in Africa and Brazil, same telescopes and verify the results?
The paper provides
independent evidence for the theory of relativity. In other words, it just adds to the the mountain of existing evidence obtained by other studies.
Other way to see it is, who reviewed his works? You?
Experts in the relevant scientific sub-discipline. That's what peer review means. The people who are most competent to assess the work assess it.
Yes, you habve lots of propaganda...
I have lots of
evidence. You just don't like it. Without even having looked at it.
... but tell them to deny that refraction of light causing illusions is also the answer.
Do you honestly think that astronomers don't considered refraction of light in their observations and calculations?
You really have no idea, do you?
These are
experts, Luchito. Not people with ideological axes to grind or a fixation on "intellectual elites" or whatever the issue is that stops
you from wanting to learn.
While my position is backed up with solid recognized observations and experiments, what those studies show that those are made based on blind faith: time dilates.
Please cite the relevant papers or other sources that contain your solid recognised observations and experiments.
If you can't do that, I think it will be fair for me to assume you're just making it up. Don't you?
I showed you mine. You turn to show me yours.
Yeah, Money buys lots of things.
Yes, including expensive space telescopes and the like. Which, as it happens, are really great for testing theories such as the General Theory of Relativity.
No a single contradiction, everything fits exactly as predicted.
Well, not exactly. But within experimental uncertainty. Scientists are very careful to quantify uncertainties, you know.
I see more fantasy in those studies than in the bible with a talking mule.
See, the thing is, Luchito:
nobody cares what you think about any of these studies. Do you know why? It's because you have already demonstrated that you're completely unequipped to offer any meaningful commentary on them. That's because you don't even understand what theories are being tested or how they are being tested.
Let's face it: you didn't even read the papers. Did you?
Luckily, you have me taking pity on you and trying to lead you a little way towards the light. Right now, you're just sort of lost and angry at the world. But it will take effort from you to get you back on track. You have to want it.
Sure. Eddington lied and committed fraud doing make up to the plaques. He convinced the Astronomer Royal to validate his claims and validate Relativity theory. It was found later that such results weren't correct, that better pictures came from Newton's prediction and that Eddington made fool the Astronomer Royal. What the Royal Society will do? No other thing but to push hard to keep such validation as secured forever and that his Astronomer Royal was never a fool. This is a case of pride versus truth. Pride won.
How would you respond to the arguments in the paper I linked to you about those observations etc, then?
You didn't read it, did you?
The motion of the mortar mix line is the illusion, the cause is the phenomenon called mirage.
If you like.
When you know that the reason of the displacement of the image of the star in question was caused by the sun atmosphere, then those 100 plus years supporting Relativity have no value at all.
But I don't know that.
I have now asked you several times to show me the data that supports your claim that the observed deflection of light can be explained by refraction in the Sun's atmosphere.
You have come up with a blank. It seems like you
have no data or arguments to support your specific claim.
There is a big machine, mentioned indirectly by Asimov, protecting the accepted science and rejecting any attempt to overcoming it.
No. Scientists win prizes for overturning "accepted science" and for discovering new science, not for "protecting" accepted science.
Every scientist is working her hardest to try to prove existing theories wrong and/or to find new facts about the world that no scientist has found before.
It's what scientists are paid to do.
Somebody lied to you when they told you that there's a conspiracy of scientists to try to protect a dogma. That's not how science works. That's something we tend to see in religion, not science.
If what you say is true, then there would be no technological advances. Anybody who dared to try to invent something new would be persecuted by the "protectors" of "accepted science", and their inventions destroyed or hidden away.
This is not what we observe in the real world.
For you information, I was participating in discussions forums decades ago, when there were hundreds if no thousands of websites, where even Lorentz was challenged just by moving a coordinate and his work became peanuts.
Seems like those thousands of websites that disproved Lorentz gained no traction with mainstream science. I'm guessing that most of them just disappeared with a whimper, overcome by the power of actual science.
Is that what happened, Luchito?
Today, with all the technology available same AI is incapable to think the possibility of a challenger against Relativity, because it has been manipulated to provide solely favoring articles for Relativity.
It has been trained on data from the entire internet, including on what all the pseudoscientists and naysayers like yourself have to say about science. Clearly, for whatever reason, all that training has resulted in the AIs overwhelmingly accepting science over pseudoscience as the best model of reality. For what it's worth.
However, with all that in your hands, you still can't answer the simple requests made by me. Isn't something?
Which simple requests can't I answer? I've tried to be reasonably thorough in my responses to your questions. Would you like me to post more in each of my responses to you? Do you think you can keep up with me?
Meanwhile, as you can see from these replies to your most recent posts, you're
seriously struggling to come up with
anything to support
any of your anti-science claims, other than your own ill-informed opinions.
You just can't define properly what is time...
See above.
... you can't make a simple diagram showing how time dilates.
Oh, I
can. I
choose not to, because a brief internet search would turn up many diagrams for you. Do your own homework.
No learning ever comes with zero effort, Luchito.
I wonder, how far blind faith can reach?
It can reach far enough to make a person deny the obvious. We see that all the time here at sciforums.