The Bible: Energy = "nothing"? or 0?

Yes of course, that's how science works, falsification is part of the filtering process.
True, but with a caveat - if you have a model that has already been shown to work well within a certain domain, and some data points appear that contradict the model, we don't just throw it out wholesale; instead, we recognise that its domain of applicability is limited, and use it accordingly. The classic example is Newtonian mechanics - we know that it works extremely well within a certain well-defined domain of applicability (the low-energy, low-velocity, weak-field regime), but the further you go outside that domain, the more it fails in increasingly catastrophic ways. Yet it's still taught in school physics classes, because within its domain of applicability it is very useful due to its relative mathematical simplicity. So this isn't merely a right/wrong type of situation, it is also about usefulness and contextuality.
 
True, but with a caveat - if you have a model that has already been shown to work well within a certain domain, and some data points appear that contradict the model, we don't just throw it out wholesale; instead, we recognise that its domain of applicability is limited, and use it accordingly. The classic example is Newtonian mechanics - we know that it works extremely well within a certain well-defined domain of applicability (the low-energy, low-velocity, weak-field regime), but the further you go outside that domain, the more it fails in increasingly catastrophic ways. Yet it's still taught in school physics classes, because within its domain of applicability it is very useful due to its relative mathematical simplicity. So this isn't merely a right/wrong type of situation, it is also about usefulness and contextuality.
Yes the more complete and nuanced answer, but since Lucito would not recognise this kind of treatment or nuance if it jumped up and kicked him in the xiphoid process, that answer would be lost on him.
 
Yes of course, that's how science works, falsification is part of the filtering process.
120 years of the best minds have not only failed to do that they have used relativity to develop their own theories, make new discoveries and build an entire technology on it.

Why don't you publish your ground breaking paper, win the Nobel, upend physics and become the world's most famous person?
I just came back. I re-read my last messages here and, man! So many typos, I guess I have become a great typographer.

Look, what you say is not easy. I can tell by experiences of others. While with others we were interchanging our "discoveries", one of them leaved the attached Yahoo pages on my desk. I only post two of them.

You will see and know about a guy who challenged the orthodox physics teaching in those times.(this is page one)

And in page three, the reaction of the main guys about the papers of Lynds.

No calls for his papers to be evaluate by a member of the Nobel Prize Academy but rejection and bury of his "ideas". They didn't want even read the papers of Lynd, as if those were taboo. (they said that, but lied because if they said they have read his papers, then they would have to give their opinions about them).

Lynd obtained his 15 minutes of fame, of course.

Like him, the established orthodox scientific community will find the way to diminish and hide any theory or explanation that debunks the doctrines of Relativity. And the more new papers come out challenging them, the more propaganda they create to overcome any publication made that nullifies their theoretical claims. You can notice this when suddenly the news says that a new experiment proved "Relativity right again", and this phrase is repeated every six months or when needed. Keeping people brainwashed is their specialty. I have posted before how Issac Asimov describes what happens to the ones who decide to accept new scientific approaches that practically destroy the conventional accepted theories, they won't receive grants, no access to important information, and so forth.

The only thing I can tell you is to review what you have learned in physics, but from a different frame of reference. I did it, and I found that some theories claims are coincidences, false and even fraud. But, thanks to propaganda those still the accepted ones by general consensus.

From my part I didn't agree with the extra push he was making about time, but he was in the right path anyway.


Lucho.jpgLucho 2.jpg
 
Luchito:

Thanks for your replies.

It's a little hard to know where the best place to start is, to reply to what you have written. I must say that your replies read as if you just hit the "reply" button before reading my posts in full, and then just reacted to each part of my posts in the order I wrote them, but without ever taking a moment to try to understand the arguments and justifications I put to you. Probably because of that, there is a lot of unnecessary repetition in your replies.

I cited 4 or 5 recent peer-reviewed studies for you. I get the strong impression that you didn't actually read any of those papers. Is that just laziness on your part, or is it more because you were afraid that (a) you probably wouldn't understand the contents of the papers and/or (b) that the contents would be too convincing in their details for you to try to refute?

It seems like you have mostly just repeated your previous claims about relativity being wrong, but you have utterly failed to produce any actual evidence - or even one good theoretical argument - to show that it is wrong.

Maybe you have been pushing this anti-relativity line for so long that you're just stuck in your ways and quite unwilling to learn anything about the actual science. Is that the problem?

Anyway...

I think one of the main problems that's preventing you from even starting to get a grasp on what the theory of relativity is all about, is that you haven't managed to grasp what a frame of reference is yet - even though the impression I get is that you've been doing the rounds of the interwebs for decades complaining about relativity being false etc.

Just think of the time and angst you could have saved yourself, if you had only channelled some of that anti-establishment rage you have into spending just a little time getting up to speed on what those pesky scientists actually have to say about their precious Theory of Relativity! But it seems like you never invested any time in that. Was the maths too hard for you to understand, perhaps? That's a common hurdle that a great many pseudoscientists never manage to get over. It's not necessarily about lacking ability. It's often more about being just too darned lazy to put in the hours necessary to learn the relevant mathematics. It's especially difficult for the ones who delude themselves into believing they are natural geniuses who just know how science ought to work, and who therefore also delude themselves that every bit of science they don't understand must be wrong because it's just too darn overcomplicated for their liking.

So, I'm going to reply to parts of your most recent posts, but in a slightly different order than the order you posted them. I'm going to start by teaching you something more about the basics of frames of reference. In my next post, I will be examining, once again, the perennial mystery of wind, because it seems to me that you're still struggling to understand what it is.
 
Luchito:

Let's consider for a third time the experiment in which you drive your car in a straight line along the highway at 70 miles per hour, while I watch you from the roadside.

Let us now assume that you and I each have an anemometer to measure the wind speed. Mine is mounted on top of a pole that is dug into the ground where I'm standing on the roadside. Yours is mounted on top of your car (on the roof).

Now, suppose that, as your drive along, my anemometer reads zero, while yours reads 70 mph. Can you account for these two different readings, Luchito?

My explanation is this: the air above the road is not moving relative to the road. My anemometer is also not moving relative to the road. Therefore, the air about the road is not moving relative to my anemometer. Since an anemometer measures the speed of air flowing past it, thus causing its little propeller to spin around, my anemometer's propeller isn't turning, and so it reads zero.

On the other hand, your anemometer's propeller is spinning rapidly as you drive along. Why?

The air above the road is not moving relative to the road, remember. So why is your anemometer spinning? It is because the anemometer is moving relative to the road. Therefore, it is also moving relative to the air.

Now, let's think about this carefully. If you're driving away from me 70 mph, that means that in 1 hour you will be 70 miles away further from me than you are now. Right?

How fast am I moving relative to you, Luchito? I'm stationary on the road. So does that mean that, from your point of view, I won't ever get any further away from you - that I'll be exactly the same distance from your car in 1 hour's time? Hopefully, you will agree that, in 1 hour, I'll be 70 miles further away from your car, compared to where I am now. But that means that relative to your car, I must have travelled at 70 miles per hour for 1 hour!

To put it more succinctly - if your speed relative to me is, say, 70 mph in a northly direction, then my speed relative to you must be 70 mph in a southerly direction. Or, if you can cope with a little maths: v(me relative to you)=-v(you relative to me), where 'v' means velocity and the minus sign says we go in opposite directions relative to one another.

Back to the anemometers.

Your anemometer, on top of your car, is moving at 70 mph relative to the road and therefore also at 70 mph relative to the air. But that also means that the road is moving at -70mph relative to the anemometer. And it also means that the air is moving at -70mph relative to the anemometer.

From the anemometer's point of view (or, equivalently, from your point of view as the driver of the car on which the anemometer is mounted), the air speed rushing past the propeller is 70 mph. And so your anemometer readout says 70 mph. Does that make sense to you?

What about my anemometer, on the roadside, then? I just told you that, relative to you, my anemometer is travelling at 70 mph. But you don't see it spinning. Why not? Well, how fast is the air moving relative to your car? 70mph; we just went through that. But how fast is the air moving relative to the road/me/my anemometer? Zero.

Since the speed of the air relative to my anemometer is zero, my anemometer doesn't spin and its airspeed readout says 0 mph.
Since the speed of the air relative to your anemometer is 70mph, your anemometer spins and its airspeed readout says 70 mph.

Now, the funny thing is, in this scenario, I don't feel any wind at all. But if you stick your hand out of your car window, you feel exactly the same sensation as if you were sitting in a car at rest on the roadside, with a 70 mph wind blowing past it. Why is that?

Answer: you feel wind if and only if the speed of the air relative to you is not zero.

How can the speed of air past you not be zero? At least in these two ways:
1. The air can be physically moving along relative to the road while you're stationary relative to the road; or
2. The air can be stationary relative to the road while you're moving along relative to the road.

What's a simple rule for determining whether an anemometer you're carrying will spin in the "wind"? Here's the rule:
If the air is moving relative to the anemometer, it will spin. If the air is stationary relative to the anemometer, it will not spin.

Notice: there's nothing in that rule that says anything about how fast the anemometer has to be moving relative to the road, to the Sun, to the centre of the galaxy, to the star Betelgeuse, or whatever.

All that matters is the speed of the air relative to the anemometer, or equivalently, the speed the anemometer relative to the air.

So there you have it, Luchito. A primer on relative speed for you, all in one post.

I have only two questions for you in regards to the content of this post:
1. Do you understand the content of this post?
2. Do you agree with the contents of this post?

If you think there's something wrong in this post, we'd better deal with your confusion first, before we continue the discussion of relative motion onto more complicated topics.

Baby steps.
 
Last edited:
Luchito:

In this post I want to quickly address some of your replies, referring to the quick primer I just gave you about relative motion. This is a good way for me to further check your understanding of the basics.

Yes, I did. But I was inside the airplane. I invite you to fly in an airplane but outside of it, and let me know if you feel some or none resistance at constant speed over there at high altitude.
If I'm outside the airplane, then I will feel the air that is moving relative to the airplane. Refer back to my previous post if you are still confused by this.

Do you now agree with me?

I'm hoping you're bright enough to be able to understand the concept of relative speed. I guess we'll see, one way or the other.
No, not the equivalent, I felt my body traveling at 60 miles per hour against the air around.
Human beings have no direct perception of their speed. They can only measure their speed relative to some other object (or collection of objects).

I agree with you that you are travelling at 60 mph relative to the air, in this example. And therefore, the air is also travelling at 60 mph relative to you.

Notice, again, that your speed relative to the ground, and the air's speed relative to the ground isn't important in determining why you feel the wind.

I understand that, at this point, you might want to say "Oh, but when I'm travelling along the road in my car, it's really my car that's moving, not the road and air that's moving."

But you can't know that. All you know is that your car is moving relative to the road, and that the road is therefore moving relative to your car at the same speed (but in the opposite direction). Nobody has said anything about how fast the road is moving relative to anything else, apart from your car.

That is, nobody has said how fast the road is moving relative to the Sun. Nobody has said how fast the road is moving relative to the Great Attractor. Nobody has said how fast the road is moving relative to the moon Titan. Why didn't they specify those speeds? Because they are irrelevant to how fast the air is moving relative to your car. And that is the only speed that's relative to the force you feel from the air.

Are you getting it, yet?

I know what I felt, I studied Sensation and Perception, do you remember?
Nobody is questioning your perception.
The air was quiet, I was the one moving fast.
The air was still relative to the road. Your motorbike was moving relative to the air. Understand?
I truly have no idea of what are you talking about with your "equivalents" and your "relatives".
Yes. That's the problem you've been having all these years.

But now I'm taking the time to teach you the basics, so you don't keep having no idea.

Your thanks would be appreciated, but I don't expect you to thank me. Perhaps you'll just be upset that you wasted so much of your life before somebody taught you this stuff. Maybe you'll want to look for somebody else to blame.
But, when concentrated and driving away from the mountains, I am very aware that the mountains are not the ones moving away from me. The mountains can be further at each moment, but not moving away from me.
You're not moving away from yourself, but you're still somehow travelling along at 70mph in your car, or whatever.

What's your speed relative to yourself, Luchito? Looks like it is always zero, to me.

On the other hand, if mountains get further away from you at a rate of 70 miles further away every hour, it seems to me that the mountains must be moving at 70 mph relative to you. And, of course, you're also moving at 70 mph relative to the mountains - but in the opposite direction.
WEll. if your frame of reference is distant mountains "moving" backwards relative to my car, then such a frame of reference doesn't belong to physics at all.
If you still think so, then go through my previous post line by line and point our the errors I made in it.

Otherwise, I'd appreciate it if you would concede that I was right all along.
You see, reality has some parameters, you know. we must be very careful in not reaching the borders of the absurd.
If there something absurd about saying: if the air moves relative to you, then you're also moving relative to the air?

What's absurd about that?
You already also said that one will feel resistance when traveling on the wing of the airplane at fast speed, even at fixed one.
Yes, because the air is moving relative to the wing...
I agree, speed itself is not the one that affects the person or machine, but the resistance in the environment.
Relative speed of the person or machine to the "environment" is what matters. Agree?
Well, Relativity assumes a person inside the spaceship won't be affected by speed, but never mentions a person without spaceship traveling fast in space.
The spaceship doesn't matter. Human beings can't directly perceive speed. They can only look at objects around them to judge their relative speed, compared to those objects.

Spaceships are important for carrying air for people to breathe, of course, but that has nothing to do with relative speed.
One must say, what about space "walking"? In reference of astronauts going out of the space station for certain duties. But those are in limited periods, not years of traveling. Like a fiush surviving outisde the water for a certain period, but later...
I think we can agree that astronauts need air to breathe. Maybe we can also agree that there's a shortage of air in space?

None of which is relevant to a discussion about speed.
 
Last edited:
(continued...)

Luchito's Science 101says everything moves in our universe.
Okay.

Does that mean that when you drive your car and the speedometer says you're doing 70 mph, the speedometer is wrong? Or is it correct?

If it's correct, that implies that the road isn't moving. But you just said that everything is moving.

So, if the road is moving, how fast is your car actually moving? And what does that 70 mph figure actually mean? Is it telling you anything useful at all?

Think about it and get back to me with your answers.

However, with respect of one to another, the motion can be different. The traveler can be the one moving faster and the particles of the air moving very slow, almost quiet; or can be the person standing in a place while the wind traveling fast, or both traveling same direction or opposite one to the other.
It almost sounded like you were beginning to grasp the concept of relative motion, but then this happened...
Here is the disagreement. If you use an anemometer located at the middle of the way, and you drive fast on the road and the air is quiet or slow moving, you can measure that the air is not speeding up relative to you but it's you pushing air away while you go fast.
I don't understand the point of disagreement that you're trying to explain here.

But I have posted a quite lengthy post, above, regarding anemometers and such. Does that help you?
Again, an anemometer will find your statement as incorrect.
I don't think so. See my post about anemometers, above. If you can spot an error, please point it out for me.
By my answers given right above, you already know I can't agree with your statements because are in disagreement with what instruments will measure when the event is in progress.
Tell me what you think the anemometers will measure in my example in the previous post, then. And explain why, of course.
Perhaps you are referring to action and reaction.
Action and reaction concern forces. We're mostly talking about relative speeds here.
But you must consider that particles of the air are not traveling in reference to you but are expelled or pushed from you when the air of the atmosphere was quiet at your location.
I don't understand what you mean.
Oh, I got your point. And unfortunately you are talking about another, you won't like what is next, another... I warn you, you won't like it at all, another... well, I will say it anyway, another illusion.
Is it an illusion that the anemometer attached to your car records 70 mph, while the one on the roadside records 0 mph?
The air is quiet, I am traveling fats in a road at 70 miles per hour, I take my hand out thru the window and I feel the resistance of the air that appears to be wind hitting my hand. Such is what I might feel, and if I don't know what is going on in reality, then yes, I should think that the air was the one moving fast. But such is not the real scenario. And such is the trick caused by motion, a trick called illusion.
Okay.

Suppose I am wearing a blindfold. Somebody puts me in a car. I wind down the window and stick my hand out.

Now, let's suppose one of two situations is arranged:
1. A driver drives the car along a road at 70 mph.
2. The car remains stationary in a large room (like a wind tunnel) in which a large fan blows air at 70 mph towards the car. In this case, let us also assume that the car engine is turned on and the car is sitting on a platform that vibrates in a way to give a convincing impression of a car driving along a road.

In which scenario is the wind I feel with my hand real? And in which scenario is the wind an illusion?

Do I feel the wind in both scenarios?

Is there any experiment I can do from inside the car, with my blindfold on, to determine whether I'm in situation 1 or situation 2?

Remember, I am using a valid perspective acquired from psychology studies.
I don't believe you. I think you're just going based on your own gut instincts and life experience. And I think you're trying to make your thoughts seem like they are backed up by "studies", in the hope that will sound impressive to me.

It doesn't impress me, Luchito.
Oh yeah, I was never aware of how relativistic ideas can accomplish such interesting insight as shown by you in this conversation.
I deduced that you were never aware, based on what you wrote previously.
Thanks for allowing me to understand the methods used by relativists to coordinate events and relativity doctrines in several and different scenarios.
We haven't even made a start on the Special Theory of Relativity yet. You need to be schooled on good ol' fashioned Galilean relativity before you'll be ready to go toe to toe with the big man Einstein.

Baby steps.
When relative motion is over viewed at distance it fits graciously with the doctrines of the theory. When its essence is studied, here is when the theory seems to fall apart.
You haven't shown how it falls apart, so far. Not surprising, since nobody has managed that in the past 100+ years.
I have a question for you. If (a conditional), if Relativity theory was finally found false, even after decades of assumed evidence backing it back, would you accept taking it out of science?
Of course. In a heartbeat.
 
Last edited:
Of course. In a heartbeat.
I disagree, see my explanations in post #161 - relativity is already too well established via experiment and observation to ever be found "false" in the sense that it would be struck off all textbooks. What would happen, rather, is the same that happened to Newtonian mechanics after it was found to make incorrect predictions in some circumstances; namely, we would recognise that its domain of applicability is limited, but continue teaching and using it within its own regime. Relativity is in fact somewhat unusual among models of physics in that we haven't unambiguously determined yet just how far its domain of applicability really extends, particularly in the case of Special Relativity (we already know now that GR is limited at most to the classical regime).

My personal feeling is that also SR might eventually break down at extremely high energies, but this remains to be seen.
 
Luchito:

Next, I want to address some of your comments about time and clocks.
To start, your definition is time is what the clock measures, or something similar.
You keep asking for a definition. So let me give you one:

Time is the fourth coordinate needed to uniquely specify when and where an EVENT occurs.

Here's an example of why we need a fourth coordinate. Here are two events:
Event 1: I ate cornflakes for breakfast at my dining table.
Event 2: I ate cornflakes for breakfast at my dining table.

Are these the same event, or different events? It's hard to tell, right? In both events, the same thing seems to have occurred. In both events, the thing that happened reportedly occurred in the same place.

Now how about these two events:
Event 3: I ate cornflakes for breakfast at my dining table on 30 October 2026 at 8:30 am (AEST).
Event 4: I ate cornflakes for breakfast at my dining table on 25 December 1994 at 7:45 am (AEST).

It looks like we added some additional information that shows that Event 3 is different from Event 4, doesn't it? In case you missed it, what I added is the time that each event occurred.

In fact, it turns out that every instance of me eating cornflakes can be uniquely specified (as Events 3 and 4 are) if I specify exactly where in space the event occurred and when it occurred (in time).

Without the time coordinate, the events are no longer uniquely determined (as, for example, in Events 1 and 2).

This is a sufficient definition of time, I think.

We can also, because it's useful, define the following:

The time interval between two events, A and B, is equal to (time coordinate of event A) minus (time coordinate of event B).
It happens that clocks doesn't measure anything, the clocks is a device having or signaling a calibrated motion.
Clocks can be used to measure time intervals.
From here, the age of my son is 33 orbits around the sun, translated to the conventional measure invented by us, my son is 33 years old.
The motion of Earth around the Sun can be used as a kind of clock to measure time intervals, including the ages of biological organisms.
Staff that happened to me today have a different motion than same or other staff happening to me yesterday of tomorrow, because even if the same waking up from bed, the same computer use at work, same pages written, same time for lunch, same meal, etc. etc. it won't the same repetition from yesterday because my location with respect to the sun has changed, this means the angle of the sun illuminating my day is different, and the air motion is different since yesterday up to today and more different tomorrow.
Yes, and your time coordinates changed as well.

Note, again, that giving only your location with respect to the Sun is not sufficient to uniquely specify individual events.
Time is just a measure, the clock shows this measure units, like hours, minutes, seconds.
Clocks measure time intervals.
Time itself is just the comparison of your motion against the measure units given by the clock (a regular motion).
Motion isn't necessary. I can sit still for an hour and still use a clock to work out how long I was sitting still for.
Time itself is just a definition made, a measure invented by us, something like drawing in a world map lines indicating longitudes and latitudes. You fly in an airplane and you won't see any line, you just detect latitude and longitude thanks to a device also calibrated and based in the information input in it.
Okay. I have no problem with that. 1 yard is similarly a measure invented by us. But I don't see you arguing that distances don't exist.
The deduction reached by you as an existing time is not valid, it appears it carries a confusion calling motion of things as "existing time".
Maybe you're also confused in calling the spatial separation of thing as "existing distance", then.

What do you think?

Are you going to argue that space isn't real, as well?
But don't worry, eventually you will find out that time doesn't exist and doesn't dilate.
Will I also find that space doesn't exist?
Oh yes, I will love for you to decipher relativistic babbling. Go ahead.
I think my "relativistic babbling" will have to wait until I have confirmed that you're up to speed in your understanding of the basics of relative motion.

Briefly, though, the phrase "Time intervals between events are reference frame-dependent" means that the time interval between a given pair of events (like Events 3 and 4, above, for instance) that is measured by the clocks carried by observers who are in motion relative to one another, will differ from one observer to the other.

If the relative speed between the observers is small compared to the speed of light, the time difference will also be small. If, on the other hand, the speed is a largish fraction of the speed of light, the time difference can be quite noticeable.

I appreciate that most of the above has probably flown over your head. But we can get back to it later.
Dilation is enlarging. In reference to time means nothing because time doesn't exist.
If time doesn't exist, how is it that you can distinguish between Events 3 and 4, above, then? Please explain.
Like I say before, the famous relativistic phrases or terms mean nothing until you establish with certainty that time exists.
Do all events happen at once, Luchito? Or could it be that different events happen at - shock! horror! - different times?

Maybe see what that life experience of yours tells you about this, before you answer.
You have bot showed such a thing yet.
Nevertheless, I'm pretty sure that my eating cornflakes last week was not the same event as my eating cornflakes yesterday.

How do you want me to show you that events can happen at different times? Isn't it obvious to you?
 
Last edited:
(continued...)

I have been reading your replies and you confused motion of things with time existence.
I very much doubt it.

Motion usually refers to velocity, which involves both distance and time. It's why the speedometer in your car has units of miles per hour. Miles (distance) divided by time (hours). Get it?
OK, if you say so.
Great!
Now is my turn, the fairy tooth left one dollar bill under my pillow once.
Do you have evidence that supports that claim? Remember: I have lots of evidence for the existence of time and for the existence of time dilation.
It appears that you have no idea of what was going on the first time the clocks were just transported from one place to another. These clocks are so sensitive because the process is by transmission of signals that moving an atomic clock from sea level to a third floor level,the data just suffered some modification. Essen, the inventor of this clock knew this from the very beginning.
Are you aware that clocks can be designed so that their timing is not affected by bumping the container the clock is in, and similar? This has been true for at least 200 years.
Waste of money those experiments.
How could you know that, seeing as you haven't looked at any of them?

You didn't read any of the papers I cited for you, did you?

Anyway, even assuming the experiments were a waste of money, that wouldn't mean the results obtained by them aren't valid.
I used to have TV in one of my cars. I bought it from China and installed it in my car. As long as I was parked the TV images were clear and neat, but as soon as I moved the vehicle interference caused the image to become blurred. That is what happen to atomic clocks in space.
What evidence do you have for your claim about atomic clocks in space? Got a link to a peer-reviewed paper or two I can read about that?
How hard is for to recognize this simple truth?
Not hard. Show me suitable evidence and I'll change my mind.

How about you? Can you be persuaded by evidence, Luchito?
Those clocks are precise in data but are not perfect or secured against changes in environment.
They don't have to be perfect. Just good enough.
OK, a watch in your arm will also suffer due to environment changes, but you won't notice much because your watch don't show nanoseconds, just seconds and above. But surely is affected.
My watch is good enough for its purpose. I'm not using it to test the predictions of the Theory of Relativity. Atomic clocks are MUCH better clocks than my wristwatch. You really have no idea how much better they are, do you?
You are pushing too much and you are avoiding to answer the simple request, to make a diagram and explain step by step how time dilates.
Do I have to teach you how to use a search engine next?
What is the speed of time?
Speed, as I mentioned earlier, involves both distance and time. So the idea of a "speed of time" makes no sense at all. Time doesn't move from place to place.
I watched the diagrams of Hawking with cones showing the direction of light, time and so forth. How he knew that, in other words, how he was capable to obser such a phenomenon is incredible to be understood. I only see imaginations after imaginations.
Well, that's understandable, seeing as you have no background in the mathematics necessary to properly understand the Theory of General Relativity, or even (I suspect) the (simpler) Special Theory.
Well, in that case you have millions of people saying contrary to what I say, and those millions of people can't answer my simple requests in order to accept Relativity as a scientific goal. However, if you "google it" you might find lots and lots of websites where Relativity is considered false. Use your google and find out.
I'm fully aware that there's a huge number of other people on the interwebs who are just as ignorant of science as you. Some of them have visited us here at sciforums in the past. Some of them are regular visitors right now.

The one thing you did right was to come to a place where you can learn something, if you're up for it.
Well, lets see it this was. I have provided my definition of time. My definition shows that time is nothing but an invented by us measure. So far, you have not rejected my definition, you can't prove it incorrect.
Remind me: what is your definition of time?

How can you even have a definition, if you claim that time doesn't exist? (Mind you, I have definitions of "unicorn" and "God", so there's that.)
But, on the other hand, you lack of a proper definition of time, a definition that includes its assumed "flexibility" and "attachment to each person or frame of reference. This means that millions of people definitively might be wrong. Don't you think?
Yes. Millions of people have been wrong in the past. And millions of people will be wrong in the future. About all kinds of things.
In science definitions must be clear, concise and capable to be proved, tested and more, things that your definition lacks.
Science isn't really in the business of proving things. At least, not in the way that mathematics is.

I agree with you that in science definitions should be clear.
Everybody knows that if you don't accept evolution theory then you won't get a biology related diploma. Tell me about it.
Did they kick you out of biology class because you were/are a creationist, Luchito? Or did you just fail the subject?
Pulling your legs and making great profit by doing it.
Interesting. Please tell me who makes a profit from pushing the lie of Relativity onto the public. Where does the money come from, and who gets it all?

I'm wondering if I can get a cut of the profits. ;)
If a god exists, I guess the only tests will be for knowing what kind of god or similar.
So, you're saying there can be tests that can falsify certain kinds of gods, are you? Like what?
I told you before that decades ago several web sites published experiment after experiment regarding Relativity proving them false. You appear to ignore about them.
Did those who conducted these ground-breaking and revolutionary experiments ever collect their Nobel prizes for proving Relativity wrong? I don't remember ever reading anything about that.

Perhaps we can discuss these peer-reviewed experiments published on ... ahem ... websites, in a different thread. If you want to.
Like I say, you are living very happy with Relativity, and I didn't want to perturb your happiness, but you have asked for.
It might make me very happy to debunk evaluate the experiments to which you refer. In a different thread.
The recipe given by Relativity lacks the main ingredient: existing time.
Nah. I don't think so.
 
Last edited:
Luchito:

I'll get to your light refraction and gravitational lensing stuff next, but here's a quick one:
That is turkey stuff for thanksgiving dinner.

More turkey stuff.


More turkey staff, and we are close to November.


And more turkey stuff. I don't say is not useful but is just added stuff. The turkey is the real meal, so let's continue with it.


Because a person doesn't believe in evolution, such won't automatically make him a religious person.


I tell you something. I prefer you to describe what is the article about. And yes, you can add the website as "bibliography" or reference. Thanks.
There's really no substance in this post of yours that requires any response from me. I assume you were unable to refute any of the statements I made in any way, so you decided to just label them "turkey stuff", as if merely waving at them derisively were equivalent to an argument.

Just so you know: it isn't. You'll need to try harder if you want anybody to take you seriously.

I might add that it is incredibly disrespectful to attempt to dismiss and deride somebody who is patiently trying to help you, in the way that you did here. Didn't your mother teach you any manners?
 
Luchito:

So, let's talk about refraction of light etc., now.
Of course refraction of light is a known physical phenomenon, but it causes illusions.
It can make things appear to be in places where they are not, certainly. So, I don't disagree with this.
You see the reference in the 1919 expeditions plaques. The image of the star located near the Sun was displaced, refraction of light is a sure thing.
You didn't do what I asked you to do.

I asked you to show me a suitable reference that confirms that the sun's atmosphere is able to explain the observed bending of starlight, without the need for general relativity.

I am to take it that you can't come up with any plausible references that support this claim of yours, then? I will assume that is the case unless and until you produce something.
Yes, we can do that doing experiments we can control from the very beginning. But, for example, you take same pictures of the image of the star near the sun when the sun suffers abnormal huge storms, something out of your control, then the displacement of the image will suffer those effects.
Show me a reputable reference (e.g. a peer-reviewed journal paper would be fine) that confirms this.
Let me ask you something, and think about it.
Again, you didn't answer the question I asked you. I asked: How do you account for the many images of distant galaxies that show distortions entirely consistent with gravitational lensing, as predicted by general relativity?

Am I to assume that you can't account for this data, then? I will assume you can't until you show me a reputable reference to the contrary.

In the meantime...
Let me ask you something, and think about it. When you talk about "gravity", where the greatest influence of gravity is located: close to body or farther away from it? Let's say, close to the center of the galaxy or close to its edge?
At its edge.
Close to the center of the galaxy seems to be the correct answer.
Wrong answer. Remember that it's mass that causes light to bend. If all the mass of a galaxy is on one side of a light ray (i.e. a ray passing near the edge of the galaxy), that ray will be bent more than if it passes through the galaxy closer to the centre (because, in that case, there's mass on both sides).
Then, how in the world, you claim that the image of the bodies near the edge of the galaxy can be so badly influence by so poor gravity level of the galaxy?
I don't understand your question.
I point cosmic dust as a better cause of some mirages observed in space.
Dust can't account for the lensing effects we see that are exactly as predicted by the General Theory of Relativity.
Forget about "calculations" because numbers can be manipulated to fit anything a mathematician can claim.
Sorry to break it to you, Luchito, but modern physics is a quantitative science. Modern theories such as the Theory of Relativity don't just make vague hand-waving predictions like "gee guys, like, maybe light can bend a bit when it passes a star". Instead, they make predictions like "If light passes a star that has mass M, at a distance r from the centre of the star, then the angle of deflection of the light will be theta" and those M,r and theta values will be precisely numerically calculable, so they can be precisely compared with experimental measurements.

Did you not know this, Luchito? Well, now you know.
 
Last edited:
(continued...)
Well, the guy already take for granted the assumed gravitational lens.
Nope. The point is to numerically compare the precise behaviour predicted by the General Theory of Relativity with mathematically quantified observational data. No assumption is made in advance as to whether the predictions of the theory will match the observations. That is the result that emerges at the end of the analysis.

This is why the study provides evidence that the General Theory is correct.

Understand?
Tell him to replace his title with atmospheric lens, or refraction by cosmic dust, and so forth. My guess his numbers will be the same.
You should have read the paper. But you didn't. Right?
CAn nyou notice that these guys are pushing a lot other kind of measures when the simplest way is to send another expedition to same locations in Africa and Brazil, same telescopes and verify the results?
The paper provides independent evidence for the theory of relativity. In other words, it just adds to the the mountain of existing evidence obtained by other studies.
Other way to see it is, who reviewed his works? You?
Experts in the relevant scientific sub-discipline. That's what peer review means. The people who are most competent to assess the work assess it.
Yes, you habve lots of propaganda...
I have lots of evidence. You just don't like it. Without even having looked at it.
... but tell them to deny that refraction of light causing illusions is also the answer.
Do you honestly think that astronomers don't considered refraction of light in their observations and calculations?

You really have no idea, do you?

These are experts, Luchito. Not people with ideological axes to grind or a fixation on "intellectual elites" or whatever the issue is that stops you from wanting to learn.
While my position is backed up with solid recognized observations and experiments, what those studies show that those are made based on blind faith: time dilates.
Please cite the relevant papers or other sources that contain your solid recognised observations and experiments.

If you can't do that, I think it will be fair for me to assume you're just making it up. Don't you?

I showed you mine. You turn to show me yours.
Yeah, Money buys lots of things.
Yes, including expensive space telescopes and the like. Which, as it happens, are really great for testing theories such as the General Theory of Relativity.
No a single contradiction, everything fits exactly as predicted.
Well, not exactly. But within experimental uncertainty. Scientists are very careful to quantify uncertainties, you know.
I see more fantasy in those studies than in the bible with a talking mule.
See, the thing is, Luchito: nobody cares what you think about any of these studies. Do you know why? It's because you have already demonstrated that you're completely unequipped to offer any meaningful commentary on them. That's because you don't even understand what theories are being tested or how they are being tested.

Let's face it: you didn't even read the papers. Did you?

Luckily, you have me taking pity on you and trying to lead you a little way towards the light. Right now, you're just sort of lost and angry at the world. But it will take effort from you to get you back on track. You have to want it.
Sure. Eddington lied and committed fraud doing make up to the plaques. He convinced the Astronomer Royal to validate his claims and validate Relativity theory. It was found later that such results weren't correct, that better pictures came from Newton's prediction and that Eddington made fool the Astronomer Royal. What the Royal Society will do? No other thing but to push hard to keep such validation as secured forever and that his Astronomer Royal was never a fool. This is a case of pride versus truth. Pride won.
How would you respond to the arguments in the paper I linked to you about those observations etc, then?

You didn't read it, did you?
The motion of the mortar mix line is the illusion, the cause is the phenomenon called mirage.
If you like.
When you know that the reason of the displacement of the image of the star in question was caused by the sun atmosphere, then those 100 plus years supporting Relativity have no value at all.
But I don't know that.

I have now asked you several times to show me the data that supports your claim that the observed deflection of light can be explained by refraction in the Sun's atmosphere.

You have come up with a blank. It seems like you have no data or arguments to support your specific claim.
There is a big machine, mentioned indirectly by Asimov, protecting the accepted science and rejecting any attempt to overcoming it.
No. Scientists win prizes for overturning "accepted science" and for discovering new science, not for "protecting" accepted science.

Every scientist is working her hardest to try to prove existing theories wrong and/or to find new facts about the world that no scientist has found before.

It's what scientists are paid to do.

Somebody lied to you when they told you that there's a conspiracy of scientists to try to protect a dogma. That's not how science works. That's something we tend to see in religion, not science.

If what you say is true, then there would be no technological advances. Anybody who dared to try to invent something new would be persecuted by the "protectors" of "accepted science", and their inventions destroyed or hidden away.

This is not what we observe in the real world.
For you information, I was participating in discussions forums decades ago, when there were hundreds if no thousands of websites, where even Lorentz was challenged just by moving a coordinate and his work became peanuts.
Seems like those thousands of websites that disproved Lorentz gained no traction with mainstream science. I'm guessing that most of them just disappeared with a whimper, overcome by the power of actual science.

Is that what happened, Luchito?
Today, with all the technology available same AI is incapable to think the possibility of a challenger against Relativity, because it has been manipulated to provide solely favoring articles for Relativity.
It has been trained on data from the entire internet, including on what all the pseudoscientists and naysayers like yourself have to say about science. Clearly, for whatever reason, all that training has resulted in the AIs overwhelmingly accepting science over pseudoscience as the best model of reality. For what it's worth.
However, with all that in your hands, you still can't answer the simple requests made by me. Isn't something?
Which simple requests can't I answer? I've tried to be reasonably thorough in my responses to your questions. Would you like me to post more in each of my responses to you? Do you think you can keep up with me?

Meanwhile, as you can see from these replies to your most recent posts, you're seriously struggling to come up with anything to support any of your anti-science claims, other than your own ill-informed opinions.
You just can't define properly what is time...
See above.
... you can't make a simple diagram showing how time dilates.
Oh, I can. I choose not to, because a brief internet search would turn up many diagrams for you. Do your own homework.

No learning ever comes with zero effort, Luchito.
I wonder, how far blind faith can reach?
It can reach far enough to make a person deny the obvious. We see that all the time here at sciforums.
 
Last edited:
Luchito:
Do you really need an exact calculation of a image displacement caused by a mirage to accept that such phenomenon happens?
Yes, I really do, to be satisfied that the mechanism suggested to explain the mirage is actually able to explain it.
You can't predict mathematically what you can't control.
You are wrong (again). I explained why, previously. You were rude enough to ignore my previous response, so I won't repeat it for your benefit.
Look at the results favoring Relativity.

From Brazil expedition the plaques able to be measured were 1.86 and 2.1seonds of arc , results given by a 4" telescope. From astrograph takings the results were an average 8.6.

From Africa expedition, the plaques were all of them blurred, but Eddington continued working with them regardless. The available ones to be considered gave 1.31 and 1.91 seconds of arc displacement. From here comes 1.61 seconds arc, well below 1,7 seconds arc predicted by Einstein. Here is where the magic hands of Eddington acted w=and the miracle happened, the average amount became 1.7.

And you claim that relativity prediction was validated by "precise" result.
I will be happy to engage with you on this once you demonstrate to me that you have read the 2022 paper that I cited for you about those observations.
Well, were everybody is blind, the one-eyed man rules. If current science accepts false theories of science that are included in high level studies, then I have a great advantage over them.
Don't tell me you don't know what the Dunning-Kruger effect is...
I was using an analogy or a similar phenomenon to prove atmospheric lens. My lens is way more accepted than the gravitational one.
Apparently not, judging by the scientific literature on the matter.
There are sure evidence of medium acting as lens creating mirages, displacement of images and more. The causes of the phenomena are by elements, particles and similar identified by science.
In the atmosphere, yes.

Did you know that gravitational lensing is observed to occur in the vacuum of space?

Explain that, Luchito.
On the other hand, up to today, gravity still is considered as a force and calculations are made using that force instead of using gravity as part of time united with time forming together the fabric of the universe.
Horses for courses. It's fine to think of gravity as a force for some purposes (e.g. low masses, small speeds, relative small volumes of space, etc.) We only need to bring out the big guns to explain some of the more complicated stuff.

The point is: the force picture gives us a reasonable approximation to how gravity actually works, under appropriate restrictions. Newtonian gravity was good enough for 400 years, after all.
You have repeated such "100+ years of real-world experimental data" phrase so many times that I am afraid I am debating with an AI branch. But well.
It appears you missed the point. Real-world experiments that produce data that precisely matches the predictions of a scientific theory tend to support the claim that the scientific theory is an accurate description of nature. That applies no matter which scientific theory we're considering.
From all those so called experiments made supporting Relativity predictions...
You mean those experiments made supporting Relativity predictions. They were real experiments, not fake experiments.
... can you explain with layman language one of them?
Yes. Didn't I already do that for you, with the muon experiment? Or was that somebody else?

I don't need to use AI, by the way. I know stuff, you see.
Knowledge in the 1900 was that time flows. I don't think that time flows. What about you?
I'm on the fence. If I had to choose, I think I'd say that it doesn't. But I think it's still an open question.

I'm also not entirely sure whether "flows" has been well defined. Certainly, you have made no attempt to tell me what you mean by it.
Relativity is a huge beautiful building constructed over a base of sand. It has been condemned because its structural problems.
Only pseudoscientists make that kind of claim in that way.
Point is that, in reality Einstein was indeed a looney. No joke.
Why do you think so? What do you know of Einstein the man?
Well, the answer is very simple. You see the 1919 star image displacement, well, such is refraction of light.
Show me the theory and data that support your claim.
The imagination claims is gravitational cause.
The experimental results - including ones published in the past 10 years - support the theory.

You just don't like that they support it, so you reject them, without even reading the papers, apparently.

Ho hum. Just another ignorant naysayer. You guys are a dime a dozen.
Then, we have a case were contradiction appears.
Which case?
The most common answer is refraction of light, because can be proved and even tested in lab.
Show me the proof that refraction by the Sun can account for the results of the 1919 experiment.

I keep asking you. You keep coming up with nada.
When you watch all the pictures related to relativity, including black holes, and others, all of them are manipulated images, and you happily accept them. I don't see what you point is.
What evidence do you have that any images have been manipulated? Please give me a few examples.
 
Last edited:
No Ghost in This Shell:
I disagree, see my explanations in post #161 - relativity is already too well established via experiment and observation to ever be found "false" in the sense that it would be struck off all textbooks. What would happen, rather, is the same that happened to Newtonian mechanics after it was found to make incorrect predictions in some circumstances; namely, we would recognise that its domain of applicability is limited, but continue teaching and using it within its own regime. Relativity is in fact somewhat unusual among models of physics in that we haven't unambiguously determined yet just how far its domain of applicability really extends, particularly in the case of Special Relativity (we already know now that GR is limited at most to the classical regime).
I agree with you about all of that.

We know for sure that if Relativity is wrong, it is still nearly correct in many situations. Any new theory that replaces Relativity will have to account for all of its correct predictions, within the limits in which they have been confirmed.

To put it another way, the Theory of Relativity will have to still be correct as some kind of limiting case or approximation to the theory that replaces it, in the same way that Galilean Relativity is still correct as an approximation to the Special Theory of Relativity in the limit of low speeds and not-too-large distances.
My personal feeling is that also SR might eventually break down at extremely high energies, but this remains to be seen.
Interesting. In what way do you think it might break down?
 
Last edited:
God can keep such a mass of water up in the clouds
he lifts it up by his solar energy, heat that evaporates water, then lifts it by boyancy, (water vapor is lighter than air), and then lifts it some more by the expansion powered by the heat of condensation. 3 lifts. felt it in the seat of my pants. Updrafts can reach 300km/h judging by the size of hailstones ( another bible topic ).
Even gravity is the equivalent of an acceleration, not possible without energy
matter itself has an energy equivalent too, awesome.
 
Job tried to show God how much he knew and the reply from God showed how much Job ignored.
imho, no, -- He, Job, was affirming his confidence in his Creator, born of past experiences, came up with some inspired -science proven- truism. lesson?
We ignore our father's laws at our own peril
available energy used recklessly will bring destruction. Rev 11:18.
 
We know for sure that if Relativity is wrong, it is still nearly correct in many situations. Any new theory that replaces Relativity will have to account for all of its correct predictions, within the limits in which they have been confirmed.

To put it another way, the Theory of Relativity will have to still be correct as some kind of limiting case or approximation to the theory that replaces it, in the same way that Galilean Relativity is still correct as an approximation to the Special Theory of Relativity in the limit of low speeds and not-too-large distances.
Spot on
Interesting. In what way do you think it might break down?
There are in fact various ways for it to potentially break down, but specifically my gut feeling tells me that at high enough energies, spacetime itself might cease to be modellable (is that even a word?) as a smooth, continuous manifold in the usual way. It is anyone's guess what kind of microscopic structures, geometries and topologies might emerge if one abandons smoothness and continuity, but pretty much all of them pose a problem to Lorentz invariance, which is after all a continuous symmetry. Of course I can't rule out that this invariance somehow survives even on a non-continuous spacetime, but I find it rather unlikely.
 
Back
Top