Science question based on limited understanding - starlight refraction.

Ok, average density. GOOGLE Ai sculptor

    • Interstellar space (inside galaxies): About 1 million to 1 trillion molecules or atoms per cubic meter (\(10^{6}\) to \(10^{12}\text{ m}^{-3}\)) in dense clouds, dropping to roughly 0.25 to a few atoms per cubic meter in hot, diffuse regions. [1, 2]
    • Interplanetary space (inside the solar system): About 9,000 to 25 million protons/atoms per cubic meter near Earth due to the solar wind, dropping to about 1,000 atoms per cubic meter near the edge of the Solar System. [1, 2]
    • Intergalactic space (between galaxies): Only about 0.2 to 10 atoms per cubic meter. [1, 2]
    • Cosmic average (entire universe): About 0.3 ordinary matter (baryonic) atoms per cubic meter (or roughly 5.9 total particles including dark matter and neutrinos when measuring total mass-energy density). [1]
 
Last edited:
Does a pure vacuum actually exist?
anywhere?
1. Note that, whether or not any given volume is a perfect vacuum, it does not stop us from measuring the speed of light in a vacuum. Any more than a couple of towns interspersed along an interstate highway will prevent us from measuring the top speed of our VW bus, if we're careful about it.


2. That being said, even that is inaccurate, since we know exactly what the speed of light is. It is defined to be 299,792,458m/s.
A metre's length is defined as the distance light travels in 1/299,792,458 of a second.
 
Note that, whether or not any given volume is a perfect vacuum, it does not stop us from measuring the speed of light in a vacuum. Any more than a couple of towns interspersed along an interstate highway will prevent us from measuring the top speed of our VW bus, if we're careful about it.
That's a good analogy.
 
Pyab,
Light moved through a medium and a specific speed, always labelled c but the speed attached to c may differ, is that correct?
The symbol 'c' is typically used in physics to mean the speed of light in vacuum, which is a universal constant as far as we can tell.

The speed of light in a medium that has refractive index n is v=c/n.

For example, n is close to 1.33 for water, it is only slightly greater than 1 for air, for glass it is usually close to 1.5.
So the actual question - my (potentially flawed) understanding is that the difference in c between different media results in refraction, like the prism experiment, white light in, differences in speed results in different angles of refraction, and we get a pretty wee rainbow.....
Rainbows are actually due to a combination of reflection and refraction by water droplets in the air. The primary rainbow you see is formed when light rays pass from air into a water droplet (refracting in the process), then reflect off the back inside surface of the droplet, then refract out the front again, towards your eyes. The sun is always behind you when you see a rainbow.
My thinking, again possibly based on incorrect assumptions - space within our solar system is "contained" by the heliopause (incorrect term? one of many terms? not sure - the boundary between us and actual interstellar space)
Not exactly, as I understand it. The heliopause, if I remember correctly, is just the surface surrounding the solar system where "pressure" from the solar wind is balanced by pressure of particles from the interstellar medium. It's not like a hard barrier. In fact, I think that both Voyager probes have passed through it at this time.
would it be safe to assume that the heliopause would be basically uniform around our system...
I don't think so. Our Sun is moving around the centre of the galaxy. The heliopause is kind of shaped like the shock wave around an aeroplane that is breaking the sound barrier.
Yeah - never been able to get my head round that....especially when, if you were on the other side of the same light beam from myself, but you are doing 10 times the speed i am - we would still, both, measure the same light beam as doing C...............i understand thats true, but fuck me, its unfair to expect us lowly humans to understand why....well this lowly human at least...
I can give you a formula, if that helps at all. Suppose you (A) are travelling at speed vA relative to somebody else (B) and another person (C) is travelling in the same direction at speed vC' relative to you. Then B will measure the speed of C to be"

vC=(vA + vC')/(1+(vA)(vC')/c^2)

So, for example, suppose you (A) are going at (0.75)c relative to Earth (B) and you see somebody else (C) pass you going at (0.5)c relative to you, you might think that intuitively the guy on Earth would measure the speed of C to be (1.25)c, which would be faster than the speed of light. But the formula gives:

vC=(0.75 +0.5)c/(1+(0.75)(0.5)) = (0.91)c

which is slower than the speed of light.
 
Does a pure vacuum actually exist?
anywhere?
Depends what you mean by a "pure" vacuum.

If you mean a region of space with no matter or photons in it, sure.

If you mean a region of space with no quantum fields in it, you're out of luck.
 
On the part of your question about the speed of light in a medium (air, water, glass etc), yes the phase velocity of light, i.e. the speed at which the wave crests pass a given point, does reduce compared to c, the value in a vacuum. The reason is that the electrons in the substance tend to get polarised by the electric field wave of the light and move back and forth, more or less in synch with it. This has a similar effect to what happens if you try to run on a trampoline: when you take a step you put energy into the trampoline and get it back via rebound a bit later. So it slows you down. (The actual details require quantum mechanics but that gives you a picture of the process.)

The degree to which this happens depends on how close the wavelength of the light is to one of the wavelengths at which the substance absorbs light. For instance in glass there is an absorption band in the ultra violet. The result is that shorter wavelength blue light is slowed down more than longer wavelength red light, because blue is closer to the UV absorption frequency than red. This is why a prism bends blue light more than red, and other colours in between to varying degrees, creating a rainbow spectrum when you shine white light through it. In physics terminology the refractive index of glass for blue light is greater than for red light. The closer to the absorption frequency the light is, the more it is slowed down. And, yes you've guessed, if it is at exactly the absorption frequency it is stopped! In other words at that frequency the light is absorbed.

So refractive index is linked to the process responsible for the absorption spectrum of a material. I had no idea of this connection until 2nd year at uni and I found it pretty amazing.

The slower speed of light in a medium is not referred to as c. In fact refractive index is the ratio of c, the speed in a vacuum to the speed in the medium. So refractive index values are greater than 1, the higher they are the more the light is slowed down. For glass the value depends on the type of glass but it is around 1.5. For diamond it is 2.4, far higher, which is why a cut diamond sparkles so much (this is the property that gives them value as gemstones.)
ahhh danke - i think i actually understand that mostly, the trampoline analogy especially i find helpful.

cheers very much
 
Pyab,

The symbol 'c' is typically used in physics to mean the speed of light in vacuum, which is a universal constant as far as we can tell.

The speed of light in a medium that has refractive index n is v=c/n.

For example, n is close to 1.33 for water, it is only slightly greater than 1 for air, for glass it is usually close to 1.5.

Rainbows are actually due to a combination of reflection and refraction by water droplets in the air. The primary rainbow you see is formed when light rays pass from air into a water droplet (refracting in the process), then reflect off the back inside surface of the droplet, then refract out the front again, towards your eyes. The sun is always behind you when you see a rainbow.

Not exactly, as I understand it. The heliopause, if I remember correctly, is just the surface surrounding the solar system where "pressure" from the solar wind is balanced by pressure of particles from the interstellar medium. It's not like a hard barrier. In fact, I think that both Voyager probes have passed through it at this time.

I don't think so. Our Sun is moving around the centre of the galaxy. The heliopause is kind of shaped like the shock wave around an aeroplane that is breaking the sound barrier.

I can give you a formula, if that helps at all. Suppose you (A) are travelling at speed vA relative to somebody else (B) and another person (C) is travelling in the same direction at speed vC' relative to you. Then B will measure the speed of C to be"

vC=(vA + vC')/(1+(vA)(vC')/c^2)

So, for example, suppose you (A) are going at (0.75)c relative to Earth (B) and you see somebody else (C) pass you going at (0.5)c relative to you, you might think that intuitively the guy on Earth would measure the speed of C to be (1.25)c, which would be faster than the speed of light. But the formula gives:

vC=(0.75 +0.5)c/(1+(0.75)(0.5)) = (0.91)c

which is slower than the speed of light.
cheers dude, i get the Ex explained some of it as well - so its in there now and the question - i consider it answered and my theory - debunked lol.

I am annoyed about the heliopause, because i knew the shape of the heliopause, and remember the graphic of its shape as it circles the galaxy, i had just forgotten it and so didn't consider it in my question - cheers for reminding me.

the formula does not help at all ;) i believe you, it just doesn't help make it any more intuitive lol
 
ahhh danke - i think i actually understand that mostly, the trampoline analogy especially i find helpful.

cheers very much
Yes there are a lot of "explanations" of why light slows down in a medium on YouTube etc., but many of them are a bit misleading. The rigorous explanation is very mathematical, to do with the quantum mechanics of "polarisability" of materials, and to be honest I no longer remember the maths of it (it was over 50 years ago). However my pictorial trampoline analogy was said to be sort of OK by a mathematical physicist whom I trust on another forum, so I feel I can use it without too much fear of talking ballocks. :)

The diamond sparkling involves another phenomenon that you may recall from school physics, which is "total internal reflection". If a light beam inside a medium hits the interface with another one of lower refractive index, e.g. light passing from water into air or from within a diamond into air, part of the beam passes through and part is reflected back off the interface. However if the angle of incidence is shallow enough, 100% is reflected, which is called total internal reflection. There is a critical angle at which total internal reflection sets in and the bigger the difference in refractive index between the media the steeper that angle is. For diamond this results in a lot of total internal reflection. A diamond is cut to promote this so the light bounces around inside, reflecting off the surfaces and emerges at particular points, depending on the angle from which it is viewed. A piece of glass cut the same way has not nearly such a strong effect because total internal reflection only sets in at shallower angles of incidence.

But I digress from the thread topic.
 
Continuing down my chemical physics rabbit hole, I was bothered by why diamond has a higher refractive index than glass. Both have an absorption band in the UV around 200nm, so it can’t be due to diamond having an absorption band closer to the visible region. What I found, though, is that diamond has the highest number density of atoms of all crystalline materials, i.e. no. of atoms per unit volume. This will be because carbon is a small atom forming short bonds with its neighbours in the crystal, hence a relatively small interatomic spacing.

I think that must be the reason. In a given path length there are far more polarisable atoms for the light to interact with. So they slow it down more. Good. Now I will be able to sleep well tonight. :)
 
Continuing down my chemical physics rabbit hole, I was bothered by why diamond has a higher refractive index than glass. Both have an absorption band in the UV around 200nm, so it can’t be due to diamond having an absorption band closer to the visible region. What I found, though, is that diamond has the highest number density of atoms of all crystalline materials, i.e. no. of atoms per unit volume. This will be because carbon is a small atom forming short bonds with its neighbours in the crystal, hence a relatively small interatomic spacing.

I think that must be the reason. In a given path length there are far more polarisable atoms for the light to interact with. So they slow it down more. Good. Now I will be able to sleep well tonight. :)
The explanation was much more involved than I thought it was from memory. QED required? I think I read a thread on PF.
 
Are you sure of that?
Yep. There are free atoms floating around everywhere. But choose a small enough volume and you can guarantee there is nothing material in it (other than quantum foam, which gives the vacuum energy level, and dark matter, if such is ever proven.)
 
Depends what you mean by a "pure" vacuum.

If you mean a region of space with no matter or photons in it, sure.

If you mean a region of space with no quantum fields in it, you're out of luck.
Quantum fields...............................and or waves
OK: I ain't completely confused yet........But, I am working on it!
I can parrot back the words "quantum field ... waves" but i do not understand what it means.
quantum waves ---I picture interacting waves in a pond---or ocean
compound to create wave crests(could this be the excitation of/in the quantum field?) and troughs, or cancel each other leading to the level of calm water
and then we have the casimir effect---which seems an awful lot like gravity to me..........I ain't completely confused yet........But, I am working on it!
explain
please
please start with the difference between the casimir effect and gravity
confusedly yours
rod
 
Quantum fields...............................and or waves
OK: I ain't completely confused yet........But, I am working on it!
I can parrot back the words "quantum field ... waves" but i do not understand what it means.
quantum waves ---I picture interacting waves in a pond---or ocean
compound to create wave crests(could this be the excitation of/in the quantum field?) and troughs, or cancel each other leading to the level of calm water
and then we have the casimir effect---which seems an awful lot like gravity to me..........I ain't completely confused yet........But, I am working on it!
explain
please
please start with the difference between the casimir effect and gravity
confusedly yours
rod
Gravity and the Casimir effect are unrelated.

The Casimir effect is due to London forces between a pair of plates separated by a narrow gap. It can equivalently be described in terms of the difference in random electromagnetic fluctuations in the vacuum, inside the gap relative to those in free space. London forces arise from random fluctuations in the electron distribution of atoms. The two can be shown to be mathematically equivalent, though don’t ask me to explain exactly how. This is a quantum phenomenon.

Gravitation is treated in general relativity as arising from the effect of energy and momentum, notably the rest energy associated with mass, on the curvature of spacetime. This is not a quantum phenomenon.

The force of attraction between the plates due to the Casimir effect is many orders of magnitude stronger than the attractive force of gravity.
 
Back
Top