Science is not God

duendy said:
me))yes te 'science' of psychology applies biology to behaviours it deems unacceptable subjectively which is false science

no, it doesn't. certain people will apply biology to behavior they deem unnacceptable, but a scientist trained in how to properly research/test a subject won't look at it that way. psychology is the study of the mind, we use its discoveries to help us understand how the mind works. the evidence we find and the research we do because of what we find shows that biological processes (balance of chemicals and structure of the brain) relate to a person's personality. if anything in psychology is known, its this. but there is also the interaction of the electromagnetic field, which hardly anything is known about.

duendy said:
mePPi am viewing that definition as materialistic. for we cant just reduce being to cehmical structure. that is a major point and the problem with the mental health ideology. what cannot be measured is an individuals subjectiviy. for example takea look at 'The Hard Problem' (David Chalmers). where he shows we cannot KNOW, scientifically, what another subjectively feels

i am not reducing the human being to a chemical structure. there are still many unknown variables lying within the connection between the neuronal structure of the mind, the electricity travelling through it, and the chemicals the mind releases. what is the use in viewing everything as mystical? it only leaves us in ignorance. it only makes us stagnate, and if anything can be learned from the universe its that stagnation leads to death. There is just as much awe in how the mind is revealed to work as there is in any myth you can come up with, perhaps even more. you want to fight against the oppression of mainstream science, yet when i try to open your eyes to real science, you're just as dismissive as the people who shove pills down childrens' throats.

duendy said:
as i say. we cant look at human life or ANY life as the sum of chemicals or elctrical activity....what as in individual FEELScannot be actually measured. The Hard Problem is revealingnhow science does not understand consciousness in its entireity. Thus to blindly drug behaviours we do not understand is wrong.....You are alomst there--sorry to seem patronizing--but dont seem to get beyond te rductiveidea w are JUS chemical reactions. yes that is part of it, but certainly not ALL of it.
what mental hygene indctrinates is a state demanded by the State. 'normalcy' as it is subjectively understood to be by the powers of an oppressive culture, which actually causes itself much of te distress we see, in individuals, other species, and Nature
you reveal yourself to be just as hypocritcal and ignorant as the people you call oppressive with these statements. of course we don't understand consciousness in its entirety. we don't understand anything in its entirety and we never will. i don't believe that the human mind, nor any mind, can be reduced to just chemical and electrical interactions, but those interactions are a big part of it. most likely, anything more would be inherent in either those chemical or electrical reactions, rather than some completely different and new system.
 
Huwy said:
I think I will contact Fred Baughman, but I was flat out with exams and now I'm looking after my little brother who is very sick. When he's better I'll think about contacting him.

Huwy, there's no point in arguing with Duendy. She is illogical, unlearned and I suspect there is a much deeper problem behind her refusal of real science, particularly psychology.

I've begun to wonder if it may be that at a younger age she was actually diagnosed with a mental illness. For one thing, she's obviously paranoid and overly obsessed with many things. She's also destroyed a part of her mind with LSD and other hallucinative drugs.

And since her family (and others) have undoubtedly told her she was "crazy", she has rebelled against all professional science.

I could possibly find it in me to feel pity for her, as I do many others, if it were not for the fact that the majority of her problems are self-inflicted.

She will not listen to reason because there IS no reason within her. Facts mean nothing and carry no weight. She clearly - and without reservation - stated once that "everything she knows" came as a result of trips on LSD.

So how can anyone feel pity or remorse for such a fool as that?
 
Avatar said:
Why not, have you any evidence apart from your subjective experience that counters that?

me)))have YOU any evidence that states we are JUST chemica, electrical 'computers'? as i keep saying, in cognitive science we have the 'brain/mind problem' also called the Hard Problem. it is a problem. aint been sorted yet. have you worked it out? please present your thesis to te people then if so. whatya waitin for kid gooo forrr itttt!

Consciousness is a process (biochemical and electrical reactions) where brain (It can be other organs or cells too) evaluates incoming (or new, self created) information against the data that has already been stored in it. There is no need for something more to have consciousness.
We talked about that in the consciousness thread here at Sciforums.

me)))))hah. you mean YOU talked about it completely takin over te debate wid dyour homies. does 'we already have talked about it in your consciousness thread. MEAN to YOU that the problem is solved?....in your world maybe. not mine. you are not listening. i suggest you red about The Hard Problem (David Chalmers) for your homework, and thehn get back. for you are rally not saying anything

Again, subjective perception, chemical induced visions, experience, etc. is not evidence.
no, you are totally not gettin it Avatar. who are you thinkin you are? some very serious minds in science are wondering how subjective consciousness came to be. and here you ar just regurgitating amatuer physicalist ideas. not good enough. could do better.
we are much more tat just hemcial reaction. sad you feel such a machine. maybe it could explain a few tings..........
 
we are much more tat just hemcial reaction
You have no evidence to prove this, or you would have mentioned it in the previous discussions.
All that you do is say how wrong I am, nothing more,
but you haven't disproved my definition not by a little.
 
Avatar said:
You have no evidence to prove this, or you would have mentioned it in the previous discussions.
All that you do is say how wrong I am, nothing more,
but you haven't disproved my definition not by a little.
look....watch my type---neither have YOU evidence humans etc are all merely chemical and electrical machines. agreed?

next.....so then we havethe HARD PROBLEM.

now. my mate avatar. what part of the Hard Problem BEING A Hard Problem dont you understand??
 
My definition explains everything about consciousness.
Not in the smallest detail, it is too short for that, but in general it does and nothing points against it. There is no problem.
The evidence is that which physics, biology and basic neurology provide.
There are some questions that remain to be answered though, but they fall well within the definition.
But this is offtopic, refer to the consciousness thread in the Philosophy section.
 
Laika said:
As I have asked a couple of times already, do you deny that alzheimers is a mental illness?
Laika...i told you i had contacted Dr Fred Baughman about your query. I received his reply earlier on, here it is:

"Progressive dementia, loss of memory, immediate, current more than remote, long-term is the hall-mark of AD. There is no test in life that is confirmatory of AD but at autopsy all have diffuse brain abnormality with that of AD quite specific for that disease. Though AD appears in the DSM it is a neurological disease as are all diseases confirming microscopic abnormalities of the brain--not true of any mental/psychiatric illness." (Dr Fred Baughman, private communication)
 
duendy said:
Laika...i told you i had contacted Dr Fred Baughman about your query. I received his reply earlier on, here it is:

"Progressive dementia, loss of memory, immediate, current more than remote, long-term is the hall-mark of AD. There is no test in life that is confirmatory of AD but at autopsy all have diffuse brain abnormality with that of AD quite specific for that disease. Though AD appears in the DSM it is a neurological disease as are all diseases confirming microscopic abnormalities of the brain--not true of any mental/psychiatric illness." (Dr Fred Baughman, private communication)

Ho-ho-ho! Nice try, Duendy, but you scored exactly ZERO points on this one!

I'm very much aware of Baughman and his work and - are you ready for this? Sitting down? I'm one among many who agrees with him! His primary focus is on kids and ADHD and ADD and I'm among the first to admit that the kids are FAR over-medicated.

But what you will not hear or see him speak out against are the large number of different types of psychosis - like bipolar disorder, obsessive-compulsive, paranoia (your own personal condition), multiple-personality disorder, schizophrenia, and all the rest. Why? Because he knows those are true mental disorders. And if he did mention anything about any of them, you conveniently cut it out of what you posted.

So you gained nothing here.
 
Light...first, dont diagnose me you prize clown
secondly and finally, you haven' a clue what you are talking about, and obviously haven't understood Dr Baughman and what he is about at ALL. so maybe look in the mirror and dont laugh. cry........you clinger on to a dying world view you
 
duendy said:
Light...first, dont diagnose me you prize clown
secondly and finally, you haven' a clue what you are talking about, and obviously haven't understood Dr Baughman and what he is about at ALL. so maybe look in the mirror and dont laugh. cry........you clinger on to a dying world view you

I've got MUCH more of clue (and knowledge) than you've ever had. You are fooling no one but yourself.
 
Light said:
I've got MUCH more of clue (and knowledge) than you've ever had. You are fooling no one but yourself.
clown? you cant even compreHEND!....now thats itQ i try and not have too many dealings with trolls who disrupt serious subjects wit empty-arsed BS.
 
duendy said:
clown? you cant even compreHEND!....now thats itQ i try and not have too many dealings with trolls who disrupt serious subjects wit empty-arsed BS.

Ah, yes - and spoken by the Queen of the BS artists!

Deundy, you've probably met few like me. I'm just as paitent as you are dumb and I never give up or give in to foolish people.
 
A major drawback of scientific methodology

Selective sampling is a problem rampant in the scientific world and overlooked by the peers in most cases. There are no inbuilt checks in the scientific institution/ methodology to tackle this problem of wrong sampling, and the validity of sampling is dependant totally on the conscience of the researcher.
 
There are no inbuilt checks in the scientific institution/ methodology to tackle this problem of wrong sampling, and the validity of sampling is dependant totally on the conscience of the researcher.

LOL. Come now you must know this is incorrect.

Here is just a small subset.

Random sample
Systematic sampling
Cluster sampling
Statistical practice
Snowball sampling
Nonprobability sampling
Latin hypercube sampling
Multistage sampling
Uematsu's Best Selection
Quota sampling
Survey sampling
Median filter
Stratified sampling
Feature selection
Selection bias
Selection effect
Ewens's sampling formula
Quantitative marketing research
Sensitivity analysis
Randomization

As always your ignorance does not stop you from making off the cuff remarks.

Science represents our best effort at understanding. You may not like it, but its validity is proven via the technological result of our modern world.
 
Back
Top