duendy said:
when you say you have read the links i sent and think i am extrapolating more out of them than there really is. what do you mean?"
I partially take that back. This Dr. Fred Baughman has some very interesting and correct points, but after reading the second web page you offered (the refuting emails) I see why you so avidly attack scientific foundation.
But you are both slightly wrong there. You both make the mistake of dismissing all psychology just because pop science--materialistic science--is horribly wrong. The sole purpose of psychology is not to determine who is normal and abnormal in society. The sole purpose of psychology is to figure out how the brain works. Anyone who thinks differently, whether or not they have a doctorate, is wrong. But, as you and the doctor have stated over and over, a large chunk, perhaps even the majority of researchers and psychiatrists (at least in this nation) have deluded themselves in tradition and/or money. They don't see the difference between "personality and pathology" as it were.
Also, you're attacks on materialistic science are just that. You often tend to mistake credible science with this materialistic popscience that is buried in tradition. You dismiss the ideas of those who disagree with you without even trying to understand what they are talking about. You are not, nor ever will be, entirely correct. It would be good to listen to others for a change, whether or not you think they are correct. You can still learn something from someone even if they are completely wrong.
duendy said:
second......you seem to be confused as to whati mean by 'mental illness'--tho i am sure i would have made it clear. but heregoes agin. mental illness as itis being indoctrinated by this culture--'pharmacratic' culture (Thomas Szasz) is 'biological disease of the brain'. we are saying no it isn't if there is no evidence of organic lesion/growth.
all reports OF brain damage due to 'menal illness' are POST-medication', and the damage ahs been done BY the so-called medication which is harmful.
there are many, many different circumstances that can cause a change in the structural and/or functional state of the brain. It has been proven that physical lesions in the brain will damage/change the state of the mind. It has been proven that growths in the brain will change the state of the mind. It has nearly been proven that organic or inorganic (virii) agents can change the state of the mind. The last is a little more sketchy because it is a much more complex process. Falling down some stairs and having a concussion can damage brain cells and change the state of the brain. A growing tumor in the brain can damage brain cells and distort regions of the brain to change the state of the mind.
In fact, living can damage the brain and cause a change in the state of the mind. This is how we learn, experience, develop personalities, etc. It is all directly connected. Any damaging of the brain can change the personality of the person slightly. And this is a physical change. All our lives, the neurons in our brains are dying. These neurons die depending on how often we use them. The neurons less used will die. But this is not how it always is. Due to genetic differences, everyone's brain 'acts' differently. Some groups of neurons are favored over others and are therefore used more.
There are many things acting on the brain that can potentially cause what some people view as 'mental illness'. I dislike the term mental illness myself because it conveys a sense of abnormality or disfunction. While it is true that the characteristics associated with these 'abnormalities' are at the very ends of the bell curve, it does not mean they are disfunctional. Many of the greatest minds could be proven to have mental illnesses, and perhaps that is why their minds were great; because they were different. It is my view that the next step in human evolution--what we are now at the beginning of--is extreme differentiation. Obviously we are going to see 'abnormalities' in personality and therefore brain structure.
There is no normal, there is only differentiation and similarity between those differences. There is no abnormal, there is only differentiation. Personality is a testament to all of this.
duendy said:
yes i am aware tat peopl can be mentally distressed. really it is not just 'mental'. it is bodymind distressed. yes we agree. wat are we going to do wit say the child who is seeming very over active and is driving his prents nuts. is it a case of druggging the child and causing MORe harm--to the immediate results MA seem benign--ie for parents and teachers etc. OR are we going to look at food, drink, the school system, the community, the capacity of thechild, etc etc ? THAT. Not make up a ruddy phony disease and then harm te child. NO!
Yes, more or less. You are correct here. The real cause to most mental disorders is society itself, or at least the parents that raised the child. Often the genes of the person with the disorder cause their mind to be more susceptible to catalists of extreme differentiation. Catalists such as the environment they grow up in, or lesions of the brain, or diseases contracted.
But there is the question of what to do with these people. There are many people with extreme differentiation to the point that they are harmful to other people. Most of modern psychology is spent wondering what to do with them, rather than how to prevent them. It should not be this way.