Relative Time & Temporal Divisions: The 3ST Framework

Ray2380

Registered Member
Part1- The Core Concept & Sheet Layouts

Intro:

Hi everyone, I want to share a conceptual thought experiment and geometric hypothesis exploring an alternative interpretation of Einstein's universe. I do not have a heavy mathematical background, so I am hoping to get a conceptual, plain-English discussion on where the logic of modern spacetime interpretation might be failing.

(Note: Throughout this text, I am using 2D paper sheets as a visual analogy for 3D space to make the internal geometry easier to picture).



The Core Concept:
We often hear that space and time are "one and the same," but that language causes confusion. A more accurate description is that space and time are simply two different ways of describing one single thing—just like "yellow" and "round" are two different ways of describing the sun. You cannot separate them, meaning you cannot add a separate fourth dimension to space.

Newton said we had 3 dimensions of space and a separate dimension of time—Absolute time. Einstein countered that there is no universal time acting as a background, and that space and time are just two inseparable properties of the same single fabric.

However, Minkowski's mathematical formulation maintained the framework of a separate time dimension axis, creating a 4D compromise (3S + 1T). This has been the stage that science has operated on for the past hundred-plus years. To me, it feels like a compromise or a refusal to fully accept the true consequence of Einstein’s view: that we should drop the independent time axis entirely and look at a strict model of 3 spatial/time dimensions (3ST).

To show what I mean, we can lay out the concepts using sheets of A4 paper:



Sheet Layout 1: The Newtonian Stack (3D Space + 1D Time)

  • The Structure: Take an A4 sheet of paper and print a picture of Isaac Newton on it. This single page represents 3D space.
  • The Time Mechanism: To show time passing, you cannot change this page. You must take a second, identical A4 sheet and place it on top of the first one. Then a third, a fourth, and so on.
  • The Result: You have built a physical stack of separate sheets representing a timeline of frozen moments. Time is an independent dimension—the vertical axis of the stack.
  • The Expansion Defect: For the universe to "expand" in this Newtonian stack, every new sheet you add to the top must be cut physically larger than the sheet below it, physically growing outward into a void.


Sheet Layout 2: The Minkowski Block (The 4D Compromise)

  • The Structure: Take that exact same expanding stack of loose Newton pages and glue them all tightly together into a solid, 4D pad of paper. This is Minkowski Spacetime (the modern Block Universe).
  • The Time Mechanism: You no longer add pages; the layers are already printed and frozen inside the solid block. Time is treated as a directional axis—a literal side-edge of the block that an observer travels across.
  • The Point of Failure: Textbooks claim this fully adopts relativity because the pages can be sliced at different, tilted angles depending on an observer's speed. But look at it structurally: it is still a stack of layers. Minkowski kept the 4th dimension axis intact. Time is still treated as an independent direction distinct from the space on the page, which contradicts the idea that they are just two inseparable properties of one thing.


Sheet Layout 3: The Einsteinian Reality (3D Spacetime / 3ST)

  • The Structure: Take a single A4 sheet of paper and print a picture of Einstein on it. Unlike Newton or Minkowski, this single page represents both time and space simultaneously—3D spacetime, not a 3+1 or 4-dimensional model that cannot let go of a separate time axis.
  • The Time Mechanism: Time is a division of the one and only page that exists, not the creation of another page, and another, and so on. There is no stack, and no axis to travel across. The single sheet stays a fixed absolute size, completely conserving all resources. Instead, Time is the active, internal mechanism that continuously divides this single page from within. The division itself is a seam.
  • The Result: The sheet divides cleanly down the middle, creating a seam and yielding two co-existing A5-sized pictures of Einstein. The smaller A5 pieces are the exact same single picture, just existing as different relative pieces separated by that seam.
  • The Scaling Reality: Because we are built from the product of these coexisting divisions, our composite structures—our bodies, planets, and rulers—automatically scale down as the underlying grains sub-divide. We look out at the cosmos and perceive distant galaxies as moving away simply because our composite measuring sticks are shrinking uniformly relative to the fixed, unchangeable boundaries of the single absolute sheet.



​
 
Part 2- Physical Evidence & CMB Anomalies



How the 3ST Model Aligns with Physical Evidence (Macro to Micro)

  • Macro Evidence — Cosmological Redshift:
    We know the cosmos changes scale because light from distant galaxies is redshifted. In a 3ST universe, this can be understood as a geometric effect of internal sub-division. To create a new relative "now," the single sheet sub-divides. Because all matter is built from the product of these divisions, our local scale shrinks uniformly with each shift. Distant light looks stretched simply because it was emitted by the larger version of atoms from an earlier, wider layer of division before the current seams were carved.
  • Macro Evidence — The Axis of Evil & Satellite Data Alignment:
    NASA’s WMAP and the ESA’s Planck satellites mapped the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) and found a massive, unexplained alignment: the largest temperature features in the universe point directly along the orbital plane of our solar system. Standard 4D cosmology cannot explain why a pattern from the beginning of time aligns with a tiny planet that wouldn't exist for another 9 billion years, nor why distant black holes and galaxy clusters stream in the exact same direction. The 3ST framework provides a completely natural geometric solution. The CMB is not a map of ancient random fluctuations; it is a map of the primary structural seams of the absolute un-divided page. Our solar system is a smaller, deeply nested sub-division carved much further down the timeline. Because our local system was drawn along the exact same master structural seams that dictate the shape of the entire sheet, our planetary plane remains perfectly parallel and aligned with the cosmic background grid lines.
  • Macro Evidence — JWST "Little Red Dots":
    This provides the direct physical reinterpretation for the thousands of ultra-compact, hyper-luminous "little red dots" discovered in deep space by the James Webb Space Telescope. Standard cosmology struggles to explain how objects 200 times smaller than our galaxy can emit the energy of 250 billion suns, forcing theories of impossible black hole densities. In the 3ST framework, these dots are the visual signature of scaling. Their hyper-dense energy profile is a geometric illusion caused by our modern, shrunken frames measuring an earlier, wider layer of the geometric division index.
  • Intermediate Evidence — Conservation of Energy:
    At the structural level of the cosmos, energy is perfectly conserved, aligning with the First Law of Thermodynamics. Standard cosmology struggles with this because it requires "dark energy" to be constantly created out of nothing to maintain a constant density inside an expanding space. In the 3ST model, the absolute bounds of the single page never change. The universe isn't creating new space; it is simply increasing its internal resolution by drawing temporal seams.
  • Micro Evidence — Quantum Entanglement:
    In the quantum realm, entanglement looks like two separate things communicating instantly across vast distances. In the 3ST model, non-locality disappears. Entangled particles are not independent entities separated by distance; they are the exact same single entity existing across a temporal shift. We are looking at one single whole universe intersecting our slice of reality at two different relative "nows" created by the seam.
  • Micro Evidence — Wave-Particle Duality:
    The subatomic world doesn't have its own separate set of rules; it is the exact same entity as the macro world. Instead, the microscopic particles that make up your body—your electrons and quarks—are themselves individual, coexisting, scaled-down whole universes (the grains). Before the first division, the state of nothing existing here and now still exists within every division to this day. Duality is the direct geometric consequence of moving through these levels of division:
    • The Wave State is the complete whole universe having undergone temporal shifts and scaling down with each shift to conserve energy. It is the continuous, cumulative fabric of those layered shifts.
    • The Particle State is a single coexisting, scaled-down whole universe locked into a distinct relative "now" along a structural seam.



​


Reinterpreting Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) Anomalies



By analysing WMAP and Planck data through the 3ST geometric grid, several major cosmic mysteries reveal themselves as natural boundary conditions of a fixed sheet:

  1. The Low-Multipole Lack of Variance: Both satellites noted a mysterious lack of massive temperature ripples at the largest scales of the sky. In 3ST, this is direct evidence of a bounded canvas. Because the sheet has fixed absolute boundaries, there is a strict maximum limit to the scale of any feature. You cannot have a ripple larger than the page itself.
  2. Hemispherical Asymmetry: The sky is documented as being structurally lopsided, with one half of the cosmic background being noticeably more active than the other. This asymmetry is the physical signature of the universe's very first division seam. When the original page undergoes its primary split, the resulting two halves naturally possess different relative energy layouts separated by that primary dividing line.
  3. The Quadrupole-Octupole Alignment: The four-lobed and eight-lobed temperature shapes mapped by satellites align perfectly with each other and point along our solar system's ecliptic plane. This is the blueprint of nested sub-divisions. Much like folding an A4 sheet into smaller squares forces the grid lines of the tiniest squares to run parallel to the master folds, our local spatial orientation matches the background because it is structurally locked to the primary seams of the single sheet.



​
 
Part 3- Math, Predictions & References



The Geometric Logic of Step-Like (Quantized) Transitions



In standard physics, the word "quantum" is treated like a magical boundary where the universe suddenly changes its rules for tiny things. In the 3ST framework, the step-like (quantized) nature of energy and matter is a direct consequence of geometry.

You cannot smoothly or gradually turn an A4 sheet into an A5 sheet. You can either have the whole A4 sheet, or you can create a sharp seam down the middle to instantly get two complete A5 sheets. There is no stable, mathematical "in-between" state.

Because time is the active mechanism drawing these seams, the universe cannot smoothly "glide" down in scale. Each division creates a whole, scaled-down universe. When a particle changes states (like an electron dropping orbits), it is jumping from one structural seam of the page to a tighter, smaller internal seam. Because you cannot have half a seam, the energy released or absorbed must be a precise, fixed packet. The "quantum leap" is simply the local observer stepping across an internal geometric boundary of the single, unchanging universe.




​


The Math of 3ST: Transforming the Variables



The 3ST model does not require throwing out established physical observations; it translates existing equations into a non-standard variable structure. By replacing the independent, linear time axis (t) with a discrete division index (n), we can use SciForums' TeX formatting to show how the math translates:

  1. Superposition & The Wave State: In standard quantum mechanics, the Schrödinger equation relies on a separate time axis to track a wave function:
    $$i\(\hbar\frac{\partial}{\partial t}\psi = \hat{H}\psi\)$$
    In the 3ST framework, the independent axis is dropped. The wave function is rewritten to track the global scale factor (S) of the single, undivided fabric:
    $$\(\psi \)(x, y, z, S)$$
    The math no longer tracks a particle blurred across an independent room, but rather the cumulative history of the single canvas having undergone temporal shifts. Superposition is simply the state of the unbroken background fabric before a distinct internal seam is counted.
  2. Randomness & Parallax Error: Heisenberg’s Uncertainty Principle states that a particle's exact position and momentum cannot be simultaneously verified:
    $$\(\Delta x \cdot \Delta p \geq \frac{\hbar}{2}\)$$
    In 3ST, this uncertainty limit is rewritten as a function of the internal observer’s scaling rate (dS) relative to the fixed absolute boundaries of the page. Quantum randomness is revealed as a geometric parallax error. Because the observer is a composite structure built from the products of the scaling picture, measuring a subatomic position means trying to pinpoint the exact boundary line of the very temporal frame currently defining the observer's reality.
  3. Force Scaling & Concentrated Mass: To explain why the subatomic world seems to have a "Strong Force" that dwarfs macro gravity, 3ST utilizes a geometric mass multiplier aligned with advanced variable-gravity metrics. As the single sheet divides, the rest mass (M) of the coexisting universes scales uniformly relative to the division index (n):
    $$M_n \(= M_0 \cdot 2^n\)$$
    This reveals that the subatomic world does not have its own separate rules. The gravitational equation remains identical, but because the relational density of the internal seams has multiplied by $$2^n$$, the force becomes tightly concentrated at the micro scale. Gravity and the strong force are the same equation, just viewed at different levels of division.
  4. The Planck Length Boundary Condition: Mainstream physics treats the Planck length as a chaotic point of structural breakdown:
    $$\(\ell_P \approx 10^{-35} \text{ m}\)$$
    In 3ST, it is mathematically defined as a hard boundary condition—the absolute minimum limit of scaling for a single division layer. When extreme energy is focused to compress a system past this threshold, the math triggers a fractal recursion: Scale Limit reached -> Page splits along a new seam -> 2 Coexisting whole universes. It completely removes the mathematical nightmare of a chaotic breakdown, showing that subatomic particle creation is a step-like geometric consequence of the sheet reaching its division limit.



​


Core Testable Predictions

By shifting the mechanism of the cosmos from an outward expansion to an inward sub-division, the 3ST model makes distinct predictions that separate it from standard 4D Minkowski spacetime:

  1. Quantized Cosmological Redshift: Because the universe scales down along distinct, structural paper folds (seams) rather than a smooth slide, light traveling across massive cosmic distances will exhibit distinct, step-like energy drops rather than a perfectly smooth curve.
  2. Flat Cosmological Resource Baseline: If we measure the total energy density and absolute boundary limits of the cosmos across deep time, the value will remain a flat, unchanging constant. True cosmic resource growth will be verified as zero, proving that acceleration is an observer-centric scaling illusion.
  3. Unified Step Proportions: Because the subatomic world does not have its own separate set of rules, the step-like energy jumps measured during quantum transitions inside a particle will mathematically mirror the step-like structural seams observed in macro cosmic redshift. The proportions will be identical because the particle state and the macro cosmos are the exact same single sheet.



​


References & Prior Literature Foundations

To address the historical context and mathematical precedents of an internally scaling 3ST architecture, this framework draws upon and critiques established foundations in peer-reviewed literature:

  1. Newton, I. (1687). Philosophiae Naturalis Principia Mathematica. This paper critiques Newton’s definition of absolute, independent time flowing as an external parameter to a 3D grid.
  2. Einstein, A. (1905). "Zur Elektrodynamik bewegter Körper" (Annalen der Physik). Establishes the non-existence of absolute rest and introduces the relational properties of space and time.
  3. Minkowski, H. (1908). "Raum und Zeit" (Address to the 80th Assembly of German Natural Scientists and Physicians). This framework critiques Minkowski's introduction of time as a formal 4th coordinate axis (3S + 1T) as a mathematical retention of the classical stack.
  4. Hoyle, F., & Narlikar, J. V. (1964). "A New Theory of Gravitation" (Proceedings of the Royal Society A). Provides the mathematical precedent for a stationary universe metric where mass values change dynamically over time rather than space coordinates expanding.
  5. Wetterich, C. (2014). "Universe without expansion" (Physical Review D). Establishes the peer-reviewed cosmological precedent that cosmological redshift and the illusion of cosmic expansion can be mathematically modelled entirely through the uniform, cosmos-temporal shrinking of local atom metrics within a static, fixed spatial volume.
  6. Wheeler, J. A., & Feynman, R. P. (1945). "Interaction with the Absorber as the Mechanism of Radiation" (Reviews of Modern Physics). Connects to the "One-Electron Universe" hypothesis, establishing a precedent for looking at multiplicity in space as a temporal reflection of a single entity.



​


Conclusion & Primary Question

If space and time are just two inseparable properties used to describe a single entity—like yellow and round describing the sun—the preservation of a separate fourth dimension axis is a logical contradiction.

Core Question: If "now" is entirely relative to the observer, doesn't that imply time is an active, local process of internal division (drawing seams on a single 3D spacetime canvas), rather than a static 4th dimension axis we travel through?




​
 
Oh goody, another "framework". :rolleyes:

At least it's not telling us it's showcasing an ontology -_O.

And as usual the writer isn't good at maths........
 
"The math isn't missing; it's an inverse transformation. Christof Wetterich (Phys. Rev. D, 2014) proved redshift can be modeled via local metrics shrinking within a static volume.
Instead of space expanding, our rulers shrink relative to the index $$n$$, scaling subatomic mass by $$M_n \(= M_0 \cdot 2^n\)$$. Where does that logic fail?"


 
"The math isn't missing; it's an inverse transformation. Christof Wetterich (Phys. Rev. D, 2014) proved redshift can be modeled via local metrics shrinking within a static volume. Instead of space expanding, our rulers shrink relative to the index n, scaling subatomic mass by M_n = M_0 * 2^n. Where does that logic fail?"
 
Where does that logic fail?
It fails trivially by not considering that neither the strong nor the weak interaction are scale-invariant. IOW, if you try to scale down an atom such that macroscopic redshift is recovered (which is what I assume is meant by "rulers shrink"), you break exactly those physics that make selfsame atom stable in the first place.
I should also point out that this shrinking matter thing is an old chestnut, it's been popping up in various iterations for a long time. No one has ever made it work, precisely for the above reason.

I do not have a heavy mathematical background
I don't mean to be rude, but if you don't actually understand the existing model completely and thoroughly, you aren't in any position to suggest a replacement for it. For example, if you knew the maths you'd have realised that by eliminating a dimension you also make it impossible for gravity to exist in vacuum, which is obviously counter to what we observe in the real world.
 
Ray2380: we take a dim view of chatbot regurgitation here, particularly when it is not attributed. That doesn't mean you can't use chatbot as a tool for your purposes, but we are not really inclined to engage a chatbot with you as merely its "meat proxy".

where the logic of modern spacetime interpretation might be failing.
What makes you think it might be failing?

As NGiTS says, this idea that we're shrinking is a very old idea. The problem with it is that it is a] very tortured and b] doesn't explain anything any better than what we have, which works very well. So Occam's Razor alone raises the question: why do we need this?
 
Last edited:
Wetterich's math bypasses the scale-invariance issue by scaling particle masses alongside the Planck mass, leaving the dimensionless ratios that govern atomic stability perfectly constant. 3ST doesn't drop a spatial dimension; it integrates time into the 3D grid as an internal division mechanism rather than a separate spatial axis. The question remains, "If Einstein rejected absolute time to weld space and time together, why does mainstream physics still insist on keeping a separate fourth-dimension axis?
 
The problem with it is that it is a] very tortured and b] doesn't explain anything any better than what we have, which works very well.
a. I have never heard of any shrinking universe idea before and truly though I was the only one. It has been a very long time between posting any idea on a science forum, some 20years I'd say.

b. I think it explains a lot better-
  • The Conservation of Space-Time Energy (Eliminating Dark Energy)
  • The CMB "Axis of Evil" Alignment (Explaining Cosmic-Solar System Parallelism)
  • The JWST "Little Red Dots" Paradox (Resolving Hyper-Dense Early Galaxy Sizes)
  • The Cosmological Horizon Problem (Removing the Need for Faster-Than-Light Inflation)
  • The Quantum Gravity Singularity Breakdown (Replacing Infinities with Fractal Recursion)
The framework utilizes a standard conformal Weyl transformation; it doesn't break the equations of physics, it simply flips the scaling variable so that the expansion happens in the denominator (our shrinking atoms) rather than the numerator (expanding space).
 
Wetterich's math bypasses the scale-invariance issue by scaling particle masses alongside the Planck mass, leaving the dimensionless ratios that govern atomic stability perfectly constant. 3ST doesn't drop a spatial dimension; it integrates time into the 3D grid as an internal division mechanism rather than a separate spatial axis. The question remains, "If Einstein rejected absolute time to weld space and time together, why does mainstream physics still insist on keeping a separate fourth-dimension axis?
Reported for regurgitating Ai generated slop.
 
it integrates time into the 3D grid as an internal division mechanism rather than a separate spatial axis.
So yes, it does drop a dimension, which is precisely that (in non-technical terms) - a separate axis that is orthogonal to the other three.
why does mainstream physics still insist on keeping a separate fourth-dimension axis?
Because Lorentz invariance is - according to all data we currently posses - a fundamental symmetry of the world, and to make it work you need the separate time axis. By extension, this also applies to the Standard Model's CPT symmetry, as one implies the other.
Wetterich's math bypasses the scale-invariance issue by scaling particle masses alongside the Planck mass, leaving the dimensionless ratios that govern atomic stability perfectly constant.
Dimensionless constants aren't the problem here, quite the opposite; in QCD, an explicit dimensionful scale is introduced through the phenomenon of dimensional transmutation; and in QFD, the explicit scale appears due to electroweak symmetry breaking and the Higgs mechanism. You cannot scale things while simultaneously keeping the ratios of dimensionless constants invariant and ensure that the dimensionful scales change in just the right way, and guarantee local conservation of the energy-momentum tensor. You can perhaps do each of those things in isolation (if the respective beta-functions of the QFTs in question happen to vanish), but not all of them simultaneously.
I have never heard of any shrinking universe idea before and truly though I was the only one.
You are definitely not the first. I've been on various forums for quite a long time now, and this is an old staple that pops up again from time to time.
I think it explains a lot better
Do you think that, or do you know that? Have you seen a fully worked-out new version of the Standard Model Lagrangian that is actually manifestly invariant under scale transformations of the type suggested here? This is the most fatal flaw so far as I am concerned, because the usual Standard Model does not feature such an invariance. You must remember that the various interactions don't stand in isolation, but they must all scale simultaneously in just the right way, in spite of their different mechanism, coupling constants, and scale behaviour.
Note also that what we are talking about here isn't just any old rescaling, but one that must exactly reproduce all expansion-related observational data we have (not just redshift!).
Also, you must find some mechanism that actually stops expansion happening at all, since this is not a stand-alone phenomenon, but something that follows directly from the laws of gravity. So this idea implies that we must either modify General Relativity in some way, or write down an entirely new law of gravity that does not lead to metric expansion, while still being compatible with all the tests we have subjected standard GR to.
So yes, this whole idea very much breaks quite a lot of known physics, from QFT all the way to GR.
 
Ray2380:

Have you published your work in a peer-reviewed physics journal?

If not, why not?
 
The truth behind why I haven't published is that I am a retired fireman, not a physicist. I wouldn't have a clue how to navigate the academic peer-review system anyway. This is just my take, shared on a public forum for genuine conceptual discussion.
According to Einstein's spacetime, I am here and now; and somewhere else is also sometime else. He proved that space and time are just two inseparable ways to describe the exact same single thing. 3ST doesn't treat time as something separate from space—it takes Einstein's vision to its literal geometric conclusion by dropping the independent 4th axis completely, since a separate axis contradicts that core inseparability.
When Hermann Minkowski first introduced the 4D mathematical spacetime block in 1908, Einstein famously dismissed it as 'superfluous learnedness' and joked that 'since the mathematicians have invaded the theory of relativity, I do not understand it myself anymore.' Einstein only adopted it later because he needed the calculus to make gravity work. I think he was simply too busy developing relativity to fend off Minkowski's architecture.
In 3ST, time and space are unified as an active internal mechanism dividing the 3D canvas from within. If we are built from the products of these internal geometric divisions, our local atomic frames naturally scale down in unison. Why must we assume a separate physical axis is the only mathematical way to preserve Lorentz symmetry? If we don't scale down internally, then how do you explain the global conservation of energy when space expands?
Wetterich’s 2014 paper ('Universe without expansion') explicitly provides the fully worked-out field equations showing how quantum fields and General Relativity can be mapped into a static volume through variable particle masses.
 
According to Einstein's spacetime, I am here and now
No, this is precisely not how it is modelled. In spacetime 'you' are a bundle of very many worldlines, one for each of the particles that constitutes your body; so 'you' are a geometric object that extends in both space and time. The here-and-now is just an arbitrary slice through that bundle.
He proved that space and time are just two inseparable ways to describe the exact same single thing.
Again, not really. What he showed was that you need to account for both space and time in order to construct quantities (called proper quantities) that all observers agree on, ie which are invariant under changes of reference frame. Examples are the spacetime interval between events, and more generally any quantity that can be expressed in terms of a representation of the Lorentz group, most notably tensors and spinors. So fundamentally it is about symmetries.
Einstein only adopted it later because he needed the calculus to make gravity work.
Yes, and not just gravity.
Why must we assume a separate physical axis is the only mathematical way to preserve Lorentz symmetry?
Because that separate axis has opposite metric signature to the other axes, which you need if you want the overall line element to remain invariant.
how do you explain the global conservation of energy when space expands?
A metrically expanding spacetime is not Riemann-flat, and in such curved spacetimes there is no global law of energy-momentum conservation. The energy-momentum tensor is conserved everywhere locally, but not globally across regions of curved spacetime.
Wetterich’s 2014 paper ('Universe without expansion') explicitly provides the fully worked-out field equations showing how quantum fields and General Relativity can be mapped into a static volume through variable particle masses.
Ok, I have had a closer look at the original paper, as well as his follow-up publications Variable Gravity Universe (2014) and Hot BB or Slow Freeze? (2014). Firstly, we must recognise that the paper survived peer-review, and was subsequently published in a reputable paper; this indicates that it deserves to be taken seriously.
As for the actual contents of the papers, it seems to me that he never claimed that the universe is in fact static and atoms are shrinking, while standard cosmology is "wrong" - rather, he shows that the same underlying evolution of the universe can be described in terms of different field variables, and that these descriptions are mathematically equivalent and cannot be distinguished observationally/experimentally locally (!). So the central claim is about different but equivalent ways to model the same system locally. Furthermore I haven't found any mention of abandoning time as a dimension, so that bit is clearly your own invention.
Personally I find Wetterich's work quite interesting conceptually, and probably worth further study - but it's absolutely not the same as the ideas you have described on the OP of this thread.

PS. I have highlighted 'locally' above, because I think his proposed additional scalar field (the cosmon field) would need to imply a change in the fine structure constant over time (ie not locally) in order to produce the cosmological redshift we observe. Such a possibility is strongly constrained by data from natural fission reactors (like the one at Oklo). The scalar field must also couple to matter in general (since it leads to variations in masses), which in turn is strongly constrained by precision tests of the equivalence principle. So experimentally there is to date no evidence of the extra scalar field.
 
I appreciate you taking the time to read Wetterich’s papers. It means a lot to have a genuine, respectful discussion on these concepts.

You are completely right that abandoning the independent axis for a discrete division index n is entirely my own conceptual addition, not Wetterich’s. That is the core of the 3ST thought experiment.

When you say 'you are a geometric object that extends in both space and time' as a bundle of worldlines, that is the standard Minkowski Block Universe interpretation. But to me, that highlights the exact historical compromise I'm questioning. If you look at the timing between Einstein and Minkowski, the 4th axis was a mathematical convenience, not Einstein's pure physical vision.

If we take Einstein's original philosophy literally—that space and time are inseparable properties of one thing—there is no separate corridor to stretch across. In 3ST, what we call 'time' is simply the measured relation between the internally sub-divided pieces of the single 3D canvas itself.
Your note about global energy conservation is exactly why I find this compelling. Accepting that an expanding spacetime forces us to abandon a global law of energy conservation feels like a massive conceptual price to pay just to keep Minkowski's 4th axis intact.

Mainstream cosmology tolerates several massive anomalies to protect the expanding 4D grid—such as the violation of global energy conservation, the unexplained cosmic-to-solar alignment of the CMB 'Axis of Evil,' the impossible densities of JWST's early 'little red dots,' and quantum non-locality.

If the observational data for an expanding universe and a uniformly shrinking observer are mathematically dual, why is an inverse scaling variable conceptually impossible to consider as a physical reality?


 
I appreciate you taking the time to read Wetterich’s papers. It means a lot to have a genuine, respectful discussion on these concepts.

You are completely right that abandoning the independent axis for a discrete division index n is entirely my own conceptual addition, not Wetterich’s. That is the core of the 3ST thought experiment.

When you say 'you are a geometric object that extends in both space and time' as a bundle of worldlines, that is the standard Minkowski Block Universe interpretation. But to me, that highlights the exact historical compromise I'm questioning. If you look at the timing between Einstein and Minkowski, the 4th axis was a mathematical convenience, not Einstein's pure physical vision.

If we take Einstein's original philosophy literally—that space and time are inseparable properties of one thing—there is no separate corridor to stretch across. In 3ST, what we call 'time' is simply the measured relation between the internally sub-divided pieces of the single 3D canvas itself.
Your note about global energy conservation is exactly why I find this compelling. Accepting that an expanding spacetime forces us to abandon a global law of energy conservation feels like a massive conceptual price to pay just to keep Minkowski's 4th axis intact.

Mainstream cosmology tolerates several massive anomalies to protect the expanding 4D grid—such as the violation of global energy conservation, the unexplained cosmic-to-solar alignment of the CMB 'Axis of Evil,' the impossible densities of JWST's early 'little red dots,' and quantum non-locality.

If the observational data for an expanding universe and a uniformly shrinking observer are mathematically dual, why is an inverse scaling variable conceptually impossible to consider as a physical reality?


Reads like AI.
 
When you say 'you are a geometric object that extends in both space and time' as a bundle of worldlines, that is the standard Minkowski Block Universe interpretation.
I don't see it as any kind of "interpretation", it is just how the standard formulation of relativity works.
That being said, there are in fact alternative ways to formulate the same physics. I'd like to use the ADM formalism as just one example among quite a number of possibilities - here, instead of looking at worldlines on a 4D manifold from the outset, you consider 3D hyperslices of simultaneity instead, and stack those up like cards in a deck (this is called a foliation). You can then label each slice with a number, and this is what becomes 'time'. The dynamics of the whole system are then encoded in how these slices are related to one another. The physics are the same in the end, but the formulation is different, and more suitable to solving certain problems.
not Einstein's pure physical vision
Einstein's original philosophy
I don't know what these are. He developed SR based on the already known fact that the laws of physics - specifically electromagnetism - are the same in all inertial frames; people already knew this, there just wasn't a coherent framework to formulate it properly before Einstein. And to go from SR to GR is really just a mathematical exercise - we know that SR holds locally, we know the Equivalence Principle, and we also know that any metric theory of gravity must fulfil certain quite stringent mathematical consistency constraints, so it turned out that the Einstein equations are the only valid constraint on the metric that fulfils these conditions. To be sure, actually finding that constraint equation was still one hell of a task, which is why it took him eight years to get there.
I'd like to make this quite clear - Einstein did not set out to write a geometric theory of curved spacetime from the beginning. He began with SR and the equivalence principle, plus of course abovementioned consistency requirements and some general properties of gravity, and attempted to find a model of gravity that was compatible with all of this. That was his original program, an almost purely physical one. It was only later in the course of his work (around 1912) that he realised that these requirements were not mathematically compatible with the flat spacetime of SR, and he began to understand that the problem was the constant metric tensor in the line element. Seeing the possibility that this object could be made to vary from event to event was the crucial insight. His first attempt at writing down field equations was wrong, but he realised this and found the correct version in 1915.
Accepting that an expanding spacetime forces us to abandon a global law of energy conservation feels like a massive conceptual price to pay just to keep Minkowski's 4th axis intact.
No, it is a natural consequence of the how gravity works. You need to remember that the very concept of energy-momentum itself is defined from spacetime symmetries via Noether's theorem. Specifically, the energy-momentum tensor is just precisely the conserved Noether current associated with spacetime translation invariance. When this invariance fails to hold - as it does anywhere in the presence of gravity - then energy-momentum no longer has a global conservation law.
It is possible to recover such a law, but you need to generalise the conserved quantity even further than just energy-momentum - you need to build a covariant quantity that accounts for the energy-momentum of gravitational sources, as well as for the energy content of the gravitational field itself. That latter part isn't localisable, so the maths become pretty non-trivial, but it can be done. The result is called the Landau-Lifschitz stress-energy-momentum conservation law.
So there's no price to pay, you just need to account for all relevant contributions.

Take careful note of what I'm saying above - without a 4D spacetime, there wouldn't even be any meaningful concept of energy-momentum in the first place, never mind a corresponding conservation law!
such as the violation of global energy conservation
See above on how to fix this. Also, it's not a violation, but rather the absence of a conservation law. That's not the same thing at all.
If the observational data for an expanding universe and a uniformly shrinking observer are mathematically dual
They are equivalent only if you introduce an additional scalar field that couples to matter, and change the Standard Model Lagrangian accordingly and in just the right way. That is what Wetterich has done in his publications. It can not be done without that additional field.
why is an inverse scaling variable conceptually impossible to consider as a physical reality?
It takes a lot more than just an 'inverse scaling variable', you need to make a number of pretty technical adjustments to get it to work, while still being compatible with existing data. But as I said in my comments on Wetterich above, it can be made to work, if his calculations are correct, which I assume they are. The crux of the matter is that extra scalar field that is needed - does it exist, or not? If it does, it would at least in principle be detectable, and currently we have no evidence suggesting that this is the case. We have on the other hand some pretty stringent constraints on possible extra scalar fields (in general) in place from experiment and observation, so personally I'd be quite surprised if something like this turned up. But of course it's not impossible.
 
But now I think I've written enough about standard physics - don't you think it's time you showed us your actual model now? After all, that's what this thread was meant to be about.
 
Back
Top