Philosophy Updates

Consciousness research is ready for its Einstein moment
https://iai.tv/articles/consciousness-research-is-ready-for-its-einstein-moment-auid-3709?_auid=2020

INTRO: It remains a mystery about how consciousness relates to neural mechanisms. Now, with the advent of AI, some argue that consciousness could emerge in these systems. Here, philosopher and Lead for Responsible AI at Microsoft Ken Archer, and phenomenologist Harald Wiltsche, argue that the attempt to reduce consciousness to a mechanism won't work and relies on a misunderstanding. Instead, using Einstein's re-thinking of the ether as a guide, we can unlock the mystery of consciousness. (MORE - details]

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

An interested review of Emily Eakin’s ‘The Frenchmen’
https://www.loureedsnephew.com/p/remembrance-of-things-post

EXCERPTS: Like Emily Eakin, author of The Frenchmen: Or, My Life in Theory, I came of intellectual age in the late heyday of French theory, though from a slightly different vantage point.

[...] The picture that emerges is one of seductive ideas proposed by flawed men—the book dedicates significant attention to Barthes, Lacan, Althusser, Foucault, Derrida, and de Man—that gained purchase in young minds (Eakin’s included), peaked, faded, and have gone on to have ambiguous afterlives in American culture. Eakin’s tone is abashed—how foolish we were!—apologetic, but in the end hopeful that theory contributed something positive to the world.

Theory certainly had its excesses. Decades later, I admit that reading a Foucault paper in a writers’ group is pretentious and that I have very little idea what Baudrillard is talking about.

But I would argue that what the French theorists were getting at was both “real” and—perhaps more importantly—not theirs alone. The French theorists didn’t destroy stability, nor were they the first to describe its loss. They offered a description of an instability that was being independently verified elsewhere.

[...] Whatever the cause—epistemic evolution, economic and social development, or the natural demise of empires—foundationalism unraveled throughout the twentieth century in a way the French theorists could not have caused, but for which they became easy scapegoats... (MORE - details)

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Liberalism’s deepest grounding is the belief that cruelty is an absolute evil
https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/2...t=2DPnH7-w5PunRuGFjgT5W5ds5fdXVtTrGl3nB9USvUo

EXCERPTS: In 1989, the year the West won the Cold War, Francis Fukuyama published an essay announcing “the end of history.” He wasn’t claiming that historic events would stop taking place; what was over, rather, was the debate about the meaning of those events. Since the Enlightenment, Western thinkers had believed that history was progressing toward a final destination.

According to communism, the engine of progress was class conflict, and history would end in the creation of a classless society. With the failure of the Soviet empire, Fukuyama argued, this idea had been discredited. Only one alternative remained: It was now clear that the “end point of mankind’s ideological evolution” was “the universalization of Western liberal democracy as the final form of human government.”

There would still be disagreements within liberalism—Fukuyama named religion and nationalism as likely fault lines—but there could no longer be any disagreement about liberalism.

To see how that judgment is holding up, just look at the kinds of titles that political theorists are producing these days [...] Across the West, the far right and the far left are on the rise, and the one thing they agree on is their contempt for liberalism.

[...] Now that the liberal triumphalism of the post–Cold War era is dying, what can replace it? The answer may lie in another important essay written in 1989—one that received much less attention than Fukuyama’s, but enjoys a cult reputation among keepers of the liberal flame. “The Liberalism of Fear,” by Judith Shklar...

[...] Liberalism doesn’t offer a vision of a perfect world—one where injustice is abolished, or where a particular nation reigns supreme. Instead, it is rooted in a justified fear of the real world, where people with power often use it to oppress, torture, and kill. “Liberalism’s deepest grounding,” Shklar writes, is the belief “that cruelty is an absolute evil.” (MORE - details)
_
 
NTRO: It remains a mystery about how consciousness relates to neural mechanisms. Now, with the advent of AI, some argue that consciousness could emerge in these systems. Here, philosopher and Lead for Responsible AI at Microsoft Ken Archer, and phenomenologist Harald Wiltsche, argue that the attempt to reduce consciousness to a mechanism won't work and relies on a misunderstanding. Instead, using Einstein's re-thinking of the ether as a guide, we can unlock the mystery of consciousness.
Ricardo Pulito's reply to this article was helpful in uncovering a couple problems in the analysis. In particular, Pulito's first paragraph:

First, the irony attributed to the anti-reductionist who becomes a reductionist about AI seems to rest on an assumed symmetry that does not hold. Reducing to a mechanism something we have discovered, such as a pathogen, is an explanatory hypothesis about a given phenomenon, and it may well fall short. Describing as a mechanism something we have invented, such as a clock or an AI system, is not a reduction at all. It is simply an account of what was built. In the first case the phenomenon comes first and the mechanism later; in the second, the mechanism is the blueprint and the behaviour follows from it. One might reply that engineers do not know what happens inside large language models. They do not know the particular computations or pathways involved in a given output, but they do know the mechanism. The opacity concerns the route, not the nature of the process. There is therefore no inconsistency in denying that human consciousness is merely mechanism while affirming that a machine is computation. It is, in fact, your own principle of letting the phenomena set the terms, applied to two different phenomena.
 
  • Like
Reactions: C C
Scientists are growing human brain tissue in living mice – could this make their welfare harder to assess?
https://theconversation.com/scienti...is-make-their-welfare-harder-to-assess-293390

EXCERPT: The idea of creating human-animal chimeras – animals containing human cells – raises ethical questions, particularly when involving the brain. Various philosophers have argued that as the proportion of human brain tissue increases, we should consider whether the animal could acquire human-like mental capacities – and whether this should change how we treat it. But I argue that serious questions about our ability to recognise animal suffering will arise long before mice gain increased intelligence. (MORE - details)

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

What Montesquieu can teach modern‑day France
https://theconversation.com/politic...ontesquieu-can-teach-modern-day-france-294737

KEY POINTS: Democratic erosion does not start by doing away with elections; it starts with the weakening of institutions that limit political power. Montesquieu’s intuition back in the 18th century helps us to to gain a sounder understanding of the mechanisms at work in France today. For the French philosopher, without intermediate bodies, only the “fleeting and capricious will of absolute power” lays itself bare to acts of revolt... (MORE - details)

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Simon Armitage's translation of "Gilgamesh" doesn't mollify the bad habits of royalty
https://www.theguardian.com/books/2...-epic-is-brilliantly-translated-for-our-times

EXCERPT: [...] The epic originated in ancient Mesopotamia (modern-day Iraq) at least 4,000 years ago, and it begins with the eponymous demigod, king of Uruk, lording it over his subjects. Among other bad habits, he exercises the “right of the first night”, which allows him to bed newlywed brides before their husbands. To check his powers, the gods create his counterpart, the wild man Enkidu, who confronts Gilgamesh outside the house of one of these brides. The two rivals turned comrades then embark on a series of extraordinary adventures

[...] The register of Gilgamesh remains one of the great unknowns of the poem. Given the nature of its content – often violent, mocking and sexually explicit – there is no reason to assume it should, as it generally is, be translated into elevated language. Armitage tackles this head on by mixing different registers and idiolects. His tactile, visceral version is a tour de force, combining careful scholarship with poetic verve and deft linguistic meldings, and it is likely to become one of the standard renditions in English... (MORE - details)

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Machiavelli’s ‘audaciously honest’ The Prince reveals how politics works
https://theconversation.com/guide-t...-the-prince-reveals-how-politics-works-262726

EXCERPT: As a political scientist, I consider The Prince a classic because of its bold realism. It responds to how the world is, rather than how it should be.

Instead of offering idealistic visions of leadership, Machiavelli presents a clear-eyed observation of how power is gained and retained in the real world. Many of the traits he describes – including adaptability, strategic communication, and the careful balance between fear and love – still shape political leadership today.

The book is divided into 26 short chapters and spans just 105 pages, making it a quick read. Each chapter explores how to acquire and maintain power in a particular scenario, offering practical advice to rulers navigating various political landscapes.

Machiavelli’s realism is not just about tactics. It’s about understanding human nature. He urges rulers to observe and accept reality as it is... (MORE - details)
_
 
The idea of creating human-animal chimeras – animals containing human cells – raises ethical questions, particularly when involving the brain. Various philosophers have argued that as the proportion of human brain tissue increases, we should consider whether the animal could acquire human-like mental capacities – and whether this should change how we treat it.
Maybe worth a thread, not sure. Why would some human brain cells make a difference? If the mouse could suffer as a normal mouse then we shouldn't mistreat it. Arguably lack of intellect would make suffering worse. (not that a few human neurons inside the tiny space of a mouse cranium are really going to give it an intellect, anyway)

Side note: human neurons in a cat brain would actually make it dumber, as cat neuronal structure actually allows more capacity per cc than human. It's why cats are notably good problem solvers, and that walnut sized brain has ~ 20% more cortical neurons than a dog's brain.
 
  • Like
Reactions: C C
Maybe worth a thread, not sure. Why would some human brain cells make a difference? If the mouse could suffer as a normal mouse then we shouldn't mistreat it. Arguably lack of intellect would make suffering worse. (not that a few human neurons inside the tiny space of a mouse cranium are really going to give it an intellect, anyway)

Side note: human neurons in a cat brain would actually make it dumber, as cat neuronal structure actually allows more capacity per cc than human. It's why cats are notably good problem solvers, and that walnut sized brain has ~ 20% more cortical neurons than a dog's brain.

Graham's earlier 2019 article below. Like any moral competition without an authoritarian panel of judges to declare a winner, the various theses will just have to slug it out rhetorically on the playing field (which also includes who has the best empathy-generating gimmick). No particular contestant or team will sway the entire audience due to some members of the latter having occupational interests.

Should be no worries about the "food" issue with regard to hybrid mice (though rats are definitely on the menu). For the tinier rodents, the civil rights brawl will hover over the domain of bondage, captivity, enslavement, Nazi experimentation, etc. Difficult to conceive organ harvesting becoming applicable unless rats develop to the size of boars. ("Bad neighborhood" jokes about vermin dimensions...)

Human‑animal hybrids are coming -- a philosopher weighs in
https://theconversation.com/human-a...for-transplant-a-philosopher-weighs-in-121228

EXCERPT: Moral status tells us whose interests count, from a moral point of view. Most people would say human beings have full moral status, as do babies, fetuses and the severely disabled, which means we must consider their interests. More controversially, some people also believe that non-human animals – such as chimpanzees or human embryos – possess a degree of moral status approaching that of human beings.

But pinning down what characteristics confer moral status can be tricky. Various criteria have been suggested, including the ability to reason, have self-awareness, the ability to form relationships with others, the capacity for suffering, or simply being a part of the human species. But each of these criteria ends up including some groups who don’t have moral status, or excluding some who do.

The idea that non-human animals might have sufficient moral status for it to be morally wrong to kill them for food, or use for medical research, has gained significant traction in the philosophical community. Similarly, veganism has grown massively worldwide. There’s been a 600% increase in people identifying as vegan in the US in just the last three years. While in the UK the number of vegans has risen from 150,000 in 2014 to 600,000 in 2018, which suggests people are increasingly willing to take the interests of animals seriously.

From a philosophical perspective using non-human animals for food or medical research is unethical because it significantly harms the animal, while providing only a small or insignificant benefit to us. But even those who believe that non-human animals have moral status would likely support sacrificing the life of a non-human animal to save the life of a human – as would be the case in human-animal organ donation. This is because a human can value its life in complex ways that a non-human animal cannot.

But if human-animal hybrids become more like us than non-human animals, it could then be argued that it’s unethical to produce a hybrid simply for the purposes of extracting its organs. That is, harvesting the organs of a non-consenting human-animal hybrid could be morally equivalent to harvesting the organs of a non-consenting human.

Of course, for this argument to work, there would need to be strong reasons for thinking not only that a human-animal hybrid has moral status, but that its life has equal moral value to that of a human. And even if a mouse-human hybrid did have a “human-like” brain, it is exceedingly unlikely that it would be human enough to merit equal moral consideration...
(MORE - details)
_
 
Last edited:
But if human-animal hybrids become more like us than non-human animals, it could then be argued that it’s unethical to produce a hybrid simply for the purposes of extracting its organs. That is, harvesting the organs of a non-consenting human-animal hybrid could be morally equivalent to harvesting the organs of a non-consenting human.
This and some of the other issues you raise could merit a thread here, though I don't lnow how many members would want to chase this deep into the weeds. (so to speak) The organ harvesting also intersects with that Ishiguro novel where teens at a British school turn out to be clones created solely to be organ banks for the wealthy. (Shudder) I like Ishiguro, but that one chilled me to the bone. Back to this later. The veganism stats in that article were a little startling - I knew it was up but not to that degree.
 
Liberal eugenics and the troubling quest for human perfection
https://www.theguardian.com/news/ng...-and-the-troubling-quest-for-human-perfection

EXCERPTS: Towards the end of the last century, some philosophers and bioethicists began to defend what they called “liberal eugenics”. Nicholas Agar and Julian Savulescu are among the figures who have argued that this form of eugenics, driven by parental freedom of choice, is something entirely different from the repressive eugenics of the past, which sought to mobilise the state to marginalise or even exterminate entire groups.

[...] States need to manage their populations for instrumental purposes – to keep the economy growing, to avoid public health emergencies and to have enough soldiers available to fight wars. For a long time, this management was carried out in paternalistic or authoritarian ways.

But, as the philosopher Michel Foucault argued, a signal feature of the modern state is that it operates through governmentality – by providing the incentives for citizens to manage themselves in ways that align with state interests. If we, as individuals, freely decide to treat ourselves and our families as miniature populations to be optimised for health and productivity, that saves the state quite a lot of effort.

But what does this mean for our sense of ourselves? (MORE - details)

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Review of "The Age of Hobsbawm: The Life of a Revolutionary Historian" (by Emile Chabal)
https://jacobin.substack.com/p/eric-hobsbawm-historian-of-defeat

EXCERPTS: For a new generation of politically committed historians, the struggles of Eric Hobsbawm — a communist who had lived in Berlin when the Nazis came to power, been in Paris at the height of the Popular Front in 1936, and traveled to Spain during the civil war — could be inspiring.

[...] In 2018, the historian Emile Chabal traveled to Delhi where he encountered a group of left-wing students who admired Hobsbawm’s work. ... But as Chabal asks, what can the life of Hobsbawm — the historical figure rather than the myth — teach us about the prospects of the Left today?

[...] Emile Chabal’s The Age of Hobsbawm ... enters crowded territory. Yet his new biography provides an excellent opportunity to revisit the life of a committed communist through the wider history of twentieth-century communism and to ask what Hobsbawm might teach us at another moment of profound uncertainty for the international Left.

[...] Chabal critically reconstructs how Hobsbawm remained skeptical of, and at times openly hostile toward, aspects of the legacy of the New Left and postmodernism. One revealing example is a letter reproduced by Chabal in which Hobsbawm responded to a student who proposed reconstructing a historical narrative in which gender, race, sexuality, and subjectivity would be central rather than adjuncts to a “grand narrative.” Hobsbawm rejected the proposed approach as neither his “kind of history” nor, in his view, Karl Marx’s, and regarded the project as symptomatic of the retreat of the Left.

[...] Hobsbawm’s attitude toward the New Left had two important and contradictory consequences. It left him poorly equipped to understand some of the new political forces that emerged after the 1960s, including feminism, identity politics, new social movements, cultural politics, and some forms of anti-colonial and postcolonial politics.

It narrowed his political analysis, but in some respects it also strengthened it. Less attached to the revolutionary optimism associated with parts of the New Left, Hobsbawm became one of the first major Marxist intellectuals in Britain to confront directly the decline of traditional industrial working-class politics.

[...] Finally came the collapse of communism in 1989–91 and the emergence of the post–Cold War world ... For Hobsbawm, the collapse of communism was therefore not simply a geopolitical event. It represented the disappearance of the world that had shaped his political and intellectual imagination since his youth.

[...] His biography reveals that his greatest political strength was not his loyalty to a particular communist doctrine but his capacity to rethink socialist strategy after defeat. This is why returning to Hobsbawm now is more useful than simply celebrating him as the great historian of a vanished left. The value of his life lies neither in nostalgia for twentieth-century communism nor in finding a political blueprint among his writings.

It lies instead in his persistent willingness to ask difficult questions after defeat. Who are the agents of political transformation when the old working class changes? How can movements with different interests be brought into a common political project? How should the Left respond when its inherited organizations cease to command loyalty? And, most importantly, how can political defeat become an opportunity for strategic reconstruction rather than permanent retreat? (MORE - details)
_
 
Why do people feel the presence of ‘ghosts’?
https://www.zmescience.com/science/...ghosts-scientists-are-starting-to-understand/

EXCERPTS: For centuries, experiences like these have inspired ghost stories, religious revelations, and tales of supernatural encounters. But psychologists have another name for the phenomenon: felt presence. And they’re beginning to understand why it happens in some people — and why it’s much more common than you might believe.

[...] These experiments suggest that at least some ghostly experiences can emerge from the brain’s own machinery for distinguishing self from other. But they don’t explain every instance of felt presence.

[...] Among people with higher psychosis-risk scores, those who also felt a strong connection to God, spirits, or a higher power described their encounters with invisible presences as more vivid and disturbing. Those who reported fewer spiritual experiences generally found these encounters less upsetting. Yet the most surprising finding concerned the pleasant experiences... (MORE - details)

- - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Is mosquito extinction morally wrong? Gene drives and the limits of utilitarianism
https://www.skeptic.org.uk/2026/10/...gene-drives-and-the-limits-of-utilitarianism/

EXCERPTS: While wiping out an entire species naturally raises red flags about messing with nature, many ecologists point out that Anopheles gambiae wouldn’t leave a gaping hole in the ecosystem... But what about the mosquito? Don’t their interests count? If we are increasingly worried about cows in slaughterhouses and animal welfare as a whole, shouldn’t we also extend some degree of moral consideration to insects? Where do we draw the line?

[...] At the end of the day, it seems that moral worth is fundamentally tied to consciousness – the capacity for subjective experience and the ability to feel pain or pleasure. As the philosopher Daniel Dennett famously explained, consciousness isn’t an all-or-nothing, binary light switch. Instead, it exists on a gradual evolutionary continuum. Dennett argued that human consciousness is a complex “user illusion” built from millions of tiny, unconscious sub-routines and neural processes working in tandem.

Because these underlying cognitive building blocks evolved slowly over time, different organisms possess varying degrees of functional awareness rather than a simple conscious-or-unconscious divide. A mosquito obviously isn’t on the same level as a human or a chimpanzee, but it isn’t a static rock either. It sits somewhere further down that spectrum, which leaves open the possibility that some rudimentary level of subjective experience is actually there.

Recent empirical research increasingly supports the idea that insect minds are far more dynamic than mere reflexive automatons. Studies on insect neurobiology and behaviour show that many species exhibit key hallmarks of sentience... (MORE - details)

- - - - - - - - - - - - - -

The brutal Harvard class that suddenly everyone wants to take (decline of the humanities)
https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/othe...t-suddenly-everyone-wants-to-take/ar-AA2gck5y

EXCERPTS: Those who see the humanities, heavy coursework and value of a Harvard education as gravely imperiled can take heart in the phenomenon that is Humanities 10. [...] Hum 10, as it’s commonly known, has become the surprise hit of Harvard’s academic lineup and something of a campus institution. Demand to get into the class has surged ... It’s a fever that even the professors are struggling to explain.

The class is definitely not for padding the GPA. Students read a hefty book a week and write regular essays. There is no pass/fail option. Digital devices are verboten, and attendance is taken in every lecture (pink slips for those who arrive late).

[...] It’s all distinctly old school. Hotly contested terms like “Western Civ,” “Great Books” and “the canon” appear nowhere in the course description. But the curriculum begins with “The Odyssey,” travels forward in time to James Joyce’s “Ulysses” and then backward to end with “The Iliad.” In between are assignments on Montaigne, Shakespeare, Spinoza, Baldwin, Dante and Plato.

In their applications and in interviews, students expressed the urge to be forced to tackle classics they otherwise wouldn’t read, the need to combat frayed attention spans and the desire for an antidote to The Machine. Several mentioned with disdain that people who aren’t in the class wondered why they didn’t “just Chat the books,” i.e., use AI.

“A lot of what we get out of this class is the human experience, and you can’t get that out of AI,” said Peggy Urdan, a government and neuroscience major from Lexington, Mass. “The only way to get anything out of this class is to not use AI.”

At the core of the humanities is, of course, humanity.

Dreamed up over dinner in 2008 by friends Stephen Greenblatt and Louis Menand, both renowned English professors and bestselling authors, Hum 10 was conceived as a Harvard twist on a famed Columbia senior seminar and Yale’s Directed Studies program, and a way to combat plummeting student interest in the humanities... (MORE - details)

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

A Debate on Metaphysics

INTRO: In this discussion, philosophers Kit Fine and Timothy Williamson explore central questions in contemporary metaphysics, including the nature of essence, necessity, modality, and the relationship between metaphysical and logical principles. This interview was organized by Path to Episteme, founded by José Maihub with the participation of Diego Borges, an independent thinker and founder of Spoudaios.

 
These experiments suggest that at least some ghostly experiences can emerge from the brain’s own machinery for distinguishing self from other. But they don’t explain every instance of felt presence.
So phantom limb syndrome and ghostly felt presences might have a somewhat similar neurological basis. So how the ghostly creatures at our door this evening manage to eat physical candy, is the remaining mystery. If they were simply neurological effects I would expect to find a small heap of dropped candy on our porch at evening's end.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: C C
A God's eye view is made impossible by quantum mechanics
https://iai.tv/articles/a-gods-eye-view-is-made-impossible-by-quantum-mechanics-auid-3717?_auid=2020

INTRO: Many scientists and philosophers seek to provide an overall account of the world, often described as a God's eye view, that aims to picture how the universe is as a whole. In this piece, theoretical physicist Eric Cavalcanti argues that quantum mechanics throws a wrench into this idea. Using a simple thought experiment, he shows that at the heart of quantum mechanics, there is a paradox that prevents a God's eye view. The upshot is: reality is different for everyone. (MORE - details)

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Review of "Bernard Williams on Philosophy & History" (edited by Marcel van Ackeren and Matthieu Queloz)
https://drb.ie/article/holding-quicksilver/

INTRO: Bernard Williams is universally acknowledged as a great humanist and one of the major philosophers of his time. Since his death in 2003 there has been a continuous stream of books on his work, of which this large volume is the latest. This is unusual in academic philosophy; there is normally a period in which people draw breath before revisiting even those thinkers who continue to deserve attention.

Part of the explanation is the sheer scope of his work. After the introduction this volume partitions its twenty-two contributors into five sections: Antiquity, Enlightenment, Modernity, Methodology and the History of Philosophy, and History and Genealogy.

A full explanation would also cite the attractive nature of Williams’s writing and conversation. As Miranda Fricker nicely puts it, his ‘thinking and conversation and writing were somehow essentially animated: agile, funny, erudite, candid, rather free with delicious anecdote or ironical comment’. His conversation was delightful, although his writing can prompt puzzlement or even irritation – no sooner has he jumped one fence then he is off to the next one that has captured his interest.

He repays reading but resists pigeonholing, refusing to be pinned down, or to defend one or another of the many ‘isms’ (realism, idealism, historicism, empiricism, relativism that give the bearings usually used to categorise philosophers). He especially hated the big theories found in moral philosophy: utilitarianism, Kantianism. Consequently, identifying what he holds can feel alarmingly like trying to get hold of a piece of quicksilver. Being elusive, he also tends to elude criticism, although as several contributors here show he doesn’t always escape.

As its title suggests, the centre of gravity of this volume is Williams’s relationship with history and especially with the history of philosophy... (MORE - details)

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Long mocked and misunderstood, Lamarck’s radical idea that organisms shape themselves and their world is making a comeback
https://aeon.co/essays/the-self-making-world-of-jean-baptiste-lamarck

EXCERPTS: Throughout the history of modern biology, most powerful figures in science and politics have ridiculed and repressed Lamarck’s radical idea that organisms have agency in the evolutionary process. In mainstream biology today, a neo-Darwinian view of living things as passive still largely dominates, though research in several areas has been challenging its reign.

This is the story of how Lamarck’s radical idea was cast aside by mainstream science, and why it was overlooked for so long. It is also the story of a surprising reversal: in recent decades, some biologists have begun turning back toward Lamarck’s view of life.

[...] Lamarck’s idea of self-making and world-making organisms gained him powerful enemies. His nemesis was the palaeontologist Georges Cuvier, a favourite of Napoleon.

[...] Following Cuvier, many others ridiculed Lamarck’s science. Because it emerged in the midst of the French Revolution and replaced God with the creative agency of living organisms, it smelled to contemporaries of atheism, revolution and regicide. These ill odours promised trouble not only for Lamarck and Lamarckism but for evolutionary theory more generally... (MORE - missing details[/url)
_
 
A God's eye view is made impossible by quantum mechanics
https://iai.tv/articles/a-gods-eye-view-is-made-impossible-by-quantum-mechanics-auid-3717?_auid=2020

INTRO: Many scientists and philosophers seek to provide an overall account of the world, often described as a God's eye view, that aims to picture how the universe is as a whole. In this piece, theoretical physicist Eric Cavalcanti argues that quantum mechanics throws a wrench into this idea. Using a simple thought experiment, he shows that at the heart of quantum mechanics, there is a paradox that prevents a God's eye view. The upshot is: reality is different for everyone. (MORE - details)

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Neuroscientists propose a surprising new home for consciousness
https://www.psypost.org/neuroscientists-propose-a-surprising-new-home-for-consciousness/

EXCERPTS: A new theoretical paper proposes that the most basic feeling of being a conscious self originates in the brainstem rather than the outer layers of the brain. By examining how the brain processes pain, anesthesia, and brain injuries, the authors suggest that raw sentience is computed in an ancient subcortical structure, located beneath the cortex, that acts as a gatekeeper for attention. The hypothesis, published in The Neuroscientist, challenges dominant models of the mind that place conscious awareness within the cerebral cortex... (MORE - details)

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Michael Levin: Memory and intelligence do not require a brain
https://iai.tv/articles/michael-lev...e-do-not-require-a-brain-auid-3719?_auid=2020

INTRO: For over a century, biology has centred genes and evolution in its explanations of behaviour. But synthetic biologist Michael Levin is creating new kinds of lifeform, known as biobots, which he argues challenge that picture. Built from unmodified frog and human cells, Levin’s biobots behave in ways that their genomes and evolutionary history fail to predict. In this interview, he tells the IAI’s Alasdair Craig that biology must do better. The solution, he thinks, may involve taking seriously the idea that biobots have minds, and that memory, learning and purposeful behaviour can exist far beyond the brain and its neurons. (MORE - details)

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

New research tests whether AI models know their own thoughts
https://www.quantamagazine.org/new-...r-ai-models-know-their-own-thoughts-20261104/

INTRO: What’s on your mind right now? You can probably answer this question without thinking too hard about it. Being aware of our own thought processes — a capacity called introspection — seems to come naturally to us.

Yet among philosophers and psychologists, introspection is a subject of active debate. Some think it’s closely related to consciousness. Others argue that it’s an elaborate illusion. It’s tricky to test theories of introspection in the lab — or to pin down a precise definition in the first place.

Now, after over a century of studying introspection in humans and animals, researchers are beginning to explore the phenomenon in unlikely new subjects — large language models. These systems, which are based on mathematical structures called neural networks, excel at cognitive tasks that until recently seemed exclusive to humans. Can they introspect as well?

In 2025, Jack Lindsey, a researcher at Anthropic, devised a way to test introspection in language models by injecting “thoughts” into their neural networks — in a kind of targeted digital neurosurgery. Lindsey’s experiment demonstrated that models could at least sometimes detect and describe these injections. It looked a lot like introspection.... (MORE - details)
_
 
When love became a factor determining marriage in lit and life
https://lifeandletters.substack.com/p/love-plots

EXCERPTS: But love has a social history. In the Renaissance, that inflection point in so many cultural curves, love entered into a new relationship to marriage. The basic change was simple: sometime between the late Middle Ages and the eighteenth century, many people came to believe that love could or even should play a role in the selection of a spouse for both men and women. Love had long been desirable within marriage. But now it would make matches. Ideally, a couple would fall in love first, and marry after -- not the other way around.

It was a radical change that cut across literature and life. The leading erotic ideal in medieval courtly literature, as readers of C.S. Lewis’s magisterial The Allegory of Love will know, was often adulterous, and almost always post- rather than pre-marital—the love of Lancelot and Guinevere or Tristan and Iseult. [...] Extramarital eroticism like Petrarch’s emerged within societies where marriages were arranged, not chosen... (MORE - details)

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Gifts forged from trial: The poems of Sylvia Plath (review)
https://hudsonreview.com/2026/10/gifts-forged-from-trial-the-poems-of-sylvia-plath/

INTRO: On October 25, 1962, two days before her 30th birthday, writing to a mentor, Olive Higgins Prouty, Sylvia Plath reflected on her writing life, framing it, and the study where she worked, as a haven, a “quiet center at the middle of the storm,” the dissolution of her marriage to poet Ted Hughes and her struggle to adjust to life as a single mother of two young children: “I shall forge my writing out of these difficult experiences—to have known the bottom, whether mental or emotional is a great trial, but also a great gift.”

The poems she wrote during this period have since become legendary, gifts forged from trial. But, since the first appearance of many of them in Ariel, her second book of poetry, they have been inextricably associated with her death by suicide on February 11, 1963, rather than as “gifts” in their own right. A long-awaited new collection, The Poems of Sylvia Plath,⁠ edited by Amanda Golden and Karen V. Kukil, offers recuperation: an objective record of the poetic growth—her working process, mastery of her craft, and relentless, steady improvement—that readied Plath to take an incandescent leap in 1962 and early 1963, to be open to what she called, in “Black Rook in Rainy Weather,” “that rare, random descent” that enabled her to write miraculous poetry... (MORE - details)

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

The life and afterlife of French Theory
https://www.theideasletter.org/essay/the-poison-and-the-cure/

EXCERPTS: One of the things that has always distinguished French theory is the extremity of its reception. Having achieved international prominence in the mid-1960s, theory underwent what the historian François Cusset describes as an “anarchic expansion” in the ’70s. Converts found it exhilaratingly radical and innovative, uncovering new techniques and areas of study, but Marxists, such as Jameson and Eagleton, were more skeptical. Others charged it with meretricious obscurity and dismissed its italicized neologisms and occasional quasi-mathematical formulae as a travesty of scientific inquiry.

Theory was a favored target of conservative philosophers in polemical mode. Roger Scruton wrote of “a boiling tide of nonsense” that would “eliminate the possibility of rational argument” and “annihilate meaning.” Alan Bloom, in his bestselling broadside The Closing of the American Mind (1987), accused the French theorists of abetting “the suppression of reason and the denial of the possibility of truth.”

The rehabilitative slant of Eakin’s and Erdur’s accounts indicates theory’s reputation has not recovered. To this day, Erdur writes, French theorists are accused of being “the intellectual originators of destructive social phenomena such as ‘fake news,’ ‘cancel culture,’ wokeness’ and ‘identity politics,’” suggesting that the record, more than two decades after the first postmortems began to appear, is still in need of straightening.

[...] In Cultural Capital: The Problem of Literary Canon Formation (1993), John Guillory argued that the embrace of French theory was the product of a larger crisis. The social value of a literary education was being eroded by the rise of a “professional-managerial class,” which was usurping the old bourgeoisie. Theory appeared to present solutions: the technical fastidiousness of deconstruction mimicked “the technobureaucratic labor” of the ascendant PMC. It not only added a philosophical luster to the measly scrutiny of poems, it licensed the study of any “text,” to use the vogueish term, enlarging the embattled category of literature to colonize other fields, to the degree that literary study could seem not the fusty means to an obsolete sentimental education but the Ur-discipline underlying all the others... (MORE - details)
_
 
Back
Top