No none of what you said is fair. Slagging someone off, defeates any purpose of an intelligable discussion. I could site loads of cases of people talking about subjects they clearly have not been educated on.
I really can't understand how you can keep misrepresenting people so much. I have
repeatedly said there's nothing wrong with asking questions on topics you don't understand. It's starting mini essay threads and throwing in lots of algebra you don't actually understand which is a problem. You
always start by trying to present yourself as way more familiar, on a working level, with the subject matter than you really are.
Why post tensor calculus expressions for the Hodge star when you don't know linear algebra? Why post algebra about curvature when you can't do vector calculus? Why post bar-ket notation when you don't know about inner products?
No one has a problem with you asking questions. It's the "Let's talk about something really advanced on a level which is actually beyond my ability to rationally converse about!" which gets people. Then when you're corrected on something basic you complain about how some source backs you up. It then transpires it doesn't and it's generally also too high a level for you to understand so you've just been parroting it or misrepresenting it.
There is a distinct difference between your types of posts and those from other members. You want to project an image of being knowledgeable when it rapidly becomes apparent you aren't. You then don't like being given advice which requires you accept your lack of knowledge, you consider it being 'slagged off'.
to be honest, I don't care what you think. I still know what a vector is, among other things.
So do 16 year olds. And at least they can actually do some calculations involving them.
Yeah ALPH, because I never said my knowledge on Hodge Duals was extremely limited .... lol
What about your neutrino thread on TSR? You claimed to have a grasp of QFT, which you don't. That's dishonest.
Oh ok then... so people attacking me, my education, in fact just being Reiku is an honest answer?
You were hardly 'attacked'. You were given honest relevant advice. The fact it wasn't what you wanted to hear doesn't make it an attack. Grow up and move on.
An honest answer would have been one which tackled the question, not the starter of the question! I'll make sure this forum has problems from people like me if it keeps up this behaviour and inivitably finds me banned again for no reason.
Most other people manage fine. The common denominator in all your bans is you. Your style is so obvious people spot you almost immediately. That just shows how little you've grown over the years.
Who are you discern such? The last two years I've been studying forensic science. Before that biology!
So you've been studying them along side your 9 years of conciousness in physics? Sure you have.
Well cosnidering your arguements, I remember one of my first-ish posts here spoke about a Hilbert space, which you said much the same thing, but equally never questioned the math!
To what are you referring?
Think? Hopefully anyone with a brain will see.
I could have given you warnings by now, I'd be completely justified, but I haven't. I could have banned Magneto, he posts plenty of utterly wrong mathematics, but I didn't.
You really don't seem to like being told "You're not ready" or "It's beyond your knowledge". Most people learn to accept such things, because it happens to us all. Most people learn from such experiences and take on board the advice given. Why can't you? Seriously, why do you think you're able to do all the high level undergrad, even post grad stuff without the grounding in the basics? Why are you special? If you're so capable why aren't you studying physics in university somewhere? Why aren't you doing physics professionally? Please explain to me why you think you don't need to do what every single physicist has had to do. Why are you above such suggestions as "Perhaps you should read about vectors before doing vector calculus?" and other such logical, reasonable suggestions?
