I don't think Croats and Serbs and Bosnian Muslims can tell each other apart visually or by spoken accent but they could still figure out who was who well enough to kill each other.
Which illustrates my contention that each instance of racism has its own unique identifier. Frankly, despite the likelihood of genetic markers in the various Slavic tribes, based upon my travels in Eastern Europe I suspect that all of the modern Slavic peoples identify each other primarily, if not exclusively, by culture and language, rather than by appearance. The ebb and flow of imperial dominance in the modern era has resulted in considerable migration and intermarriage throughout the Slavic region, with the Russians of the Soviet era being merely the most recent. Furthermore, the Germans and Austrians (a Western Indo-European people) and the Hungarians (a non-Indo-European people related to the Finns, Sami and Estonians) have also taken their turn in the gene pool blender. None of my Czech friends ever claimed to be able to spot a Pole by his looks; the same for my Serbian and Bulgarian friends regarding each other. Even my Hungarian friends seemed reluctant to guess the nationality of a Slav or a German until they heard him speak.
Since American tourists were rare 40 years ago, everywhere I went with my olio of Czech, Jewish and English DNA giving me a cosmopolitan but vaguely Eastern European countenance, people often approached me speaking their native language, assuming I was one of them.
Since Serbo-Croatian is a single language, for them "racial" differences are strictly about religion: the Serbs are Orthodox whereas the Croats are Catholic. The Kosovars are the "Bosnian Muslims" you refer to, and they are obviously also identified by religion; however they have considerable Albanian ancestry (an Eastern Indo-European people but distinct from both the Slavs and the Indo-Iranians) so they may have visible identifiers as well.
I think that is more than a little oversimplified. There is no reason to think that there was not almost as much diversity within the hypothesized four races 15KYA as there is now.
Au contraire. As I pointed out, Paleolithic people avoided traveling outside their own tribes' boundaries, which was literally punishable by death. There's evidence suggesting that at the height of the season when there was plenty of food, tribes who were close both geographically and genetically may have called a truce, held festivals and exchanged a bit of DNA. But the lack of horses and wheels, the need to spend most of their time finding food, and the hostility of neighboring tribes after festival season ended, prevented them from traveling more widely.
As today's fast and affordable DNA analysis is applied to more and more of the Paleolithic corpses we keep digging up, we'll have a much better genetic map of our ancestors. But so far it appears that there really were four distinct populations for about twenty thousand years, separated by geography: water, mountains, climate, etc. The Australians, in particular, were very thoroughly isolated once sea level rose back to its current level and it was no longer quite so easy to sail to and from the continent on a primitive raft.
We have bred dogs into all sorts of strange races of dogs but what happens when you randomly let them interbreed for a few generations? Something like the proto-dog starts re-emerging.
And the same is clearly happening to our species, but the process is a long way from completion.
Even now who the hell are the Mongloids and what is Asia? Asia is absurd as a continent because it is too big and to diverse to be comparable to the other continents.
Even with the transportation technology of the Iron Age, geography made travel between the civilizations of the Far East and those of India and the Middle East quite difficult. There's a reason that the Silk Road stands as an icon of cultural contact. With Stone Age technology that would have been a journey of epic proportions.
The same is true of the water, mountains and other obstacles that separate Europe from the rest of the Afro-Eurasian continent.
Homo sapiens didn't even colonize the place until about 25KYA, leaving it as the last Neanderthal homeland.
The Americas are the most recently colonized large land mass. Humans first arrived here around 15KYA. Their DNA shows them to be clearly of "Mongoloid" origin, and in fact 21st century research appears to have identified the Siberian tribe of their ancestors. Even their language is tentatively related to the Na-Dene family, pushing linguistic relationships back almost ten thousand years earlier than had ever been done before.
If we believe the story of Abraham the Jews begin with a Iraqi region tribe invading Canaan. But Hebrew is not an Iraqi region language.
Fortunately we have more reliable evidence than Bronze Age mythology. The Semites are one of six Afroasiatic ethnic groups, the only one whose homeland was in Asia. (Their five cousins are descended from explorers who reverse-migrated back to North Africa, using Neolithic agricultural technology to survive and repopulate the region which the Paleolithic Africans had to abandon when it became a desert. This history is not universally accepted and there are other hypotheses, but I find it convincing.)
The first evidence of the Semitic peoples is on the Arabian Peninsula around 6000BCE. They spread throughout southwestern Asia, and eventually the Semitic languages were divided into three groups:
- East Semitic, now extinct, represented by Akkadian.
- South Semitic, which spans Sinai and includes both Amharic (migration back to Africa continued after the original wave) and languages spoken in Yemen.
- West Semitic, the most successful group. This is broken into two subgroups. One is Modern Arabic and all the historical Arabic languages; the other covers everything else, including Hebrew, Aramaic and Phoenician.
Hebrew and Phoenician are descended from Proto-Canaanite, which arose in the Levant. The Palestinians and Lebanese are also Canaanites and are the Jews' closest relatives (I suspect they are descended from the Canaanites who chose not to adopt Judaism), but they now speak Arabic, practice Islam, and identify themselves as Arabs.
The greatest muddling of Jews happened not because of conquest but rather from intermarriage with non-Jews in the diaspora.
Indeed. But since throughout the Diaspora they were most often treated as second-class citizens (or worse), the distinction between that and conquest is subtle.
The word slave comes from Carolingian Europe/ old French because a large proportion of those slaves were Slavs. So the word "slave" itself incorporates a phase when race/ethnicity played a role in who would become a slave.
During the Early Middle Ages the empires of Western Europe preyed upon the people they conquered in Eastern Europe. The word for "slave" in the Slavic languages goes back to a root that means "one who changes allegiances," i.e., from himself to his master. This became
rob-/rab- as in Russian
rabotat', "to work," and is the source of the word
robot coined by Czech playwright Karel Čapek (he gave his brother Josef the credit).
I agree with this. I think the foundations of racism can be found In the way groups of Lions, Wolves, Hyenas, Baboons and Chimpanzees treat other groups of their same species. I think it is only after humans form into larger groups and alliances of tribes that racial features start being applied to the instincts for tribal antagonism.
As I noted in my previous post, humans are a pack-social species and it goes against our nature to form harmonious and cooperative communities with strangers. This is a triumph of reasoned and learned behavior over instinctive behavior, a phenomenon that is essentially unique to humans because our massive forebrain gives us the ability to override messages from our midbrain. But this override comes with a cost: the midbrain occasionally pushes through and encourages us to be suspicious or hostile to those strangers. Obviously we can't reject them all or civilization would collapse, so we find clever ways to divide them into "us" and "them."
TO REFOCUS THIS DISCUSSION ON THE ORIGINAL QUESTION FOR A MOMENT:
My reasoned hypothesis, based on millennia of evidence, is that each instance of racism is largely crafted rather than instinctive, and that the "racial" identifier varies from instance to instance, occurring often but by no means consistently. This is my rebuttal to the premise that "racism is about appearance."
PEER REVIEW IS INVITED AT THIS POINT.
If anyone has strong evidence to falsify my rather well-supported hypothesis, please step forward and present it in accordance with the Scientific Method. This is, after all, a place of science and scholarship.
Something like racism makes animals mate with their own species but this does not create antagonism towards other species.
No, that's the mating instinct. Remember that unlike humans, chimpanzees and dolphins, the overwhelming majority of mammals are only physically capable of copulation when the females are in estrus ("heat") and the males are aroused by the pheromones they emit. A male has to be of the same species for the female's pheromones to arouse him (although it is sometimes possible between closely related species) and furthermore there are often visual and other cues in addition to the (conscious or unconscious) odor of the pheromones. Lions and tigers, for example, are genetically capable of mating and hybrids have been produced in captivity (usually by AI). But tigers require having their mate claw them to become sexually aroused, whereas lions with their non-retractable claws hate this. This may occur in the wild under stress. Wolves and coyotes have been hybridizing in eastern Canada, since the wolf population has been drastically reduced by humans and they're having trouble finding mates. The resulting gigantic wolf-coyote hybrids are crossing back into the eastern USA, where they will doubtless solve our deer problem.
The definition of "species" has changed since I took biology in 1958, but one of the criteria is now "willingness to mate." Under normal conditions mammals are only willing to mate within their own species, and furthermore they are willing to mate
with any subspecies, population, variety, breed, etc. of that species. The only reason that distinct subspecies arise is geographical separation or human-directed selective breeding.
Humans are no exception. Even during the era of slavery in America, Southern slaveowners routinely mated with their female African slaves. The extent of this dirty little secret is unfolding now, as DNA testing has become a compulsion in race-obsessed America.
The mental flexibility regarding who is "us" and who is "them" seems to to be present throughout humans. It makes me think that tribal alliances must have begun a very long time ago. How long would it take the instincts that enable tribal alliances to be present and strong in all humans?
As I noted above, this is actually a
conflict between instinct and reason. What we have been doing for the past twelve thousand years is teaching our inner caveman to redefine what constitutes a "pack." In the Paleolithic Era it was the couple of dozen extended family members who hunted and gathered together for life. In the Neolithic Era it was several extended families who combined their efforts for efficient agriculture, yet they were still well acquainted, if not intimately. The first cities required people to learn to live in harmony and cooperation with people they barely knew, and as the cities grew into civilizations of cities linked by commerce and culture, they had to regard strangers as pack-mates.
Cities became states became nations, and we had to extend that harmony and cooperation to people we would never meet, but who made a compact with us that they trusted us and cared for us and shared our core values. Frequent wars gave us a chance to solidify that relationship by actually sacrificing our lives for each other, but unfortunately it also solidified our animosity toward the pack on the other side of the front.
Today's transnational communities are pushing that pack definition even further. See the Germans rescue the Greeks, grumbling all the while, but doing it because this phenomenal extension of harmony and cooperation will (hopefully!) make life better for everyone.
A great many of us have gone a step beyond, and find ourselves able to regard people as pack-mates who live on the other side of the planet and are nothing but abstractions to us. I am by no means the only American who wept over the video of Neda the Iranian dying in the street. She was a member of a people that we don't even really like very much, but dammit, she was
one of us, a human being.
There is hope.
As I have opined on this forum many times, I think that the greatest force for perpetuating our atavistic pack-social behavior is Abrahamic religion. The holy books of the Christians, Jews and Muslims all contain passages which are often interpreted as commands to regard people outside their faith as inferior.
This neatly points back to Nirakar's original observations about the Catholic Croats, Orthodox Serbs and Muslim Kosovars. That instance of racism is all about Abrahamic religion.
Some of us find it much harder than others of us to ally with people who are not like us. How we are raised probably explains most of the variation . . . .
You bet. Our species' incredibly long childhood is unique. Even elephants and whales reach adulthood in two years. Our parents and other elders spend two decades teaching us "how to be successful humans." Our instinctive behavior is vastly augmented by reasoned and learned behavior. Our instinct to distrust, fear and reject people outside of our pack can be easily focused by our parents and elders.
My parents did a crappy job in many important ways, but they did one wonderful thing that I didn't even know about until I was older: they raised me not to be a racist. They compulsively brought me into contact with Afro-Americans (in Chicago where I was born) and with Latinos (in Arizona where I would have grown up had I chosen to undergo that process). They never said a word about it, merely taught me by example that those folks were people just like us and there was nothing the least bit remarkable about them. I wasn't until I was about fourteen that I heard one of them slip and make a derogatory remark about "those colored people," and a couple of years later about "those Mexicans."
My parents were racists! Yet they knew, deep down inside, that that was wrong. They did not have the strength to change themselves, but they would be damned if they would pass the teachings of their parents down to me. Boy was that ever a revelation I had to spend some time struggling with.
. . . . but I suspect that we may have quite a bit of genetic variation in our instincts regarding "us them antagonism" and how different somebody can be and still be accepted as one of "us".
Sure. As I pointed out in my previous post, we've gone through about seven hundred generations since the Neolithic Revolution, when pack-social behavior became something of a liability. Dogs, in contrast, have gone through twelve thousand generations. Their instincts are distinctly different from those of wolves, members of the same species.
My dog will run joyfully up to
absolutely any dog he encounters and crouch to make the pitty-pat front paw gesture which is Universal Dog Language for "Hi pal, I ain't no alpha. Let's play!"
How about all of us doing that? Oh wait, that's what we're doing right here on SciForums with our "virtual pack-mates," isn't it!