Forth Worth Shooter's execution to be live streamed, Pentagon confirms

Will you watch it?

  • I will definitely watch that!

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • :shrug: just another news item

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    8
I don't know if you're old enough to recall the 70s urban legend which claimed that green M&Ms were an aphrodisiac.
Yep I remember that. I ignored it like all the other urban myths of the day. "The actor that played Mikey ate pop rocks and drank soda and his STOMACH EXPLODED!"

Of all things to become outraged about, green M+Ms wearing sneakers was very far down on my list of possibilities. But nowadays, any outrage that can be weaponized - is.
 

I know how i feel, I just wonder what the general sentiment is.
This is, for me, the most scary development in my adult life - more scary than 9/11 and Covid...i understand some may believe that to be an overreaction but this speaks to me in volumes i have never felt before.

I was born in the west, have been raised in the west on western ideals and i always, always believed that they were the voice of reason in the world - at least on paper. i have been lucky enough to have done a decent amount of travelling around the world and i know, that ultimately, individual people are fundamentally the same everywhere - vast majority are decent on a personal level and don't tend to be difficult to relate to when given the chance, so i am lucky in that i never believed that western people were superior, because we are not.

but i did honestly believe our view of society was better, at least on paper...... Russia, North Korea, China - are all authoritarian dictatorships, their people are not free in the way i understand the word. The middle east is a religious cluster of craziness, at a societal level - they are totally adrift in what i can only describe as a totalitarians extremism of hate and anger where again, your average Joe is in no way free in how i describe the word. Africa is a bit of a wildcard with regards to societies, it has a vast spectrum of dictatorships and religious fervor and of course South Africa is downright scary, one of only two countries in the world where i think i narrowly avoided a serious beating through no fault of my own.

South America - well i have never been there, so anything i say would be an unjust assumption, but it doesn't sound all that brilliant, at a societal level - willing to be proved wrong on this however.

As for us, i have said "on paper" a few times because i may be naïve but not entirely so - the ideals that we profess as a society are not the ones we actually live by on a daily basis - our freedoms and our rights are no where as clear cut in reality as they are on this imaginative paper i keep alluding to...... we have organised crime, political corruption, decreasing social cohesion and we often get involved in many of the other regions when i don't think we should. we do play a bit of the snob on the world stage, we have more comforts and believe we have earned them. we have an arrogance at high levels that are not deserved. America has had a lot to do with that, their prosperity is a large part earned legitimately but also basically stolen off other nations, i am not educated enough to know what percentage is what and i wouldn't like to guess....but my point on this is that i never once thought that western society sat atop a pedestal looking down at the rest of the worlds attempts as lesser models - we have absolutely got our own flaws, and in my life time i have seen many of those flaws get worse while some have gotten better.....

but the reason this news is the scariest out of all the modern catastrophes i have personally lived through is because of the "on-paper" element i referenced.... because no matter what happened, how bad certain things appeared or turned out in the end i always believed that the idea was to head towards that "on-paper" ideal that we all shared.....no matter how realistic that ever was, i genuinely believed it was the direction we were all trying to pull.

If this comes to pass, and our society live streams such a barbaric act, if we allow this hate and cruelty to be publicised and applauded not only by the darker elements of our society but by our children, who will absolutely see this despite efforts to stop them doing so, well then that paper i have sheltered under for my entire life has been set alight and i don't see it being extinguished before its too late.

the light from that fire will be the last light we see before a long and scary dark age.
 
This is, for me, the most scary development in my adult life - more scary than 9/11 and Covid...i understand some may believe that to be an overreaction but this speaks to me in volumes i have never felt before.
This is what happens every time you get a polarizing administration. They whip up the malcontents and turn people against one another for political leverage. An administration will come along that is interested in coming back to centre and reconciling opposing views.
 
This is what happens every time you get a polarizing administration. They whip up the malcontents and turn people against one another for political leverage. An administration will come along that is interested in coming back to centre and reconciling opposing views.
i agree with that, but to labour my metaphor - the paper, if we choose to keep using the same ideals, is always a little more singed than before, i dont see it ever getting less singed, and by that i mean, the administration you refer to, wont undo all the damage this one has done.... or am i wrong?

Because to my mind, we need a whole new ledger to start writing in.... or rather more accurately, we need to give our kids a blank one and the proper knowledge not on how to fill it, but on how to not fill it......
 
i agree with that, but to labour my metaphor - the paper, if we choose to keep using the same ideals, is always a little more singed than before, i dont see it ever getting less singed, and by that i mean, the administration you refer to, wont undo all the damage this one has done.... or am i wrong?
One man's damage is another man's progress.
(Dare I say a democrats damage is a republican's progress.)

So, no, they won't undo everything. I think what happens is (among many other facets) special interest groups and human rights groups ask for more consideration, and it swing that way. Then, after years, people start feeling like that's taking away from the budget for core needs, and demand it get rolled back, and it swings back to conservatism and corporatism.

It's a little like cancelling your credit card. Over time, CCs get used for more and more things, especially subscriptions and ongoing costs. One day, you decide you need to tighten your belt, and you cancel you card and get a new one. This pares away all the bloodletting by a thousand papercuts, and your CC doesn't drain so fast. Then you start the cycle again.


(Those who are politically and economically savvy know this stuff already. You can tell by my simplistic description I'm way out of my depth.)
 
Last edited:
One man's damage is another man's progress.

So, no, they won't undo everything. I think what happens is (among many other facets) special interest groups and human rights groups ask for more consideration, and it swing that way. Then, after years, people start feeling like that's taking away from the budget for core needs, and demand it get rolled back, and it swings back to conservatism and corporatism.

(Those who are politically and economically savvy know this already. You can tell by my simplistic description I'm pretty wet behind the ears politico-economically.)
I am not at all politically savvy either my friend - very much a simplistic blunt instrument in such matters...

To be honest - i think, i hope i always will be,
 
the light from that fire will be the last light we see before a long and scary dark age.
I remain optimistic that most Americans are sufficiently revolted (or will be) that this latest madness will be another nail in the MAGA coffin. And it shouldn't distract from the real ongoing darkness in America which is how it bends over like a one dollar whore for predatory capitalism.
 
I remain optimistic that most Americans are sufficiently revolted (or will be) that this latest madness will be another nail in the MAGA coffin. And it shouldn't distract from the real ongoing darkness in America which is how it bends over like a one dollar whore for predatory capitalism.
I expect you are right about the sea change in popular opinion. But for me the live question is whether popular opinion will still count, or whether the ruling party is able to frustrate the will of the people.
 
I expect you are right about the sea change in popular opinion. But for me the live question is whether popular opinion will still count, or whether the ruling party is able to frustrate the will of the people.
I think, to TheVat's point, it will be a matter of whether the "moderate MAGAs" * feel it crosses the line. Pedophilia running amok in the Republican ranks may have softened them up in terms of what they can stomach. I think even they are getting tired of the shenanigans. And if it doesn't ring true with them, Hegseth and Trump likely won't bother. But that remains to be seen.

* a term I made up - I'm not sure if they keep company with leprechauns and unicorns.
 
I think, to TheVat's point, it will be a matter of whether the "moderate MAGAs" * feel it crosses the line. Pedophilia running amok in the Republican ranks may have softened them up in terms of what they can stomach. I think even they are getting tired of the shenanigans. And if it doesn't ring true with them, Hegseth and Trump likely won't bother. But that remains to be seen.

* a term I made up - I'm not sure if they keep company with leprechauns and unicorns.
That may not make any difference if the election is stolen.
 
The Guardian is to my left as a rule but this echoes mine and other sentiments on here.

Should the outrage be with the public streaming or with the death penalty itself? If public streaming of the act is barbaric, perhaps we should focus more on eliminating the act?
 
Should the outrage be with the public streaming or with the death penalty itself? If public streaming of the act is barbaric, perhaps we should focus more on eliminating the act?
No, it is the public part. If the law of that state is the death penalty for certain crimes then that's what it is. We had that law not that long ago and last hanged (two men) in 1964.
Eventually is was abolished.
Streaming it is on a par with ISIS, making a grotesque spectacle, a public circus.
If that is how the US want to be seen now then they are going the right way about it.

The other thing they will do is make this guy a martyr and help extremists radicalise young Muslims, they will have a video and everything.
I had forgotten about this guy till now, at the time I thought some soldier had gone ape shit from PTSD or something.
I like many would probably have not even remembered it was a Muslim psychiatrist, who grew a conscience, decided to take out as many infidel soldiers as possible.
If it was another quiet (and successful) lethal injection.
Now all the the crazy people will get front row seats and froth at the mouth, inspire racists, Muslims/extremists.
 
[...] If public streaming of the act is barbaric, perhaps we should focus more on eliminating the act?

Yes. It's like building a rocketship and never putting fuel and LOX in it (because it is uncivilized, etc). If the product can't be internally consistent or implemented so as to fulfill its own claims, then it's just sideshow propaganda. Discarding an empty facade like that is not a loss, apart from its tool function of garnering votes for populist politicians.

Although deterrence isn't the only submitted reason for capital punishment, it's perhaps the only "physical one" aside from "permanent public protection from murderers" (which seems hardly potent in terms of statistical relevance).

The other reasons are just riding off invented moral appeals, platitudes, or principles that are still treated as sacred even in a secular or non-immaterial belief context. There's no prior-in-rank nomological stratum that is going to zap us for violating ethical fiction or social contracts proposed and submitted by either ideological side. There are practical reasons for adhering to the latter (holding civilization or society together, etc). But no magical mystical agency imbuing either right or left wing preaching concoctions. The universe couldn't care less about us or what tactics animals in general contingently utilize to survive.

That said, even the masses intellectually descended from Marxism and earlier collectivism still need their doctrines to have a correspondence to some pixie land. Nihilism isn't feasible. Reifying behavior-regulating concepts and party allegiances as something Platonically objective and universally true in some other way than upfront classic deification is a necessary psychedelic to feed the loyal herds. Don't eliminate the old manipulative category slots. Just put new literature into those placeholders to create the bogus appearance of a new system that is hygienic (free of metaphysical and supernatural taint).
_
 
Last edited:
Yes, your comment reminds me of Yuval Harari in his "Sapiens" book pointing out that natural rights don't exist beyond agreements of human imagination. Points towards elimination of the DP on anthropological (v moral) grounds, e.g. societies seem to obtain improved metrics on violence and cruelty generally when their institutions don't sponsor them. Switzerland, take a bow.
 
  • Like
Reactions: C C
It seems in one of his rambling speeches Trump has made an oblique reference to some “surprises” “in a few weeks” from his gauleiter Vought (pronounced “Vote”, ironically enough). This could indicate some new legal shenanigans to disrupt, suspend or challenge the result of the mid term elections. Engineered riots and state of emergency? Sudden “discovery” of Chinese components in voting machines? Flurry of legal challenges in states returning Democrats, to delay results until after the final date for swearing in the new Congress? Or some other trick we have not thought of. Frankly I shall be most surprised if they don’t try something.

Certainly it strikes me that the current media discussion about the mid-terms is rather complacent in focusing only on opinion polls etc, as if the electoral process will run normally as usual. I don’t think that is at all a given. There should be some scrutiny of possible attempts to undermine it or skew the results.
My view is they already own the Offices that do the scrutiny. I seriously hope to be wrong.
 
The One About How Trump Isn't In Charge

Alayna Treene summarizes for social media↱:

Trump and his advisers are debating whether to call off plans to livestream the firing squad execution of the Fort Hood shooter, with Trump having remarked privately that he did not initially know that Nidal Hasan was paralyzed from the waist down, two sources familiar with the discussions told CNN​

And that's also her lede for CNN↱. It gets even better:

The president was not aware that Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth was announcing last week that the administration planned to let the public watch the execution, the sources said, and was not sure what to make of it at first. Trump was, however, firmly behind the decision to execute Hasan via firing squad, multiple officials told CNN, and he’s often defended it in public.

And even after Hegseth posted on X on Thursday confirming that the Pentagon planned to livestream the execution, Trump polled several of his advisers and allies about how to proceed.


(boldface accent added)​

Somewhere along the way, Trump learned Hasan was in a wheelchair, and one source suggests Trump has a deep understanding of imagery in order to explain his ambivalence.

The problem with all of this is that in the second quarter of the twenty-first century we have no reason to believe that video footage of the execution won't leak. Some, we can be sure, are counting on it. But this is also one of those things we just cannot, as a nation, take back.
____________________

Notes:

Treene, Alayna. "Trump debates calling off livestream of firing squad execution after learning Fort Hood shooter was paralyzed". CNN. 13 October 2026. CNN.com. 13 October 2026. https://www.cnn.com/2026/10/13/politics/trump-fort-hood-shooter-livestream-execution

 
Yes, your comment reminds me of Yuval Harari in his "Sapiens" book pointing out that natural rights don't exist beyond agreements of human imagination. Points towards elimination of the DP on anthropological (v moral) grounds, e.g. societies seem to obtain improved metrics on violence and cruelty generally when their institutions don't sponsor them. Switzerland, take a bow.
Finding those alternatives. If only we lived in the days before postmodern critiques of science and the current eroding of confidence (due to other reasons) when research carried enough weight to settle an issue or take the wind out of one of the quarreling positions once and for. (Though no doubt I'm entertaining a past as mythical as Lemuria.)

I'm not necessarily knocking moral realism as much as kind of asking: "If I was a materialist, physicalists, naturalist, non-occultist, whatever -- is moral realism actually consistent or compatible with that kind of background belief or more fundamental thought orientation?"

And then one ventures into the evaluations:
  • #Criticisms: Several criticisms have been raised against moral realism. A prominent criticism, articulated by J.L. Mackie, is that moral realism postulates the existence of "entities or qualities or relations of a very strange sort, utterly different from anything else in the universe. Correspondingly, if we were aware of them it would have to be by some faculty of moral perception or intuition, utterly different from our ordinary ways of knowing everything else." Several theories have been developed for how we access objective moral truths, including ethical intuitionism and moral sense theory.

    Another criticism of moral realism put forth by Mackie is that it can offer no plausible explanation for cross-cultural moral differences—ethical relativism. "The actual variations in the moral codes are more readily explained by the hypothesis that they reflect ways of life than by the hypothesis that they express perceptions, most of them seriously inadequate and badly distorted, of objective values".

    The evolutionary debunking argument suggests that because human psychology is primarily produced by evolutionary processes which do not seem to have a reason to be sensitive to moral facts, taking a moral realist stance can only lead to moral skepticism. The argument aims to undercut the motivation for taking a moral realist stance, namely to be able to assert there are reliable moral standards.

    Biologist Richard D. Alexander has written, "Ethical questions, and the study of morality or concepts of justice and right and wrong, derive solely from the existence of conflicts of interest", and that such conflicts are a necessary consequence of genetic individuality. He also wrote, "Because morality involves conflicts of interest, it cannot easily be generalized into a universal despite virtually continual efforts by utilitarian philosophers to do that; morality does not derive its meaning from sets of universals or undeniable facts." Alexander's views are shared by many scientists and starkly contradict moral realism.
One thing is for sure: We don't really want nihilism. I'm not sure I could even fully trust someone who is NOT subconsciously addicted to regarding _X_ rule as a sacred principle, even if at an intellectual level they realize that might be incoherent with a broader belief they hold.

And really, that "sacred" inhibitor is a conjoined twin to guilt (along with empathy): The fear of being tortured by psychological consequences afterwards (no need for external threat of being struck by lightning). Perhaps still not quite "physical" to the satisfaction of some, but real enough for the phenomenal acknowledger.
_
 
Another criticism of moral realism put forth by Mackie is that it can offer no plausible explanation for cross-cultural moral differences—ethical relativism. "The actual variations in the moral codes are more readily explained by the hypothesis that they reflect ways of life than by the hypothesis that they express perceptions, most of them seriously inadequate
One response to Mackie might be cross-cultural studies that find commonalities under the differences, i.e. conflicts of interest and their resolution will depend on principles of trust and fair compensation. Or community safety - we sapiens tend to form villages and depend on its networks of trust and exchange. Not universals in some ontological sense, maybe, but universal in a more limited sense of spanning a whole species. You mention the human need for trust and for trust that all are honoring some principle - these would be seen in all social animals, that assertion that individuals "don't really want nihilism."

The ethical questions of a death penalty - if we eliminate metaphysical conjurings (e.g. only God can give or take life, per the RC church) - and take them down to the most basic anthropological concept of community, would be attached to the trust issues (is it capricious, is it error prone?) and to community order (does official violence make violence seem more legitimate?) and to the individual ability to make contributions and repay society (reform, remorse, helping others on a bad path, etc.). DK, I guess many people just prefer the certainties they find in a moral grounding in some supreme metaphysical ordering of the universe towards goodness. DP opposition will make for strange bedfellows, for sure.
 
  • Like
Reactions: C C
Back
Top