Battlestar Galactica vs. Star Wars

no jedi, no republic fighters, meh:p

The battle ships from the empire MAY be stronger but the fighters on the republic side are so much stronger
 
Actually... that first movie showed the singular reason why I think BSG could potentially win that (assuming the upgraded Mk. 6/7 Vipers and all that good stuff) - NEVER in Star Wars do we see a vessel lined up against it's direction of travel... yet in BSG, they routinely will hit the booster, cut their engines, flip upside down, and blast the poor SOB following them, all without changing direction... I mean, c'mon, it's an effective strat against fighters and missiles alike!
 
I agree that on fighters, BSG appears to have Star Wars beat. That said, the Empire has doomsday weapons like the Death Stars, the Eye of Palpatine, the Interplanetary Ion Cannon, Eclipse-Class Super Star Destroyers, etc.

These are weapons with levels of power that are basically ludicrous, able to destroy whole planets in a single shot. (One source indicated that the energy output of the reactors on a Victory Class Star Destroyer was comparable to that of a middle-of-the-road Main Sequence star...and that of the more advanced Star Destroyers were many times greater than such a star's, because that much power was needed to power the superweapons and get them into hyperspace).

The best the colonials have is nuclear weapons, perhaps in the 50 megaton range from what I could gather (since that's what I believe the cylons used on Caprica, and if they could have done better, one imagines they would have). That's a lotta power, but it's not ludicrous power, and not in the range of "stellar equivalent".

I also have to wonder if Viper fire and a Battlestar's battery fire could penetrate deflector shields, since their whole point is to deflect projectiles and the brunt of energy weapons...and those Victory class Star Destroyers had them, even if the Tie fighters didn't.

So the edge goes to BSG if we ignore the places where Star Wars ignored physics and common sense. If we take the stories at face value though, without those judgments, and we do not allow for improbable "single pilot" kills of massive capital ships (which to be fair are also a Star Wars staple), I think the Empire has the edge.

If we limit things to what's in the video, then I guess it comes down to whether the Colonials can breach the shields of the Star Destroyers, before being shot to pieces.
 
A couple of ships and a few more fighters against the entire EMPIRE? This is a no brainer in the SW direction. Just think pure numbers here. Even if EACH BSG fighter killed one star destroyer there are THOUSANDS OF THEM!!!!
 
My point was merely that BSG had the tactics advantage (since, ya know, Star Wars doesn't seem to know what tactics actually are... much less tactical maneuvering... heh)
 
My point was merely that BSG had the tactics advantage (since, ya know, Star Wars doesn't seem to know what tactics actually are... much less tactical maneuvering... heh)

Actually, if you watch the movies Star Wars follows a 3d representation of common Naval tactics. Group your Capital ship in Picket lines beacuase their job is to provide overwhelmiing firepower and a base for fighter launches. Even if you performed evasive manuever your trying to dodge when you are in excess of 300 meters long and tall. You're just a big target. Then you have your secondary level of combat, the fighters and smaller ships that attack and defend using manueverbility, speed and hit and run attacks.


BTW in case you are thinking Star Wars does not have tactics they are mentioned in the books several times.

Parade Shield Reinforcement: Your Capital Ships fly close enough together to reinforce each others shields. This does sacrifice some firepower thanks to being blocked by friendly hulls, but it has it uses.

The A Wing Slash aka The Proton Torpedo Slash: Used to clean up trained squadrons of fighters. A group of slower fighters gets the enemy to follow them, then suddnely the slwoer fighter scatter as coming head on is the Squadron of A-wings or hundred of Proton Torpedos.


In al all oit BSG vs Star Wars it is most definately Star Wars without a doubt.

Taking a suitably old vessel the Old Republic Dreadnaught and it compliment of fighters the battle is more even. Though you must admit Star Wars does hav superior fire power and Defenses.
 
Actually, if you watch the movies Star Wars follows a 3d representation of common Naval tactics. Group your Capital ship in Picket lines beacuase their job is to provide overwhelmiing firepower and a base for fighter launches.
Some mistake here, surely.
Capital ships in navies weren't generally used in picket lines, they were grouped in the centre, with pickets provided by destroyers and the like. :rolleyes:
 
Some mistake here, surely.
Capital ships in navies weren't generally used in picket lines, they were grouped in the centre, with pickets provided by destroyers and the like. :rolleyes:

Hey, i just looked at what they did in the movies. in ROTJ those ISD were in a 3d picket line to avoid the enemies escape, it devolved in a massive point bank firefight
 
Hey, i just looked at what they did in the movies.
And then claimed that was what happened in actual naval battles.

Oh, and you're misusing the term "point blank". But that's a common mistake.
 
And then claimed that was what happened in actual naval battles.

I am certain there have bee a time or two that capital shisp have participated in a picket line. People got my point however. There are two layers to fleet engagements when you have Capital ships and fighter craft.

Oh, and you're misusing the term "point blank". But that's a common mistake.

Consider they were ordered to close to point blank range, it;s no longer and misuse of terms.
 
Consider they were ordered to close to point blank range, it;s no longer and misuse of terms.
Right. And everyone if the movie decided call the ISDs "fish" that wouldn't be a misuse either. :rolleyes:
 
Uhm... picket lines wouldn't even make SENSE in space as it's, you know, 3D... unless you can fully encircle the enemy then they can just escape another direction...
 
Right. And everyone if the movie decided call the ISDs "fish" that wouldn't be a misuse either. :rolleyes:

In addition to its technical meaning, in English the term "point-blank" has also come to mean "at very close range". That's not "wrong" per se, it's just the use of the term in a variation that differs from its original meaning. Since the new meaning is generally accepted though, and as there is no official "Académie Anglaise" to set the standard for all of English, our definitions shift around over time, based on how people actually use the terms.

We could then debate descriptism vs prescriptivism, but the truth is that we all speak a language that has evolved over time. Proof of that point:

"Thus swived was the carpentere's wife, enjoyed
For all his keeping and his jealousy; care
And Absolon hath kiss'd her nether eye;
And Nicholas is scalded in the tout,"

is English, and there was no moment when it stopped being English (and even when , much later, labels were attached calling it "Middle English," the English people spoke wasn't our preferred form of English).

Once upon a time "decimate" meant to destroy one out of every ten of a thing, then later it came to be used to mean the destruction of any arbitrarily large number (up to total annihilation). (And then, centuries later, some guy started saying the latter use was "wrong" because he persopnally preferred the older Latin meaning.)
 
Uhm... picket lines wouldn't even make SENSE in space as it's, you know, 3D... unless you can fully encircle the enemy then they can just escape another direction...


Oy Vey. Can everyone be more literal. Applying a touch of common sense you make a Net. Not that hard to understand.

The point is that Star Wars, like Babylon 5, Battle Star Galactica, Firefly/Serenity, and Wing Commander among others recognizes the difference between Capital Ship combat and Fighter Combat.
 
Oy Vey. Can everyone be more literal. Applying a touch of common sense you make a Net. Not that hard to understand.

The point is that Star Wars, like Babylon 5, Battle Star Galactica, Firefly/Serenity, and Wing Commander among others recognises the difference between Capital Ship combat and Fighter Combat.

Its my understanding that in real historical terms the decline of the Battleship was largely caused by the development of the aircraft carrier and torpedo bombers that were launched from these sorts of ships.

The Bismarck, Germany's most powerful battleship withstood an assault by the British navy and sunk their most powerful ship the Hood with one shoot.

But even as powerful as this ship was, in the end it was was sunk by Swordfish biplanes launched from an aircraft carrier.

So it's not a long shot to say that in this science fiction scenario capital ships would be vulnerable to attacks by swarms of smaller ships.
 
Its my understanding that in real historical terms the decline of the Battleship was largely caused by the development of the aircraft carrier and torpedo bombers that were launched from these sorts of ships.

The Bismarck, Germany's most powerful battleship withstood an assault by the British navy and sunk their most powerful ship the Hood with one shoot.

But even as powerful as this ship was, in the end it was was sunk by Swordfish biplanes launched from an aircraft carrier.

So it's not a long shot to say that in this science fiction scenario capital ships would be vulnerable to attacks by swarms of smaller ships.

Example - Death Star
 
Example - Death Star

The Death Star's weakness was more of an example of bad writing. No real engineer would ever have left that exhaust port exposed and vulnerable.

Battleships were taken out not by swarms of smaller ships, but really by a fundamental change in technology that forced a complete change in tactics. It was important that planes were fast moving and hard hitting relative to the strength of Battleship armor...and if the armor was breached, a battleship could sink.

It's not well established that the bullets from a Viper would have any serious impact on a Death Star, and if they could even pass the deflector shields of a Star Destroyer (which have to be able to deflect meteorites of comparable mass traveling at far greater velocities). A nuke might certainly make it past the shields, but isn't going to bring down the whole ship.

(If it could, why didn't navies in Star Wars use nukes? Surely they had that technology.)

I think a navy using bullets and missiles against one using deflector shields and directed energy weapons is like bringing a spear to a gun fight.
 
Back
Top