I am an atheist and am amused by, theist attempts to use advocate creationism & ID via logical arguments. They are ignoring one of the best arguments
: god created a mature universe.
BTW: Note that to be consistent with my atheist beliefs, I do not capitalize
god.
Theists who are fighting evolution & advocating Creationism/ID are giving up their best weapon (faith) & attempting to use logic at which they are not very adept (downright poor, might be more accurate).
Consider the mature universe argument.
- When god created the garden of Eden, there were trees which looked 100 or more years old. If Adam had cut one of those trees down, polished the stump, & counted rings, he would have had evidence that the tree was 100 or more years old, even though god had created it a few days or a few weeks earlier.
- When god created the stars, would it make sense for him to create them unseen by man for millions/billions of years? Why should he not also create light from those stars arriving at Earth about the same time as he created the Earth, Adam, Eve, the Garden, et cetera? Of course, modern scientists would come up with experiments & theories showing that the light took million/billions of years to get here even though god created the arriving light about the same time that he created the rest of the universe.
- Why try to claim that Noah’s flood carved the Grand Canyon, in 40-180 days? It is easier to claim that god decided to create the Grand Canyon about the same time that he created the Garden of Eden.
- Scientists use radioactive decay to date various historical events, proving that the Earth is millions/billions of years old. If god created the radioactive elements & their decay products a few thousand years ago, such proofs are without merit.
No logical argument can refute the Mature Universe Theory. All the scientific arguments alleged to prove that Earth is billions of years old & that the universe is even older are refuted by the Mature Universe Theory.
The Mature Universe Theory is a faith based argument. A theist can advocate it as based on faith alone & no atheist can provide a logical argument refuting it. An atheist can only claim that his belief in science seems more consistent with his interpretation of certain measurements & that he chooses to believe in science.
Believers in the Mature Universe Theory could believe that god created the universe last week or two years ago, complete with our memories extending decades into the past, libraries containing history books, radioactive materials & decay products, light from distant stars, et cetera. Of course, many Christian theists would prefer to a accept a creation about 6-10 thousand years ago consistent with the Old Testament account.
Believers in the Mature Universe Theory can amuse themselves by laughing at the scientists on whom god has played a marvelous practical joke. The can imagine god & his angels in heaven having conversations about the scientists who have been fooled by his creation of a mature universe.