Are the benefits of magnesium a half truth or a myth?

entelecheia

Registered Senior Member
Caroline Dean argues the tired argument that pharmaceutical companies are not interested in funding an investigation on a nutrient that can not be patented. Would it be worth spending money on magnesium tablets, in this time of economic crisis?
 
My intense neck pains became significantly less frequent. That's the only reason I continue taking it. So unfortunately I have no anecdote donations for the "Astounding Cancer Cure / Fountain of Youth / It Grew Back My Severed Legs" folks.
 
My intense neck pains became significantly less frequent. That's the only reason I continue taking it.
Doctors told you it is idiopathic? After reading parts of the Caroly'n book The Miracle of Magnesium, searching hungry for solid evidence, concluded it is another fraud that manages to sell books availing the placebo:shrug: effect. Another thesis ''reproacher of the egoistic farmaceutical interests''.

So unfortunately I have no anecdote donations for the "Astounding Cancer Cure / Fountain of Youth / It Grew Back My Severed Legs" folks.
If true, this kind of best-sellers are not scandalous steals? How many millions gained magnesiun sellers giving 0 benefits for health?
 
Caroline Dean argues the tired argument that pharmaceutical companies are not interested in funding an investigation on a nutrient that can not be patented. Would it be worth spending money on magnesium tablets, in this time of economic crisis?

No. Most people need about 400mg/day. Wheat, spinach, nuts etc are all good sources and most people get all they need from their diet. If not a basic multivitamin will give you all you need. Taking more than that will not improve your health.
 
After reading parts of the Caroly'n book The Miracle of Magnesium [...]

You mean there really is a book?! I could understand a page of info about signs of deficiency, and maybe some extended elaboration -- but a whole book filled with wondrous claims? Sheeeesh....
 
No. Most people need about 400mg/day. Wheat, spinach, nuts etc are all good sources and most people get all they need from their diet. If not a basic multivitamin will give you all you need. Taking more than that will not improve your health.
Carolyn Dean shows a comprehensive list of the best food sources of magnesium, but didn't mention bioavailability of each one. Could you quote this investigation (if exist) please? How to be sure we are absorbing enough amount from these foods rich on magnesium?
 
Carolyn Dean shows a comprehensive list of the best food sources of magnesium, but didn't mention bioavailability of each one.

Any food-safe magnesium compound is bioavailable. (Obviously metallic magnesium is not.) We don't transport magnesium actively; it is absorbed passively. So longer time in GI tract increases absorption, elimination (urine and feces) removes magnesium.

How to be sure we are absorbing enough amount from these foods rich on magnesium?

The RDA value is the amount you should eat to absorb enough magnesium. You don't have to calculate "gee, I am only absorbing half the magnesium so I better eat twice the RDA." RDA takes that into account.
 
Magnesium is good for preventing constipation, not one of my health issues though. :shrug:
 
The RDA value is the amount you should eat to absorb enough magnesium. You don't have to calculate "gee, I am only absorbing half the magnesium so I better eat twice the RDA." RDA takes that into account.

http://www.mayoclinic.com/health/food-and-nutrition/AN00284 Found this:
If a food has 5 percent or less of a nutrient, it's considered to be low in that nutrient.
If it has 20 percent or more, it's considered to be high in that nutrient.

And a Chart:
http://ods.od.nih.gov/factsheets/Magnesium-HealthProfessional/ Is it the most reliable chart to stick it on my kitchens wall?
 
Magnesium is one of those critical minerals that take part in of hundreds of processes in the human body. It is essential for good health.

It is true you can get some from foods, and that might be enough for some people. It would seem in the past we would acquire a lot from our drinking water and bathing water (absorbed through the skin), but domestic water supplies filter out most of the magnesium. And modern agriculture has depleted a great deal more from the soil, so vegetables and fruits no longer have the quantities enjoyed by our ancestors.

A multi vitamin will usually not contain magnesium or if it does it will be a tiny amount. Magnesium is very bulky and will not fit in those tiny multi-vit pills.

Many people do not easily absorb magnesium well and for them a supplement would be ideal. An easy sign of deficiency is if you suffer from cramps, especially leg cramps often during the night. Also constipation is a sign of magnesium deficiency.

Magnesium is a muscle relaxant, and hence the relief from muscle cramps. It is also plays a critical osmotic role in moving fluids into the bowels and keeping stools soft and hence avoids constipation, assuming you are adequately hydrated.

Magnesium is not usually found on its own and is usually bound to something else, so supplements would normally come as magnesium oxide or magnesium citrate. The citrate version seems to have the best bio absorption rate.

Magnesium is very cheap. In hospitals it is given often to those with heart conditions and most doctors seem to know its benefits well. Not much profit for drug companies of course so you won't see its benefits advertised.

RDA is about 400mg/day, which for most is on the very low side. An 800mg dose or 1.5g would be better. Higher doses cause loose stools, so one reason magnesium is a main ingredient in many laxatives.
 
I've been told that magnesium is especially difficult to actually absorb into the body. Some people advocate getting it as a solution and spraying or spreading it on the skin, rather trying to ingest it in the digestive tract.
 
Back
Top