Anyone familiar with H3O2 ?

Write4U

Valued Senior Member
Just watched a very interesting video on H3O2, aka the 4th state of water.
Ep3 - WATER: A Scientific Revolution, with Dr. Gerald Pollack, Bioengineering Scientist
Dr. Edith Ubuntu Chan
DESCRIPTION
WATER is the most abundant molecule on planet earth and in our bodies. But how much do we really know about Water? For example, did you know that Water has the ability to be CHARGED UP BY LIGHT, like a rechargeable solar battery? And did you know that Water can STORE INFORMATION like a liquid crystal computer?
 
Just watched a very interesting video on H3O2, aka the 4th state of water.
Ep3 - WATER: A Scientific Revolution, with Dr. Gerald Pollack, Bioengineering Scientist
Dr. Edith Ubuntu Chan
Aha, this old chestnut again.

I did a fair bit of work on looking into this topic, three years ago, on another forum. There is no such molecule as H3O2, as anyone with basic chemical competence will realise. (It would have to be an odd-electron molecule or an ion for which someone has forgotten to include the charge.) So I thought I'd better find out what it was all about. For any interested readers, I copy below the text of the long post I made at the time after digging into it:

"Actually, I've had a chance to read around this "EZ water" thingie a bit more today. I found it was in fact referenced on the site I linked to earlier, about the various crank theories of water. The writer does not dismiss Pollack but, being a chemist, is sceptical, as am I!

I think I understand what Pollack thinks he is on to. He thinks he has evidence that wetted hydrophilic surfaces (e.g. glass, or cellular proteins) can impose a longer-range order on the adjacent water molecules than is generally recognised. He thinks this order excludes solute molecules from a layer close to the surface, rather as solute molecules are excluded from ice crystals as they form. As you may know, the developing lattice structure in a crystal can achieve greater stability (shorter and stronger bonding) by excluding foreign items that disrupt the regularity of the order - hence why salt depresses the melting point of ice and so forth.

What is bizarre is that he also thinks that IR radiation (O-H stretch frequency I think?) is required for this structure to develop. And he thinks the arrangement is one in which oxygen and hydrogen are present in a ratio of 2:3, giving the structure a -ve charge - as indeed one would expect from a ratio like that, which is effectively H2O.OH- . So that's where the "H3O2" claim I found earlier comes from.

He thinks the viscosity of this semi-ordered layer is a lot higher than that of free water (I can imagine it might be) and that, because there are hydrophilic proteins within cells, these features (viscosity, exclusion of solute) can provide an alternative account of the behaviour of certain aspects of living cells.

It is not clear what observational evidence he has, or whether anybody has tried to replicate his findings.

Needless to say, this has nothing to do with "memory". However you will not be surprised to hear that garbled versions of this have been pounced on by various snake oil salesmen (e.g. some fellow called Mercola, who I think has actually done time for misrepresentation), sundry homeopaths, cranks and pedlars of water-based health gimmicks. I feel rather sorry for Pollack: this is attention he could well do without, if he is trying to get a serious hearing for his ideas.

But I find the bit about IR irradiation, in particular, rather hard to believe. Generally, adding vibrational energy (i.e. heat) tends to disrupt long range structure, as I'm sure most people with some knowledge of the kinetic theory of matter will appreciate. It also seems to me that a layer with the ratio he talks of could only be a couple of molecules thick or the -ve charge would be so great that it would be destabilised by mutual repulsions. H-bonds are not very strong. But I still can't find any independent write up of his research, so I can't resolve my scepticism at this point.

He clearly is someone who resorts to playing the victim card: there is a whole section on his website about the iniquitous conservatism of conventional "mainstream" [ugh!] science and the snuffing out of radical ideas. He doesn't quite say "they laughed at Galileo" but one gets the impression he has kicked up a stink about this at the university and the authorities have given him his head for the sake of an easier life - and good credentials for academic freedom I suppose. He also has a disturbing penchant for, yes you've guessed, videos, in place of papers. All this makes me suspicious that he may be a bit like Linus Pauling, who became notoriously eccentric towards the end of his life and espoused crank ideas about vitamin C. (Erwin Schroedinger and Fred Hoyle also became similarly eccentric in later life, and of course Tesla lost his marbles entirely, so it is not without precedent.)

So there we have it. He may just possibly be onto something, but we may have to wait for a decade or so before science is able to pronounce on fairly definitively. Meanwhile I am not holding my breath, for the reasons I have indicated."

So far as I can tell, this idea has gone nowhere. (The fact the Pollack has resorted to YouTube videos, rather than submitting research papers for peer review, suggests he may be awa' wi' the fairies. He must be older than God's dog by now. :D)
 
Last edited:
Also, beware the "hexagonal water scam", which leaches off Pollack's notion, though not necessarily with his connivance: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hexagonal_water
That sounds like "Penta water" a scam from about 15 years ago:

""A number of world-renowned scientists are studying Penta water and its positive effects. Among the studies completed are several indicating that Penta can help improve athletic performance, reduce acid load inside cells, increase the time cells live in adverse circumstances, and even reduce chromosomal mutation rates! Penta can do all these things because it’s truly different. The individual water molecules in Penta are arranged into small, stable clusters that more effectively get into your cells. That’s how Penta water is able to hydrate your cells more effectively and help you feel great!"
 
That sounds like "Penta water" a scam from about 15 years ago:

""A number of world-renowned scientists are studying Penta water and its positive effects. Among the studies completed are several indicating that Penta can help improve athletic performance, reduce acid load inside cells, increase the time cells live in adverse circumstances, and even reduce chromosomal mutation rates! Penta can do all these things because it’s truly different. The individual water molecules in Penta are arranged into small, stable clusters that more effectively get into your cells. That’s how Penta water is able to hydrate your cells more effectively and help you feel great!"
It does, rather. These scams are the scammers' dream, after all. You get water out of a tap, do some hocus-pocus with it and flog it to mugs at some exorbitant price.

But I suppose we should not turn this into a recital of water scams. This Pollack guy seems to be just a harmless eccentric, though he is not a chemist and some of what he says sounds like nonsense.

And, on the plus side, Write4U has not mentioned functions, potentials, microtubules, Tegmark or hive minds even once, so far! :biggrin:
 
Is any of the science true? There were some interesting claims such as an "exclusion zone" which is a gel like state of water between liquid and solid state, which alledgedly has some very interesting properties.
What Creates or Builds EZ Water?
One of the greatest surprises is that the key ingredient to create EZ water is light, i.e. electromagnetic energy, whether in the form of visible light, ultraviolet (UV) wavelengths and infrared wavelengths, which we’re surrounded by all the time. Infrared is the most powerful, particularly at wavelengths of approximately three micrometers, which is all around you. The EZ water can build on any hydrophilic or water-loving surface when infrared energy is available.
It builds by adding layer upon layer of EZ water, and can build millions of molecular layers. This is how it occurs in nature. For example, ice doesn’t form directly from ordinary H2O. It goes from regular water to EZ water to ice. And when you melt it, it goes from ice to EZ water to regular water. So EZ water is an intermediate state.

“Glacial melt is a perfect way to get EZ water. And a lot of people have known that this water is really good for your health,” Dr. Pollack says.
https://articles.mercola.com/sites/articles/archive/2013/08/18/exclusion-zone-water.aspx

These surface layers of EZ water (surface tension) is a 4th intermediate state of water allowing things which are heavier than water to float and allows a few animals to "walk on water". Theses "firm" water layers have an atomic structure which resembles the same atomic structure as graphene????

th


The video shows experiments which claim proof of this intermediate state of water???
 
Last edited:
Theses "firm" water layers have an atomic structure which resembles the same atomic structure as graphene?
Nope. Surface tension is a well understood phenomena that attempts to minimize surface area of a volume of liquid in order to minimize energy. It is not "like graphene" which is a 2D molecular structure.
 
Nope. Surface tension is a well understood phenomena that attempts to minimize surface area of a volume of liquid in order to minimize energy. It is not "like graphene" which is a 2D molecular structure.
Thanks for responding.

At first glance the 2D structure (not the components) looks somewhat like graphene, except the H atom in middle of the bond. That's the part which intrigued me. But the accompanying bottled water advertisements kinda gave it away....:eek:

Exclusion Zone Water | H3O2
ez-layer-e1419394176967.jpg
Look impressive. That's why I wanted to make sure.
 
Last edited:
You have piqued my curiosity about surface tension. Never gave it much thought before.
Surface tension in water might be good at performing tricks, such as being able to float a paper clip on its surface, but surface tension performs many more duties that are vitally important to the environment and people. Find out all about surface tension and water here.
Some remarkable properties.
wss-property-surface-tension-water-strider.jpg
Water striders use this surface tension to their advantage through their highly adapted legs and distributed weight. The legs of a water strider are long and slender, allowing the weight of the water strider body to be distributed over a large surface area. The legs are strong, but have flexibility that allows the water striders to keep their weight evenly distributed and flow with the water movement. Hydrofuge hairs line the body surface of the water strider.

Surface Energy and Nanoscale Mechanics
Kosar Mozaffari, Shengyou Yang, and Pradeep Sharma

Abstract
The mechanical response of nanostructures, or materials with characteristic features at the nanoscale, differs from their coarser counterparts. An important physical reason for this size-dependent phenomenology is that surface or inter-face properties are different than those of the bulk material and acquire significantprominence due to an increased surface-to-volume ratio at the nanoscale.
In this chapter, we provide an introductory tutorial on the continuum approach to incorporate the effect of surface energy, stress, and elasticity and address
the size-dependent elastic response at the nanoscale. We present some simple illustrative examples that underscore both the physics underpinning the capillary phenomenon in solids as well as a guide to the use of the continuum theory of surface energy.
The-ramifications-of-surface-energy-in-the-form-of-surface-tension-are-well-known-from.png

The ramifications of surface energy-in the form of surface tension-are well-known from our daily lives and are illustrated in this schematic. Surface tension forces, for instance, assist in overcoming gravity and enable the floatation of a ball. The ability of a water spider to walk on the water surface is another example. Also shown is a schematic of a capillary tube, frequently used by biologists and chemists, to highlight how surface tension causes water to be drawn up the tube
Context 1
... The surface energy concept for solids encompasses the fact that surfaces appear to possess a residual "surface tension"-like effect known as surface stress and also an elastic response, termed "surface or superficial elasticity." In the context of fluids, "capillarity" has long been studied, and the concept of surface tension is well-known (see Fig. 1). The situation for solid surfaces is somewhat more subtle than fluids in many ways since deformation is a rather important contributor to surface energy -which is not the case for simple liquids. For a simple liquid, surface energy, the so-called surface stress and surface tension are the same concept.
https://www.researchgate.net/figure...ce-tension-are-well-known-from_fig1_331025219
 
Back
Top