Star Wars vs Star Trek

Which universe would win?

  • Star Trek

    Votes: 227 35.5%

  • Star Wars

    Votes: 268 41.9%

  • Spaceballs

    Votes: 47 7.3%

  • Farscape

    Votes: 12 1.9%

  • Dune

    Votes: 50 7.8%

  • Stargate

    Votes: 36 5.6%
  • Total voters
    640
Status
Not open for further replies.
Lord Vasago said:
sorry but if you claim stuff for trek that they can rebuild th same goes for SW.
there are a lot of things in startrek that are done by someone in a specifik situation yet you claim once they did it they can do it again. bu when it comes to SW it's like "oh sorry it's destroyed in the movie so you can't use it again."

Keep it real kitt. ones it's used it can be use again period. but that would be to hard on trek wouldn't it.
Click to expand...

Name one instance I have done that!

Dyson sphere? Was never destroyed.
Borg cubes? They're mass-produced by the borg.
Escaping a black hole - it's been done by a SMALL ship, stands to reason a more powerful one could to.
Supernova'ing a sun? A missile did it... why couldn't a starship?

Give me one thing in star trek I've used that could NOT be done again for some practical reason.
 
Lord Vasago said:
euh the speed that the isd are closing in on the millenium falcon looked on screen as fast as the enterprise so why are they then slower. i don't recall anyone in the movies saying howfast a ship can go in subspace. for all we know they can do ,9 aswell.
Click to expand...

No, they can't. Simple reason for this:

1) A ship that big cannot POSSIBLY maneuver at that speed... it'd break it's own back.

2) Compare what we see on screen - we see how fast an ISD can accelerate by comparing it's length to camera focus and getting a rough estimate. Ent-D has STATED bluntly how fast it can go from full reverse to full fowards... thus we know it's speeds...
 
Lord Vasago said:
i mean't things like
* u can't use darth vader and yoda because they are dead yet data can be used though.

Uhm... Data is an ANDROID and his ENTIRE BRAIN was uploaded to B4... upgrade B4's positronic brain to match Data's and *poof* new data...

* u can't use a deathstar because they where destroyed. euh did anyone eveer mentioned that the emperor has the plans with him when ds2 is destroyed ??? i don't think so

It won't be built again... no funding for it.

when in gunfight a phasers leaves a spark and the foo dies. a blaster rifle leaves a spark and the ewok dies. so what's the differce????? Worf uses a bazooka type of weapon and you see some smoke when it hits the target. a AT-AT fires d you see a chunck of tree blown off so what's the difference????

We see Phasers detonate things... and there is a targetting computer IN the phaser which prevents you blasting a hole in your own starship.

see my point ? eveytime u see a blastershot it's clamed to be weak yet whenyou see phaser fight they are set at lowpower ??? yeah wright.

allso in this discution the empire can use his full force to fight because its universe vs universe. all vs all. so the empire would not need his forces to maintain order. they can use any one and any vessel in there universe
Click to expand...

in red
 
Uchiha Madara said:
It have shields to stop it from time-traveling in hyperspace, because they can't control how far.
Click to expand...

Doesn't matter - are the hyperdrives engaged 100% of the time? No. So as soon as the Relativity blows up the start of the SW universe, 99% of the ships will be gone. The rest can't do squat about it:)
 
Uchiha Madara said:
I read it. He did pretty well, and I will try the Centerpoint again, I am no quitter and I am not going to let such a good resource go to waste. I guess I am not a fast learner :)
Click to expand...

Centerpoint is gone, as are the people that created it... can't use it mate... unless you want us to be able to use the DoomsDay Device and encase all your planets in Dyson Spheres :D
 
Uchiha Madara said:
It is sad that the communications are knocked out, so that ISD probably have to abandon the search. Come on, they were in the asteroid field for days. I don't think they can afford to buy shields for millions of clone troopers when they have to buy ships and ammo, the Clone Wars is very economical. I am just making a guess that if droidieaks can use it, they can put it on a commando.
Click to expand...

Dude... you have the logic process of a 5 year old...

In the picture
From the movie
Bridge is there
Asteroid hits it
Bridge go bye bye

PRETTY SIMPLE
 
Uchiha Madara said:
They can build one can't they? After all they are hiding the stations in hyperspace, so UFP can't touch it.
Click to expand...

How long do you think it'll REALLY take before the races in Star Trek learn to fire INTO hyperspace lanes? I give em... a week... then HyperSpace is just a fast form of travel, nothing more.
 
Uchiha Madara said:
They can build one can't they? After all they are hiding the stations in hyperspace, so UFP can't touch it.
Click to expand...

Uchiha Madara said:
They have been in there for days and days. What makes you think that asteroid just got a lucky shot while the other asteroids didn't?

Alright here is a picture.

Droidek_anakin.JPG
Click to expand...

What in the name of FUCKING HELL does that picture have to do with an ISD bridge tower being cleaved off by an asteroid?

THAT BRIDGE IS GONE! IT WAS CLEAVED OFF JUST AS EASILY AS MY VORPAL GREATSWORD CLEAVES A HEAD OFF A KOBOLD IN D&D ON A CRITICAL HIT!

No question

IT IS GONE.
 
It appears that the thread is continuing for one reason only and my post was together advoided for only one reason only.

That is the continuation of a pointless thread without rules or speculations.
 
tnerb said:
My point exactly.

Rules have not been discussed.

If rules are discussed, Star Wars/Star Treck would either win or lose. All of Star Wars collide iwth all of Star Treck right? Well, what era? In the later era, you're actually very wrong. Luke Trains MILLIONS of Jedis. IDK if they are AS STRONG as they were in the past though (exageration on millions).

So, once again, it is an even hand UNTIL rules have been established. :bugeye:
Click to expand...

The rules are either:

All vs All as one union (all of current Trek vs all of Current wars)

OR

All vs All acting as they would (much more Difficult because we dont' know who in SW would band together to fight)

We are assuming the Q are not involved for the sake of giving SW a bone.

We are assuming CURRENT TRENDS, with SW Movies as highest cannon - if anything in them contradicts books/magazines/plays/radiobroadcasts/whatever movie wins.

Going by that logic, continue, please.

And please, do note - Jedi really would not help SW all that much...
 
Kittamaru said:
Trek, in TOS, was to promote the EQUALITY of Blacks and Women. No shit eitehr.
Click to expand...
yeah and in starwars you have female senators aswell and on both sides rebel and empire they have a lot of important jobs that are filled by other species. Lando is black and controls the mines. General ackbar is like a huge goldfish ffs.

in trek they allways favor the ships crew before anyone else. but offcourse they allways win so there's no fuss about it.

subspace weapons yeah that seems very moral. use a weapon you can't predict.

in war deserters allways get the bullit even in the usa. so whats different in SW as there is today??????
 
btw the ball on the lowerside of the droidika where i presome the powercells are in not very much larger than a basketball
 
Kittamaru said:
Name one instance I have done that!

Dyson sphere? Was never destroyed.
Borg cubes? They're mass-produced by the borg.
Escaping a black hole - it's been done by a SMALL ship, stands to reason a more powerful one could to.
Supernova'ing a sun? A missile did it... why couldn't a starship?

Give me one thing in star trek I've used that could NOT be done again for some practical reason.
Click to expand...
genesis project
doomsday device
 
Last edited:
Kittamaru said:
No, they can't. Simple reason for this:

1) A ship that big cannot POSSIBLY maneuver at that speed... it'd break it's own back. oh yeah but a cube can ??????? it's even bigger oh yeah but i forgot its in STARTREK so it must be superior

2) Compare what we see on screen - we see how fast an ISD can accelerate by comparing it's length to camera focus and getting a rough estimate. Ent-D has STATED bluntly how fast it can go from full reverse to full fowards... thus we know it's speeds...i agree. in ST they allways talk about how powerfull this or how amazing that is. that's an advantage because the onlytime we know someone stated power in sw is han solo on the deathstar.
Click to expand...

in red
 
Kittamaru said:
What in the name of FUCKING HELL does that picture have to do with an ISD bridge tower being cleaved off by an asteroid?

THAT BRIDGE IS GONE! IT WAS CLEAVED OFF JUST AS EASILY AS MY VORPAL GREATSWORD CLEAVES A HEAD OFF A KOBOLD IN D&D ON A CRITICAL HIT!

No question

IT IS GONE.
Click to expand...
and what was the speed of that asteroid and the composition?????

btw ST doesn't handle coalision that good either. looking at picard ramming the scimitar. yet we see a SSD collide with the deathstar and the damage is minimal.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top