When Queens Collide

Discussion in 'History' started by goofyfish, Feb 1, 2004.

  1. goofyfish Analog By Birth, Digital By Design Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    5,331
    I’ve read bios of both Elizabeth and Mary and have heard both sides of the story - what do you history types think? Did Elizabeth have any choice in chunkin’ Mary’s head off? Mary seems to have made one dumb (or desperate?) move (and marriage) after another and seems to have been asking for it.

    It seems to me that most of Mary’s actions suggest that she was an opportunist who had an unfortunate tendency to get emotionally and physically involved with some very bad choices, but who otherwise rarely let her eye slip from the Main Chance. While it seems likely that her personal preference was with Catholicism (especially since her childhood was spent that way), I find the idea of her as a martyr to her religion laughable; as I understand it, she married James Hepburn by Protestant rites, she readily agreed to allow her son to be raised Protestant, and the greatest likelihood is that she had her second husband, Darcy, assassinated!

    She not only exhausted Elizabeth's forgiveness, but constantly bitched that Elizabeth wasn't doing anything to put her back on the Scottish throne, despite having abdicated in favor of her son, and leaving Scotland (which she'd pretty much always detested) quite voluntarily. Of course, she'd so alienated her own aristocracy by then that they were pressuring her pretty hard.

    So, she had one husband killed, married her (probable) co-conspirator by Protestant rites, gets thrown out/abdicates and leaves Scotland, Hepburn tried to take it back and fails, dying miserably in Denmark, I think, and then wandered around England demanding asylum. Despite this, she continued from early adulthood to refer to herself in both title and arms as Queen of England, yet had the nerve to demand succor from the woman she labeled an illegitimate usurper. This woman, not out of kindness, but because she has a very strong sense that Royalty must only be judged by its peers if at all, puts Mary up for what - 20 years or better - and finally executes her when the plotting becomes so thick that Elizabeth's own life is seriously threatened.

    Or was Lizzie just ax-happy? Opinions?

    :m: Peace.
     
  2. Google AdSense Guest Advertisement



    to hide all adverts.
  3. guthrie paradox generator Registered Senior Member

    Messages:
    4,089
    Thats Darnley. And as for whether she was complicit in his murder, I would have to check, but it seems unlikely. The rest of it is roughly correct, but it seems that modern research has pointed more to Elizabeths chancellor or someone, I cant remember exactly who, who was a raging protestant, and thus wanted Mary, as the catholic heir to the throne, dead. And finally he got his way. Remember, before that she'd been kept in great houses all over England, such as Sheffield Manor and Castle Bolton, with a retinue of servants, ladies in waiting and others. Some of the letters which were used to accuse her of plotting treason are now thought to be forgeries, i think, though I am out of touch with it all.
    But apart from that, the general character summation is about right I think.
    Mary didnt have much choice about marrying the Dauphin, but after that, she was left in the usual Stewart monarchs situation of too much power at too young an age. Her male ancestors generally turned out oK, after their minorities in which other people bossed them around.
    I havnt actually read Bios of either of them, this is all picked up from a multitude of sources over the past decade. But I am born and brought up in edinburgh, and reserve the right to take anyone to task about Scottish history.

    Please Register or Log in to view the hidden image!

     
  4. Google AdSense Guest Advertisement



    to hide all adverts.
  5. DeeCee Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    1,793
    When Queens Collide

    Is this a gay thread then?

    Please Register or Log in to view the hidden image!


    Dee Cee
     
  6. Google AdSense Guest Advertisement



    to hide all adverts.
  7. guthrie paradox generator Registered Senior Member

    Messages:
    4,089
    ohhh dear. Can you imagine queen elizabeth as the spurned wannabee lover of Queen Mary?
    Welcome back Dee Cee.
     
  8. Nightpoet Registered Senior Member

    Messages:
    285
    I think Elizabeth was more or less pressured into executing Mary.
     

Share This Page