Again, q-reeus has virtually nothing except intent as evidenced by the thread title, "Simple Geometric Proof that GR GW's are impossible"...and it remains that way at least and until the whole shebang is submitted for appropriate peer review....nothing other than a claim on a science forum where you and I and most others are amateur lay people in this discipline. I'm attacking no one nor am I stifling any discussion. The problem exists with you under some illusion that this is some sort of academic forum for the enlightment of the scientific world, and for you to push your already known agenda, as much as you deny it.. It ain't! It's a bloody science forum like many others that people like Professor Thorne, Professor Begalman, Professor Hamilton just to name three, have never ever heard of. Go discuss to your little heart's content. But whatever you discuss, as with your fabricated nonsense re cosmological redshift, changes nothing: That's fact. sorry ol friend.