I just want to be clear here: If I say "I hope our troops remove the Taliban through force," I'm violating site rules? I'm just trying to figure out what we should be allowed to say about a group of people who target teenage girls for murder. I'm also not convinced that he was advocating violence based on any of the criteria you cited above. It seemed to me that he was advocating violence against a group of people based on their actions. Is there no difference? Fascinating non-sequitur. What's your point?