Bad. What you are saying is that I should stay in this thread if I agree with you, otherwise I should stay off. One more try with you.... Your objection is inconsistencies in global view. I have referred you the maths, pl pin point where the error is. And pl note, beads on the Feynman stick would move even in Newtonian Gravity, point is they will move barring certain exceptionally symmetrical non perturbative scenario. So your claim that they will not move fails on the first step.