Er, no. I am saying that a non-dualist theory might have it that the activity / function of the brain gives rise to consciousness as an emergent property. No, just trying to explain to MR that there may be no need to posit the human mind being anything other than the property of a healthy functioning human brain. I quite agree, so I suggest you find someone with a contrary position so that the analogy is not wasted. Please Register or Log in to view the hidden image!