i was so anoyed that they cut Tom out of those movies and the battle for the shire GRRRR I would love to see the similion done, think that would be awsome
That would have ruined the pacing though....The Hobbit and LOTR don't convert into the standard format for films because they both have an ending and then the journey home. What pissed me off more in the films were 1) Elves at Helm's Deep, 2) The army of the dead fighting at Minas Tirith and just killing everything, 3) Gimli becoming "comic relief" 4) That stupid scene with Legolas taking out the big elephant thing whose name I can't remember single-handedly and 5) Overuse of Crap CGI in the third film.
the army of the dead DID kill everything in the book The elephant was called a HELIPHANT your right about Gimli And i SOOO want them to do the simerilian, i thought that book was BRILLANT
Ok i will conced (i dont have the book here so i cant prove it one way or the other anyway) I actually thought he did well in the movie