Discussion in 'Free Thoughts' started by TheFrogger, May 29, 2018.
Log in or Sign up to hide all adverts.
I guess I don't understand your statement 'when did facts matter in Star Trek.'
It isn't a fact in Star Trek.
And doesn't matter.
I didn't say anything about red shirts. I said the new guy.
I had it pointed out to me in 1966. A friend of mine had missed an episode so he asked me about it. He said, "Nobody got killed, did they?" I said, "As a matter of fact, somebody did." He was shocked and said, "Not one of the hero crew?" I said, "No, a new guy." He agreed that there was nothing unusual about that.
Captain Kirk survived the series. Spock survived the series. Scotty survived the series. Bones survived the series. Lieutenant Uhura survived the series. Mr. Sulu survived the series. Mr. Checkhov survived the series.
The new guy did not. The ones who got killed were, kinda by definition, the new guys. They never got a chance to get old.
I can't watch your video but I stand by what I said.
I'm still not sure what you're getting at.
There is a real-world widely-held belief that red shirts on the TV show Star Trek are cannon fodder.
That real-world myth turns out not to be true. This guy did the math.
OK, you don't care. Why are you responding? Lots of Trekkers do care - else it would not be a widely-held belief.
Can we drop this now?
Yeah, in fact, the guy who did the math disqualified the main characters, reasoning that they are effectively immortal.
But a significantly larger ratio of blue shirts and gold shirts died on away missions than red shirts.
Gold shirts: a whopping 40%
Blue shirts: 33%
Red shirts: a mere 27%.
This entire post is worthless rubbish. Please don't post crap like this again.
Shall we drop this after you've had your say? Why? Star Trek was just a TV show.
Hooww daaarrree you?! Star-Trek is God! Please Register or Log in to view the hidden image!
Please Register or Log in to view the hidden image!
I watched a few first time around. I went to the first movie expecting nothing. I was right. The Kelvin Timeline is promising, but I'll reserve judgment for now.
I feel like I should say 'who cares?', but that would be trollish. Please Register or Log in to view the hidden image!
I don't ask you to care.
Separate names with a comma.