Longitudinal waves in the Universe / Sounds of the Sun

So sound ,vibration(s) is carried into space by the Sun's plasma field ?

 

Log in or Sign up to hide all adverts.

No.

Plasma is not a field; it is matter. It stops at the top of the sun's atmosphere, as does any sound.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide all adverts.

So doppler light wave theory , which is the transverse wave of light , is the same as the longitudinal wave of sound ? How so ?

 

Log in or Sign up to hide all adverts.

No. I did not say that.


We actually use a similar technology right here on Earth in covert surveillance.

From a distant vantage point, we cannot hear the sounds of two people talking inside a closed office. What we can do though, is bounce a laser off the window. The laser is so sensitive, it can pick up the vibrations of the window, caused by the voice of the occupants. The shifts in the returned laser pulse can be processed, pulling out just the vibration in the human range.
We can then play those human-level vibrations back from a speaker.

So, we can read sound from a distant office building - without any sound travelling between it and us - by using laser light.

 

So ........the Sun is not solid , it has fluid motion

 

Definitely.

 

Of which had a medium to travel with

Okay but so what ? In relevance to the Sun

 

No. It traveled as light. Light is not a medium. Light can cross vacuum. Sound cannot.

Simply that it's essentially the same technology.

 

There is no actual " vacuum " in space . All space has something in it .

 

Not something that an act as a medium for sound.

Sound requires matter. Sound is the transmission of oscillations (compression, rarefaction of adjacent atoms).
Sound requires matter of sufficient density that the atoms can interact with their neighbors in sufficient quantity to preserve oscillations.

What few atoms there are in vacuum do not physically interact as a medium - they are way, way too rarefied to transmit oscillations between them.

 

Sound requires a medium

Explain more clearly , your idea , in your last statement .

How so ?

It is beyond atoms , it is sub-atomic , and into quantum .

 

So sound has a medium on which to travel , plasma , within the Sun

 

Yes.
Sound is the movement of the medium. No medium, no sound.

Well, it's not my idea. It's just physics.

There are, at best, about 5 particles per cubic centimetre in interplanetary vacuum. Thst puts each atom several millimetres apart from its neighbor.

Those particles are so far apart, they cannot physically interact except very occasionally and randomly - which means they cannot transmit a pulse.

Contrast with air, where there are about a thousand billion billion atoms per square centimetre. Those atoms are about a nanometre apart. Close enough to interact.
That's how dense atoms need to be packed to transmit sound.

 

Nothing about what we are discussing involves the subatomic realm.

 

Yes. Within the sun.

 

True

But the medium upon which sound waves manifest , could be sub-atomic .

What is the density of sub-atomic particles and longitudeinal waves in space ?

 

It isn't.

As stated, about 5 per cubic centimetre. That's atoms, electrons, neutrons and protons combined.

By 'waves' you mean EMR.
EMR is not a medium, and cannot transmit sound.

 

Yet the sound of the Sun is detected

 

By the Doppler shift of light.
By definition, that is not sound. Though it can detect sound in distant objects.

 

The hallmark of scientific study is to accept what the evidence is telling you, whether or not you like it.
Otherwise, its dogma.