Background Yesterday, I addressed Dr. Otto Rössler on the merits of his general position. (Emphasis added) He replied in part: As soon as he describes me as his "enemy," I am concerned that in his adversarial casting of our roles, he has abandoned the quest for scientific truth in favor of a rhetorical exercise in lawyering. I replied in part: This was not taken in the manner intended, and the following request was made: And I accepted the request. My reply in part: Obviously, here we have trained specialists in physics and math. I don't claim to exceed their expertise in many areas, but I think I know a failure to learn general relativity when I see it. Ground Rules and Appeal to Moderation So setting aside my 6 numbered requests for clarification on Rössler's blog for his later reply on his chosen forum, I prefer this site to format a peer review for its ability to typeset mathematics and attribute quotes. If this is inappropriate cross-site discussion or an inappropriate sub-forum, I apologize and request that you work with me to find a better solution. The primary paper is [Rössler2012] Otto E. Rossler "Einstein's equivalence principle has three further implications besides affecting time: T-L-M-Ch theorem (“Telemach”)" African Journal of Mathematics and Computer Science Research 5( 3), pp. 44-47, (9 February, 2012) http://www.academicjournals.org/AJMCSR/PDF/pdf2012/Feb/9 Feb/Rossler.pdf Also cited: [Rössler1997] OE Rossler, C. Giannetti, "Cession, twin of action (La cesión: hermana gemela de la acción)" In: Arte en la era electronica: Perspectivas de una nueva estética (ed. by C. Giannetti), (Barcelona: Associación de Cultura Temporánia L’Angelot, and Goethe-Institut Barcelona 1997), p.124. [Rössler2007] OE Rossler "Abraham- like return to constant c in general relativity: gothic-R theorem demonstrated in Schwarzschild metric." Paper allegedly accepted for publication in Chaos, Solitons and Fractals. [Rössler2009] OE Rossler "Abraham- like return to constant c in general relativity: gothic-R theorem demonstrated in Schwarzschild metric." revised draft at http://www.wissensnavigator.com/documents/Chaos.pdf [Rössler2010] OE Rossler, D Fröhlich "The weight of the Ur-Kilogram" http://www.achtphasen.net/index.php/plasmaether/2010/12/11/p1890 This effort may be doomed, but I appeal to posters to keep the comments civil and the arguments directed at the text, not the person.