# "Does light move", asked Quantum Quack

Discussion in 'Pseudoscience Archive' started by geistkiesel, Mar 28, 2009.

1. ### AlphaNumericFully ionizedRegistered Senior Member

Messages:
6,697
I know and that's your problem. You have 'gotta work with what I have at the moment', which is limited compared to someone like myself who has plenty of time and access to resources to do physics. So if you know you have a limited amount of time and resources to devote to learning physics why do you think you have such amazing insight into it? Why are you so determined to tell people who have spent decades doing the photon experiments I've mentioned that they're wrong?

If you know that due to a lack of time and knowledge you have a flawed grasp of mainstream physics why are you so damn sure that you're right and mainstream physics is wrong? It seems odd to me you can be so opinionated yet at the same time get arsey because you admit to having not got as much time to devote to physics?

Why make claims about the de Broglie wavelength, relativity and quantum mechanics when you haven't learnt much about them and you're unsure of the specifics of the equations involved?

Just because you don't have to be competant doesn't mean you have to be deliberately ignorant and jump to conclusions about areas of physics you know little or nothing about.

I don't have to know much about tax law but I wouldn't argue with a judge about it if I ended up in court. So why do you argue about things you don't have time to know about with people who do?

3. ### Guest254Valued Senior Member

Messages:
1,056
Did you read that in a book too?

5. ### Uno HooRegistered Senior Member

Messages:
383
Cheez. First book I picked up at pure random out of my collection of science books has book title and author name on 6 pages inside of covers.

7. ### Uno HooRegistered Senior Member

Messages:
383
Great Cooglymoogly! Book also has complete essential publishing information on spine.

Pet rattlesnake eat spine of your book too?

8. ### raggamaxBannedBanned

Messages:
175
And even then don't do a satisfactory job.
What I asked was a question.

Question not claims.

Bla Bla

Do you really think I'm obligated or something to you?

Last edited: Nov 23, 2009
9. ### raggamaxBannedBanned

Messages:
175
And my book is so torn that even complete chapters from first half are missing from it.

10. ### raggamaxBannedBanned

Messages:
175
Do you think I need to ?

11. ### raggamaxBannedBanned

Messages:
175
Listen here man what is there to not believe? Why should I give a damn about an anonymous author? The book is not a book anymore its almost torn pages. If I had a scanner I could show you this instant that what I have are pages torn from the book.

12. ### prometheusviva voce!Registered Senior Member

Messages:
2,045
Convenient that you don't then? Why don't you 'fess up to where all that stuff about the derivation of $E^2 = (pc)^2 + (mc^2)^2$ really came from?

13. ### raggamaxBannedBanned

Messages:
175
Its up to you to believe whatever you want. I don't give a damn.

14. ### Quantum QuackLife's a tease...Valued Senior Member

Messages:
18,140
Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year to all ....been fun!