No, I don't think he's a troll. He is somewhat polite and respectful. For some reason he does not realize that because his ideas are alternative hypothesis, and not mainstream theory, that all such thread postings and comments belong there. He might think that comments there might be less valuable than those given here, for some reason, but he is getting little agreement here and lots of flack. He is a newbee like myself but based upon my calculations he is making roughly 100 postings per week. With such a high profile moderation will take notice. I myself like some of his rant but won't talk to him further in this thread.