Argentina, Brazil recognize Palestine; Israel miffed

Discussion in 'World Events' started by Tiassa, Dec 7, 2010.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. GeoffP Caput gerat lupinum Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    21,322
    And the Middle East may more rapidly approach that goal lauded there but not here: cultural homogeneity. Probably, but not absolutely, with a little spicy genocide humus on the side.
     
  2. StrawDog disseminated primatemaia Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    3,373
    Israel cannot survive in the long term as an increasingly isolated apartheid state. Integration is the only way to secure the future of the state of Israel.

    A truth and reconciliation process leading to an inclusively determined constitution that equally protects the rights of every single citizen, regardless of race or religion, is the suggested way forward. :m:
     
  3. quadraphonics Bloodthirsty Barbarian Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    9,391
    More likely, what you get is a system of nation states with said nations defined in ethnic terms (along with the destruction/absorbtion of a few ethnicities not suitably situated to play such a game). This process has already been underway in many places for generations - it's a decent description of present-day Europe, for example.

    In many other places, ethnicity is not strong enough to pose any fundamental challenge to nationalism. The nation-state is a very strong political entity, once consolodated, and so it takes a lot more than a few touchy-feely affirmations of ethnic self-determination to shake a system of states with monopolies on the use of force, industrial militaries, etc.

    But this is a bit beside the point. Palestine is a nation, to begin with. What's on the table is simply the erection of yet another nation state. This would actually patch a hole in the existing system of nation-states, rather than challenge such.
     
    Last edited: Jan 4, 2011
  4. GeoffP Caput gerat lupinum Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    21,322
    That statement is contrary to reality, Straw. Translocation of large numbers of Palestinians would mean the destruction of Israel and the probable massacre of its people, or else (more likely) their eventual extirpation via the usual slow intolerance and religious hatred.

    In that regard, Israel could at its worst be said to be completely integrated with the nations of the Middle East, although in an atypical direction.
     
  5. StrawDog disseminated primatemaia Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    3,373
    This can be a gradual process. Oh boy, the massacre of its people? When is the WW2 card going to be pulled from circulation? Points to consider. Religious intolerance and hatred at the moment is one sided in favour of Jewish folk. So thats OK, but a more even two sided intolerance is to be discouraged? That is the entire point of a Truth & Reconciliation process - a gradual application and integration of a rebooted value system. Naysayer.
    And why is this such a bad idea? Given the geaographical location slap bang in the ME and all. :m:
     
  6. quadraphonics Bloodthirsty Barbarian Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    9,391
    No, you're thinking of "power."

    Such a project involves destroying entire nationalities (along with their nation-states). Maybe that's worth doing, but it's not the kind of thing that's going to happen peacefully, or without resistance from the nation-states it threatens (who have things like armies).
     
  7. pjdude1219 troaty mouth best song ever Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    14,878
    people like you always claim that the palestinians getting their rights would lead to the massive violence against the jewish conquerors only problem their is zero evidence to support such an idea. maybe instead of reflecting the zionist movements and Israel's action onto its victims you could judge them by what they would actually do.
     
  8. StrawDog disseminated primatemaia Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    3,373
    All it will take is one leader with courage and a sense of justice. And no, I am not yet holding my breath.

    I will say it again, without considering or pursuing this path, Israel cannot survive in the long term. Its time to address the cornerstone of the hatred, that is the only way forward.
     
  9. StrawDog disseminated primatemaia Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    3,373
    Which is the reality that allows religious intolerance and hatred to perpetuate.
    All it will take is one leader with courage and a sense of justice. And no, I am not yet holding my breath.

    I will say it again, without considering or pursuing this path, Israel cannot survive in the long term. Its time to address the cornerstone of the hatred, that is the only way forward.
     
  10. quadraphonics Bloodthirsty Barbarian Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    9,391
    LOL, that's not even close to sufficient. Such a leader would be disposed of quickly enough by entrenched, interested, powerful forces.

    Not that there is any possibility of any bi-national leader - courageous or otherwise - emerging in the first place. You're putting the cart before the horse on this one: you have to dissolve the national distinctions before they can share a leader.

    Nothing can survive in the long term. You'll have to narrow your interest to something more immediate if you want to be relevant.

    You're referring to power, here?
     
  11. GeoffP Caput gerat lupinum Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    21,322
    Ask Hamas, Syria and...well, everyone else around them.

    Not exactly: power in Israel is one-sided in favour of Jewish folk. Outside Israel in the Middle East, it's one-sided in favour of Muslim folk. It may be that there's enough integral hatred for what you're suggesting, but it would be asinine to suggest that it only occurs in Israel.

    I have no idea how your first sentence relates to the sentence following it. How is this process a "two sided intolerance"? Will it be applied only in Israel, or elsewhere in the region, that it might achieve an actual two sided nature. (Sorry: I'm inferring your description here a little, but I'm not clear how this is intended to work or be presented.)

    It's not a bad idea in theory. Yet, if it were to be applied only in Israel, it would simply result in another Islamist-dominated society with equal rights for all straight Muslim men and crumbs for the rest.

    Except the constant perpetuation of the maddest possible conspiracy theories, calls to arms and anti-Semitic libel produced by the conservative religous movement in every Arab country around Israel. And that 1400 years of slow suffocation, fanned into a burning spark of pure hatred in the last hundred years or so by Salafists and the like. Oh, and the public statements of the Arab countries around Israel during the last two Arab-Israeli wars. The Hamas charter. And so on. I'm sure I'm forgetting something or other.

    I think I just related that to you. Let me know if it was unclear.
     
  12. pjdude1219 troaty mouth best song ever Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    14,878
    your twisting history again using the most vile interpertations and where that fails falsehoods and anchronism



    you mean your Judgement based on your version of history rather than you know real history. Why I still bother with your steadfast refusal to quit using anchronism to justify your prejudioce against arabs and muslims
     
  13. GeoffP Caput gerat lupinum Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    21,322
    That is pure drivel. The history of the Jewish people in the Middle East is not really open to unsupported speculation; nor are the attitudes of conservative Islam towards Jews and non-Muslims much in question, and they are often quite reprehensible.

    I have no prejudice against Arabs or Muslims, and my views, very simply, are no anachronism. Period.

    Since you cannot or will not acknowledge this, I think we have little to discuss. I recommend refreshing yourself with the history and present of the problem. Perhaps then we can continue.
     
  14. Brian Foley REFUSE - RESIST Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    3,624
    A realistic scenario is the certainty of demographics and the eventual economic demise of Israels benefactor America. Israel will resemble Lebanon with its 50/50 Christian Islamic mix, here it will be a 50/50 Jewish Arab mix. Gradually as the global shift of power moves to the E.U the Mid East loses geopolitical importance.
     
  15. Bells Frostbite! Staff Member

    Messages:
    18,353
    Recently, countzero recommended a book in this forum pertaining to Israel. The book is titled "The Israel Lobby and US foreign policy".

    I am 3/4 of the way through it at the moment and it deals quite a bit with what you are saying in this post.

    It is compelling reading and packed full of references for further reading and research, much of it by Israeli scholars about how the US and the world deals with Israel. I would strongly suggest you read it Geoff.:)
     
  16. GeoffP Caput gerat lupinum Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    21,322
    I will attempt to do so, given the chance.
     
  17. GeoffP Caput gerat lupinum Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    21,322
    I will attempt to do so, given the chance.
     
  18. StrawDog disseminated primatemaia Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    3,373
    Think FW De Klerk & Gorbachev.
    Not anyone that can presently be identified.
    Israel is a total infant in the grand scheme of nations. Long term in this case is a 100 years. they have only 40 to go. Compared to the longevity of other nations that have been around for centuries.
    I am referring to confronting and addressing theft, embracing restitution and the end of apartheid. :m:
     
  19. StrawDog disseminated primatemaia Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    3,373
    Right. So what then are the gripes of these entities? Theft? Rape? Destruction? So thus ... address the root cause of said gripes and you may yet have friendship no?
    Generally, outside Israel, Christian or other minorities in Muslim nations are not via state sanction, systematically ghettoized, starved and separated from the general population. The IDF guarantees that Jews and Jewish Settlers can hate, be intolerant and get away with acts of violence against Palestinians. The Palestinians do not have that luxury.
    If all the inhabitants of the land you see on the map as "Israel", were afforded the same human rights and recourse to the law and protection of the law, how do you think intolerance would play out?
    Goodness friend GeoffP ... Islamophobe much?

    And I utterly disagree with you. With the mix of skills and a constitutionally enshrined secular state, one could have an economic powerhouse.
     
  20. fedr808 1100101 Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    6,706
    You do realize that chances are the economic downturn is far from a demise. Of course not you bigot.

    You do realize that Israel could easily sustain itself. Especially with those new natural gas wells for a loooong time. Of course not you bigot.

    You do realize that the EU is starting to have to support bankrupted countries and issue massive bailouts for countries that are in incredible economic collapse. Of course not you bigot.

    The fact that the Arabic population is skyrocketing is only because they realize that the Israelis have improved the life of Arabs in Israel dramatically in sixty years from the desert it was before, and that they consider the price of some amount of prejudice for what it arguably the most modernized country in the middle east to be well worth it.
     
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.

Share This Page