Dear Guest: I'm not about to start fighting multiple fronts, but the answer to your question is that I said of every frame today. Following a path to the singularity is not encapsulated by that definition. Plus, screw kittens. No, I'm not "simply" contradicting anything, I'm boldly contradicting it using GR's own account of things, as you say. How can the following all be true: 1) An event horizon is formed by circumstances residing in its causal past 2) Those circumstances include a singularity in GR 3) The singularity resides in the causal future for all frames outside of it ?