sciforums SciForums.com : Science : Linguistics
sign language
Encyclopedia Register FAQ Members List Social Groups Ban List Calendar Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read
Reply
 
Thread Tools Rate Thread
Orleander's Avatar Orleander
Don't make me use UPPERCASE!! (21,864 posts)
Old 07-05-07, 01:35 PM
 #1
Reply With Quote   Orleander is offline
Is sign language pretty standard the world over? If it is, why aren't we all taught it?
Billy T
is at DarkVisitor.com (10,511 posts)
Old 07-05-07, 02:20 PM
 #2
Reply With Quote   Billy T is offline
“
Originally Posted by Orleander
Is sign language pretty standard the world over? If it is, why aren't we all taught it?
”
No, unfortunately it is not. BTW it is a language in the sense that it is governed by the same innate rules (N. Chompsky´s idea) that spoken languages are. learn it more easily when young etc.
Fraggle Rocker
Moderator (11,823 posts)
Old 07-05-07, 04:28 PM
 #3
Reply With Quote   Fraggle Rocker is offline
“
Originally Posted by Orleander
Is sign language pretty standard the world over? If it is, why aren't we all taught it?
”
“
Originally Posted by Billy T
No, unfortunately it is not. BTW it is a language in the sense that it is governed by the same innate rules (N. Chompsky΄s idea) that spoken languages are.
”
Nonetheless, each sign language is based upon the spoken language of its people. E.g., in English and Russian adjectives precede their nouns, in Spanish and Greek they follow them.

Considering that they've taught ASL to two other species of apes, it is rather surprising that more humans don't learn it. I can't believe there aren't times when it would be handy. Scuba diving, sitting on a turboprop commuter airliner, flirting with the chicas in the car in the next lane, band members trying to tell the roadies what they need, etc.
Orleander's Avatar Orleander
Don't make me use UPPERCASE!! (21,864 posts)
Old 07-05-07, 04:33 PM
 #4
Reply With Quote   Orleander is offline
“
Originally Posted by Fraggle Rocker
Nonetheless, each sign language is based upon the spoken language of its people. E.g., in English and Russian adjectives precede their nouns, in Spanish and Greek they follow them...
”
Oh, I didn't know that. I thought ASL was a language of its own, not based on another language's rules.

“
Originally Posted by Fraggle Rocker
...Considering that they've taught ASL to two other species of apes, it is rather surprising that more humans don't learn it. I can't believe there aren't times when it would be handy. Scuba diving, sitting on a turboprop commuter airliner, flirting with the chicas in the car in the next lane, band members trying to tell the roadies what they need, etc.
”
I see Moms at the park talking to their babys and toddlers in sign language more and more often.
http://www.signingbaby.com/main/
shorty_37's Avatar shorty_37
The Baroness (11,832 posts)
Old 07-05-07, 04:37 PM
 #5
Reply With Quote   shorty_37 is offline
The sign language I know I think everyone can understand
it means different things depending on what fingers you use!
Fraggle Rocker
Moderator (11,823 posts)
Old 07-05-07, 08:13 PM
 #6
Reply With Quote   Fraggle Rocker is offline
“
Originally Posted by Orleander
Oh, I didn't know that. I thought ASL was a language of its own, not based on another language's rules.
”
Actually, I think I'm wrong about that although it's not easy to figure out. According to Wikipedia American Sign Language was adapted from French Sign Language, and about 60% of the symbols are mutually comprehensible. (British Sign Language, on the other hand, was developed independently and is totally unintelligible to Americans.) I gather that French Sign Language was based on a sign language that was already in use within the deaf community in France. Since literacy was far from universal in earlier times, I can't figure out whether this sign language was based at all on the written language around them--and therefore is recognizably "French"--or if it was totally a priori.

So I retract my facile comment that sign languages emulate the spoken languages of their nation. I have no idea. I'll read more Wiki.
bsemak's Avatar bsemak
Just this guy, you know (240 posts)
Old 07-06-07, 03:02 AM
 #7
Reply With Quote   bsemak is offline
Sign Language is quite local. There are systems were you use your hand and mouth to make letters, which can be used in a broader context. More ordinary sign language, were signs are representative for words or concepts are more confined to different countries. Also you can have local dialects, meaning that you developed a local sign for some word. This would be incomprehensible for any out siders.
Zephyr
Humans are ONE (3,350 posts)
Old 07-06-07, 04:14 AM
 #8
Reply With Quote   Zephyr is offline
But apparently it's easier to learn another sign language than another spoken one. Perhaps ideas translate more naturally (and thus, consistently) into visual paths than into sequences of phonemes.
bsemak's Avatar bsemak
Just this guy, you know (240 posts)
Old 07-06-07, 05:27 AM
 #9
Reply With Quote   bsemak is offline
I guess so. My Girlfriend is a social education worker, and uses sign language every day at work. Its like written chinese. The piktograms can be read by anyone, because they are concepts more than written language. So even though they cant understand each others dialects, they can read the same paper anywhere. Anyone familiar with chinese can correct me of course, if I am wrong here :-)
sandy's Avatar sandy
Tired of getting throw out (6,665 posts)
Old 07-06-07, 06:59 AM
 #10
Reply With Quote   sandy is offline
Many of my friends taught their babies sign language. They were communicating effectively way before their 9-month birthday. It's pretty awesome to watch.
Orleander's Avatar Orleander
Don't make me use UPPERCASE!! (21,864 posts)
Old 07-06-07, 08:00 AM
 #11
Reply With Quote   Orleander is offline
“
Originally Posted by sandy
Many of my friends taught their babies sign language. They were communicating effectively way before their 9-month birthday. It's pretty awesome to watch.
”
My college roommate did it with her daughter. It was amazing to me that the child had such a vocabulary and yet couldn't speak.
sandy's Avatar sandy
Tired of getting throw out (6,665 posts)
Old 07-06-07, 08:24 AM
 #12
Reply With Quote   sandy is offline
It's amazing to watch a baby do it. I was blown away. I think babies do try to communicate with us but they get frustrated and cry. The whole sign language with babies thing is fascinating.
mikenostic's Avatar mikenostic
Stop pretending you're smart! (4,624 posts)
Old 07-06-07, 09:19 AM
 #13
Reply With Quote   mikenostic is offline
There are also somewhat universal (at least in the dog training world) signs for commands you give dogs. Dogs are also excellent at non vebal commands; 90% of their communication IS non verbal anyway. All the verbal commands that my dogs know, they also know the hand gestures for the commands as well.
Like if I point to the floor, they assume the down position. If I hold my hand out in front of them palm up, they know that's the 'shake' or 'gimme your paw' command. Same for holding my hand up for a high five.
Reply

Bookmarks

Thread Tools
Rate This Thread
Rate This Thread:

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 12:00 AM.