sciforums SciForums.com : Science : Linguistics
Grammar help; contractions
Encyclopedia Register FAQ Members List Social Groups Ban List Calendar Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read
Reply
 
Thread Tools Rate Thread
Hip Hop Skeptic's Avatar Hip Hop Skeptic
Registered User (74 posts)
Old 07-02-07, 03:23 PM
 #1
Reply With Quote   Hip Hop Skeptic is offline
Can someone please help me with these grammar issues I am having??

First issue is, what's the deal with cannot?

Why don't "donnot" "willnot" etc exist? Why just cannot?

also is it still proper to space them apart like: "I can not go"???

My next issue is does can't, don't etc. really equal do not and cannot??

Like, are they completely interchangeable?

When my teacher asks me "Didn't you do your homework?"

Does that mean "Did not you do your homework?"? Sounds weird.

Doest that make sense??

Another example:

"Why can't I play" = "Why can not I play?"??

I know it probably makes me sound dumb but can anyone help explain?
spidergoat's Avatar spidergoat
It's all about the hexagons (29,190 posts)
Old 07-02-07, 03:27 PM
 #2
Reply With Quote   spidergoat is offline
Why don't "donnot" "willnot" etc exist? Why just cannot?
Tradition, custom.
also is it still proper to space them apart like: "I can not go"???
No. See above.
My next issue is does can't, don't etc. really equal do not and cannot??
The meaning is the same, but the usage is different. See above.
mikenostic's Avatar mikenostic
Stop pretending you're smart! (4,624 posts)
Old 07-02-07, 03:36 PM
 #3
Reply With Quote   mikenostic is offline
Why can't I go?
-Why can I not go?

Didn't you do your homework?
-Did you not do your homework?

'Cannot' is one word. Can and not are not supposed to be separated.

I know it probably makes me sound dumb
Nah. English is a bitch of a language to learn (if it's not your native language) from what I hear.
Oli's Avatar Oli
Heute der Enteteich... (11,890 posts)
Old 07-02-07, 03:37 PM
 #4
Reply With Quote   Oli is offline
Originally Posted by Hip Hop Skeptic
Why don't "donnot" "willnot" etc exist? Why just cannot?
"do not" and "will not" exist.

also is it still proper to space them apart like: "I can not go"???
Yes - can & not are normally two separate words.

My next issue is does can't, don't etc. really equal do not and cannot??
don't = do not, won't = will not (very old)

Does that mean "Did not you do your homework?"? Sounds weird.
But correct English.

Oops - I read it as Did you not do your... Mea culpa.

Last edited by Oli; 07-02-07 at 06:21 PM.. Reason: Oops added.
Fraggle Rocker
Moderator (11,823 posts)
Old 07-02-07, 06:14 PM
 #5
Reply With Quote   Fraggle Rocker is online now
Originally Posted by Hip Hop Skeptic
First issue is, what's the deal with cannot? Why don't "donnot" "willnot" etc exist? Why just cannot?
"Cannot" as a single word is just one of the many idiosyncracies of our writing system. It's an exception. None of the other auxiliary verbs ("helping verbs") can be combined like that. As I've often said, I think the people who make these decisions do it just to confuse foreigners.
Also is it still proper to space them apart like: "I can not go"?
No, that is considered improper--in almost all cases. The exception would be when you're writing dialog and the speaker is speaking that way for emphasis. "Johnny, you can NOT wash a cat in the dishwasher. Don't even think about it!"
My next issue is does can't, don't etc. really equal do not and cannot?
Yes. The difference is not in their literal meaning. The contractions are considered somewhat colloquial and are frowned upon in all but the most informal writing, such as here. But to speak them as two words is considered somewhat formal, at least in America. Data the android on "Star Trek" was programmed to be unable to speak contractions, and his speech sounded very stilted.
Like, are they completely interchangeable?
Well, yes, in the sense that no one will ever misunderstand you. But if you use contractions in writing they'll think you're not well educated, and if you don't use them in speech they'll think you're a foreigner.
When my teacher asks me "Didn't you do your homework?" Does that mean "Did not you do your homework?"? Sounds weird.
That's because that's not how we say it. It's "Did you not do your homework?" You just have to learn that and make peace with it. It's not logical.
"Why can't I play" = "Why can not I play?"??
Contractions have their own grammatical rules. It is incorrect to say or write it that way. You have to say, "Why can I not play?" I'm sure you sense this instinctively when you speak in the first person singular, because there is no contraction for "am not." You have to say, "Am I not invited to your party?", not "Am not I invited..."
I know it probably makes me sound dumb but can anyone help explain?
You don't sound dumb. You just sound like someone who is learning English as a second language and you wonder about all the weird stuff that we take for granted.
Originally Posted by mikenostic
English is a bitch of a language to learn (if it's not your native language) from what I hear.
There's a thread on that topic right here in Linguistics. It kind of depends on what your native language is. I'd be surprised if most people don't find French even harder, so long as they don't speak one of the related Romance languages. It has most if not all of the same problems as English, only worse. Phonetics, grammar, idioms, writing system. In addition, the pronunciation of a word can change based on the word that follows it, making it difficult to understand speech.
Reply

Bookmarks

Thread Tools
Rate This Thread
Rate This Thread:

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 08:43 AM.