sciforums SciForums.com : Science : Human Science
Best Martial Art?
Encyclopedia Register FAQ Members List Social Groups Ban List Calendar Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read
Reply
 
Thread Tools Rate Thread
airavata
portentous (1,352 posts)
Old 04-30-03, 11:05 AM
 #1
Reply With Quote   airavata is offline
i have a question. which is ----

1. the toughest martial art,

2. and the most effective martial art.

please don't show any bias towards the one which you practise. answer objectively.
river-wind's Avatar river-wind
Registered Senior User (2,448 posts)
Old 04-30-03, 11:41 AM
 #2
Reply With Quote   river-wind is offline
me likes.

I'd divide my answer up into the following categories:
For a beginner who needs...
...to learn balance & improve strength
Tae Kwon Do
...health training (flexibility/strength)
yoga or Ti Chi or Qigung
...to learn self defense
American Kempo or Judo

for a person in fair shape who needs...
...to improve balance
TKD or Hap Ki Do & yoga or Ti Chi
...health training
yoga & qigung
...strength training
at this level, pretty much any popular Martial art will do
... to learn self defense
Jeet Kun Do, American Kempo, Judo, Akido (in that order)

for an advanced person who needs...
...to improve balance
yoga & Ti Chi, Bagua
...health training
yoga, Ti Chi, qigung
...strength training
Wu Shu or general Traditional Kung Fu, Bagua
...to learn self defense
Jeet Kun Do, Dim Mak, Kempo, Ninjitsu, weapon styles, gun training(I don't like guns, but it's still good to know how they work)

very advanced:
...general
Ti Chi, Bagua, Five animals Kung Fu, Kung Fu weapons, Kendo
...self defense
alot of the world military hand-to hand, above black belt level Kempo, traditional Karate-do, Aki-jitsu


in case you can't tell, I think the internal styles are important

anyone disagree w/ the above? have you tried a style which would fit better? The above is only stuff I've tried, I'm sure that there are other really good arts which I have no knowledge of. for example, I keep hearing about Brazillain martial arts as well as Hawaiian Martial arts, but I don't know much about them. Wing Chun either for that matter, nor Jiujistu or even Tae Bo I wouldn't know where to add them to the list above.


My personal favorites are: Dim Mak, Drunken Monkey Kung Fu, Ti Chi, and American Kempo
Weiser_Dub
Registered Senior User (308 posts)
Old 04-30-03, 12:24 PM
 #3
Reply With Quote   Weiser_Dub is offline
The Best is Brazilian Ju-Jitsu. Tough, perhaps. Effective, yes. And oh what fun. cOme on people - start cheering... Brazilian Ju-Jitsu, Brazilian Ju-Jitsu, Brazilian Ju-Jitsu...
Nasor
Registered Senior User (5,233 posts)
Old 04-30-03, 04:07 PM
 #4
Reply With Quote   Nasor is offline
“
Originally posted by river-wind
... to learn self defense
Jeet Kun Do, American Kempo, Judo, Akido (in that order)
”
You think that judo is more effective than akido for self defense? I have to disagree. I've practiced both aikido and judo for years, and I enjoy both, but aikido is much more oriented toward self defense than judo. Judo is esentially a cross between a martial art and a sport; there's not a lot of 'realism' in it.
Dr Lou Natic's Avatar Dr Lou Natic
Unnecessary Surgeon (5,571 posts)
Old 04-30-03, 08:05 PM
 #5
Reply With Quote   Dr Lou Natic is offline
1. Muay Thai
2. Muay Thai

What do you mean by toughest and most effective? If you mean "make you toughest" and "kick peoples asses most effectively" then my answers remain.

I don't do any or prefer any over any others so I'm not bias.
Revolution
Registered Senior User (164 posts)
Old 04-30-03, 09:07 PM
 #6
Reply With Quote   Revolution is offline
2- Chink Chink

























By THe Smith and Wesson Dojo.
airavata
portentous (1,352 posts)
Old 05-01-03, 02:12 AM
 #7
Reply With Quote   airavata is offline
in muay thai you do get your ass kicked. i guess it toughens you up like hell. about flexibility and health, yoga is the best. i mean it's incredibly vast, and the asanas and pranayamas are not the only thing. the food you eat etc. is also important.

coming back to martial arts, i was under the impression that kung fu was the best. wasn't jeet kun do invented by bruce lee? about the brazilian martial arts, i know wesley snipes is really good in this brazilian martial art called Capoeira.
jps
Registered Senior User (1,877 posts)
Old 05-01-03, 05:09 PM
 #8
Reply With Quote   jps is offline
I don't know anything about martial arts but capoeria looks really cool
Zero's Avatar Zero
Banned (2,357 posts)
Old 05-01-03, 05:35 PM
 #9
Reply With Quote   Zero is offline
Yoga is not a martial art. It is a spiritual practice. It is not "martial" at all!

All martial arts, as long as they have a long history (and therefore credible), are all good.
Revolution
Registered Senior User (164 posts)
Old 05-01-03, 11:04 PM
 #10
Reply With Quote   Revolution is offline
Being serious I have practiced 3 styles. Taekwando(man i cant spell sorry), ShodoKan, and basic street fighting taught by a pair of brothers I used to know who were 4th degree black belts, but I forget their style, some Philipeans stuff. Anyways they skipped the tradition and stuff and just taught what you needed to know to defend yourself if attacked. But they always upheld the Dont Attack, unless defending yourself is innevidible.

So my answer is
1- I dont know I think any style that you work your hardest at would be the answer.
3-Basic street fighting style that they taught, Self Defense to the extreme.

I am not saying I am right, this is just my opinion but those brothers were bad ass mofo's! I asked em once to play golf. They used their legs as the clubs
Blindman
Registered Senior User (898 posts)
Old 05-02-03, 08:53 AM
 #11
Reply With Quote   Blindman is offline
I learnt kendo as a young man. The use of tools is the most effective form of self-defense.
airavata
“
Best Martial Art?
1. the toughest martial art,
2. and the most effective martial art.
”
Try to match a sword.. Try to match a disarmed kendo pupil.

Kendo should be extended into modern times. Guns, pepper spray, extra.

Marital arts involves the one to one human battle. Anything else is war. Sun Tzu, Art of War is the next step.
freefighter187
Registered Senior User (34 posts)
Old 05-02-03, 02:34 PM
 #12
Reply With Quote   freefighter187 is offline
jeet kun do is every art so it has to be the best
Nasor
Registered Senior User (5,233 posts)
Old 05-02-03, 02:46 PM
 #13
Reply With Quote   Nasor is offline
“
Originally posted by Blindman
Kendo should be extended into modern times. Guns, pepper spray, extra.
”
But then it wouldn't be kendo, now would it?
Blindman
Registered Senior User (898 posts)
Old 05-03-03, 10:07 AM
 #14
Reply With Quote   Blindman is offline
Nasor.. well I guess it wouldn’t in classical terms.

But there is no reason that it can’t evolve.
sargentlard's Avatar sargentlard
Save the whales motherfucker (6,689 posts)
Old 05-04-03, 03:54 PM
 #15
Reply With Quote   sargentlard is offline
Capoeira seems amazing and well suited for learning balance but it doesn't seem practical for defending yourself in a attack. I forgot the name of the martial art Bruce Lee invented. It supposedly had no restrictions and it was made for street fighting because Bruce Lee realized that traditional arts just weren't going to cut in a world of dirty fighting.


Drunken Boxing seems amazing....throw yourself off balance to confuse enemies and then *POW* in the face and the enemy is left confused and bruised.
river-wind's Avatar river-wind
Registered Senior User (2,448 posts)
Old 05-13-03, 05:37 PM
 #16
Reply With Quote   river-wind is offline
“
Originally posted by Nasor
You think that judo is more effective than akido for self defense? I have to disagree. I've practiced both aikido and judo for years, and I enjoy both, but aikido is much more oriented toward self defense than judo. Judo is esentially a cross between a martial art and a sport; there's not a lot of 'realism' in it.
”

as always, I can be wrong. It sounds like you have more exp with these two than I do, so I could be wrong. My impression is that Akido is more technical. This can lead to very effective self-defense moves down the road, but between day 1 and being a master, you are largely defensless. don't do the move just right, and it doesn't work at all.

Judo, IME, covers more of the middle ground. so that you can leave class after day 1 with a tiny bit more ability to defend yourself.

Now if you want to be master kick ass, I'd avoid judo and akido, and go for aki-jitsui (akido w/ attacks)




after the mentions above, I think I'll have to do some more research on capoeria. oh, yeah, I forgot about muay thai completely, d'oh! A friend of mine keeps telling me that kendo is cool- how much of it is outside of the full body armor/shinai sparring? is there alot of hand-to-hand/exersize? I know nothing but what I've seen in pictures.
freefighter187
Registered Senior User (34 posts)
Old 05-16-03, 12:39 PM
 #17
Reply With Quote   freefighter187 is offline
jeet kun do "THE WAY OF NO WAY"
Learining this concept will put you on your way to kicking some ass.
Muay thai will make you tough though, a bad fighter and tough but whatever.
cyberia's Avatar cyberia
Lounge Act (170 posts)
Old 05-16-03, 06:44 PM
 #18
Reply With Quote   cyberia is offline
HAP KI DO!

Its the newest form of Martial arts and probably the most comprehensive because it was developed by the Korean military in the last 200 or so years from a conglomeration of every single type of martial arts.

I've taken three different kinds of Martial arts over my Life (Karate and Tae Kwon do) But I started Hap Ki do when I was 12 and I have to say it is definitley the hardest of the three styles I have tried.

Its think its the most effective because it covers using weapons, Disarming weapons (You have to be able to disarm a weapon before you can learn the weapon) (swords, daggers, throwing knives, Nunchaks (sp? o.O) )

The work outs a BLOODY hard as it was designed for military use specifically. To give an example, My master trained 50 American troops for three months to a High Red belt/low black belt level and 15 of them ended up dropping (from exhaustion) After the first week... Of course that was an extreme circumstance but they do NOT go any easier on us. Summer training camp followed the same program as the military and it was about the same intensity as an long/hard class.
JoojooSpaceape
Burn in hell Hippies (498 posts)
Old 05-16-03, 07:57 PM
 #19
Reply With Quote   JoojooSpaceape is offline
“
Originally posted by Weiser_Dub
The Best is Brazilian Ju-Jitsu. Tough, perhaps. Effective, yes. And oh what fun. cOme on people - start cheering... Brazilian Ju-Jitsu, Brazilian Ju-Jitsu, Brazilian Ju-Jitsu...
”

! this sounds to me like a biased quote hehe
blakeimus
Registered Senior User (30 posts)
Old 05-19-03, 06:22 PM
 #20
Reply With Quote   blakeimus is offline
Shaolin Kung Fu and Ninjitsu
Reply

Bookmarks

Thread Tools
Rate This Thread
Rate This Thread:

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:34 PM.