sciforums SciForums.com : Science : Astronomy, Exobiology, & Cosmology
The Allais Global Gravity Experiment
Encyclopedia Register FAQ Members List Social Groups Ban List Calendar Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read
Reply
 
Thread Tools Rate Thread
astrogame
Registered User (4 posts)
Old 08-28-99, 05:01 AM
 #1
Reply With Quote   astrogame is offline
A friend e-mailed this to me.

In conjunction with the Aug. 11th solar eclipse (uh, no pun intended), NASA
was to conduct an unusual gravity experiment: the Allais global gravity
experiment. As I understand the situation, back in the 1950's, Nobel
laureate Maurice Allais noted that a pendulum's motion would change slightly
during a total solar eclipse. Since then, a handfull of scientific
organizations have reported varying results. NASA was going to use a
sensitive gravitometer to check this out, and was planning on working with a
worldwide group to see what others would report. Anybody heard anything?
Jay? I think Allais' prize was for economics <grin>, but he was also
interested in both theoretical and applied physics.

...Bob...
Plato
Registered Senior User (368 posts)
Old 08-28-99, 11:45 AM
 #2
Reply With Quote   Plato is offline
well yes,

I am also anxiously awaiting more data but they said they had to wait for the next full moon, which was two days ago to confirm their results.
I guess we will get results very soon now.



------------------
we are midgets standing on the backs of giants,
Plato

Aloysius
Registered Senior User (102 posts)
Old 08-29-99, 07:57 PM
 #3
Reply With Quote   Aloysius is offline
Is Allais making a prediction based on General Relativity, or based on a homebrew thory?
Boris's Avatar Boris
Senior Member (1,052 posts)
Old 08-29-99, 11:01 PM
 #4
Reply With Quote   Boris is offline
Hey man, they are all homebrewed, that is until a prediction is actually verified to be true. Good question, though; I'd like an answer to that one.
Plato
Registered Senior User (368 posts)
Old 08-30-99, 11:15 AM
 #5
Reply With Quote   Plato is offline
Well, as far as I know he didn't give an explanation at all, only said that it was not confirm with existing theory.
Since he was the only one spotting the effect he was very carefull of course untill he got some confirmation of others.
You can read all about it on : http://science.nasa.gov/newhome/head...t06aug99_1.htm

I hope the results of these new experiments won't take that long any more to get published.

------------------
we are midgets standing on the backs of giants,
Plato

Boris's Avatar Boris
Senior Member (1,052 posts)
Old 08-31-99, 04:08 PM
 #6
Reply With Quote   Boris is offline
I've got a question for you quantum physics buffs.

I must confess I still haven't got my hands on that textbook Plato recommended a while back (though I'm going to eventually...) But, something strikes me as weird about the quantum interpretation of gravity fields (i.e. via gravitons).

It seems that gravitons must be able to pass right through matter. But on the other hand, they must be able to interact with matter, no matter how little of it there is. This is something I find hard to swallow. For example, when the Moon comes between the Sun and the Earth, would it not shield the Earth from some of the Sun's gravitons? But in this case, the linear Newtonian addition of gravity fields would no longer work! Could someone who knows what they are talking about help me out here? (Plato? Aloysius?)

------------------
I am; therefore I think.
Plato
Registered Senior User (368 posts)
Old 09-01-99, 06:32 AM
 #7
Reply With Quote   Plato is offline
Yes, I think I can shed some light on this shielding problem.
First of all this could also be applied to electromagnetism where three sources lie on the same line with regard to each other.
The solution is that the actual force-fotons or gravitons are not real particles but virtual. This means that they live not long enough to complete one wavelength of distance.
When two electrons interact they interchange fotons but these never realy come into existence, this is nescessary for them not to lose energy. Same thing goes for the earth, the sun and the moon. The virtual gravitons can't be stopped because they really aren't there. This might seem like some mathematical trick to you but it explains perfectly why all these forces are radial and have inverse square laws.
You see a same amount of virtual photons have to mediate the force at different distances from their source. You can look at it as several shells of a sphere, these shells have increasingly bigger surfaces as their radius increases and these surfaces are proportioned to the square of their radious of course. Each surface harbors the same amount of virtual photons thus the density on the surface decreases inversely proportionate to the square of the radius. Hence the laws of Newton and Coulomb.
The nuclear forces are a different matter since their force mediaters have mass themselves this makes them short distance forces which screws up the simplicity of the previous explanation.

------------------
"If I have been able to see further, it was only because I stood on the shoulders of giants."
Isaac Newton
Reply

Bookmarks

Thread Tools
Rate This Thread
Rate This Thread:

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Gravity is only a theory Roman Earth Science 32 09-03-08 03:44 AM
The Rise and Fall of Gravity Kaiduorkhon Free Thoughts 0 04-30-07 04:10 AM
Gravity Explained Farsight Physics & Math 13 03-12-07 06:23 PM
Global warming--caused by humans? francois Earth Science 32 11-21-06 12:48 AM

All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:29 AM.