Let's lead off by saying that I think these US government plans are doomed, dead on arrival, unworkable failures of conception. That is, I agree with madanthony's author's essential conclusions.
The only option that has a chance is socialized insurance, and everybody who has been paying attention knows this.
But:
“ |
Originally Posted by author What I can't figure out is why Congress would want to prohibit someone like me from keeping an affordable hospitalization plan. It works for me and it works for the hospital. I guess that's the problem. It's simple, it's easy to understand, and it works.
|
” |
Well, no, it doesn't work.
It doesn't cover the costs of medical care for serious illness, and it doesn't cover the costs of prevention. Joe there is counting on not getting sick. If he does get sick, the cost burden will first bankrupt him, and then fall on others. And any buildup of costs from his likely failures to keep up with prevention and early detection routines will contribute to the total cost of the system, regardless of who pays.
Plans like that are why 75% of the medical cost driven bankruptcies in the US involve people who had insurance, and why emergency rooms are going under in a swamp of crises that should have been routine doctor visits months earlier.
“ |
Originally Posted by author The result is that HMO plans in the state are now very expensive. The price of Empire's basic, least expensive HMO plan is more than $13,000 a year for an individual, more than $26,000 a year for a married couple, and more than $39,000 a year for a family with children. Empire is a reputable firm and those prices are typical of what's available to New York City residents
|
” |
So all that free market stuff doesn't keep the costs down? We are not shocked.
In France, in Paris, coverage much better than Empire's "basic" plan costs the citizens less than a third of those numbers.
But Joe there is worried about losing the horseshit plan he has (ask anyone who has landed in the hospital for sudden emergency what percentage of such costs Joe will probably be paying, according to that description. And that's the stuff Joe thinks he has covered!). That's how bad this system is - guys like Joe are worried about losing insurance like that.