Star Wars vs Star Trek

[Saquist]

The Excecutor got impacted by ships just comming out of hyperspace ( So you can't see them, because it is till faster then light speed ).

There was no impact.

[Cody]

There was no impact.

You are talking about this, right?

Anyway, sorry for my short absence. I have just recently bought Supreme Commander Gold Edition.

[Cody]

No cruisers crashed into Executor in Return of the Jedi. Nor is there any sign of concentrated Fleet Fire.

Even if there was. Executor is bigger than the Entire Alliance Fleet and should have a shield capacity to match. Not only are the other ISD's a factor but to say that the Executor's shield failed or even lost to heavy Fire of just THREE Mon Calimari Heavy Hitters is just handing the win to Star Trek.

(P.S Try and keep the comic books out of the discussion. It's more contradictory than even the EU and highly exaggerative.)

No proof of CFF? Watch the movie again: "All ships, target the Executor!" (Something like that.)

The fleet was bigger than that, and they had frigates pounding on it, as well as capital-grade proton torpedoes.

[Kittamaru]

Excuse me, Q ATTEMPTED to mate with Janeway, it didn't succeed. Acually only Centerpoint is a superweapon in my opinion, anything more powerful then the Centerpoint is a superweapon too.

Uh, epic fail.

Q didn't mate with Janeway because she convinced Q to mate with a female Q, resulting in their son, q. Duh... anyone with a brain that has watched the series knows that...

Centerpoint is a fail-weapon as the WASTE PRODUCTS of a Federation Starship are just as powerful!

[Kittamaru]

The Excecutor got impacted by ships just comming out of hyperspace ( So you can't see them, because it is till faster then light speed ).

They would make mention of that in the movies you insolent sub-humanoid!

[Kittamaru]

No proof of CFF? Watch the movie again: "All ships, target the Executor!" (Something like that.)

The fleet was bigger than that, and they had frigates pounding on it, as well as capital-grade proton torpedoes.

So the shields on the most EPIC single ship of the Imperial Starfleet succumbed in a few minutes to the firepower of a few cruisers and some frigates and destroyers?

PATHETIC!

Absolutely... pathetic...

That hands the win to Trek on a gold rimmed latinum platter!

[Flectarn]

[IMG]

Anyway, sorry for my short absence. I have just recently bought Supreme Commander Gold Edition.

Good reason for an absence

[Kittamaru]

Sup Com and Sup Com Forged Alliance... uber games...

Cody, what all is in the Gold Edition?

[USS Exeter]

Dude, you don't say 'mate', you're obviously very sheltered.

Well DUH! He is supposedly ten years old.

[USS Exeter]

Star Trek beats Star Wars. Y'know why? In ST, they talk about science; I like science.

End of discussion and off to bed for me.

[Oli]

Star Trek beats Star Wars. Y'know why? In ST, they talk about science; I like science.

They talk about it. But they don't use it...

[USS Exeter]

They talk about it. But they don't use it...

Science content in Star Trek and Star Wars


Star Trek > Star Wars

Star Wars is merely of the fantasy genre, I don't really see how it is even sci-fi.

[Oli]

Technobabble science content: Star Trek > Star Wars.
Actual science content: Star Trek = Star Wars.

[USS Exeter]

Oh really? Child-like fantasy content with a fascist vs. fascist duke-out: Star Wars > Star Trek.

[Oli]

Oh well...
Mythic quality Wars > Trek

[USS Exeter]

I'll have to give it that one. /admits defeat

Star Wars movies do have much more cinematic value than the Star Trek movies.

[Oli]

I cried at the first Trek movie: they didn't even play the damn theme tune until 15 hours into it...

[USS Exeter]

William Shatner > all of the Star Wars actors and actresses (in episodes 1,2, and 3)

[Oli]

Shatner's ego, certainly

[Kittamaru]

Picard is the best... how many old, bald guys can you say make being old and bald seem almost macho.