Star Wars vs Star Trek

**SkywalkerJedi** · 04-04-08, 05:52 PM

Originally Posted by Kittamaru

Oh, and in Star Trek: Voyager, their EMH (emergency Medical HOlogram, eg, their doctor) had a personal holographic emitter come season two I believe it was. This allowed him to leave the ship at will!

So BOOSH BOY!

Nope, if they did, when the ship got taken over by a allien race in one episod, their crew members need medical help, acording to you they can use use the personal emmiter.

**SkywalkerJedi** · 04-04-08, 05:53 PM

Originally Posted by Flectarn

actually i think it was more like warp 6 most of the time... and they kept running out of fuel and breaking their engine...

They always got fuel from the nebulas.

**SkywalkerJedi** · 04-04-08, 06:06 PM

Originally Posted by antaran_1979

and you are forgetting ISD1 uses dual TLs and ISD2 uses octal barbette mountings.

but they did attack asteroids giving as a valid representation of TL firepower.

BTW DS1 was not really shielded. X-wings went right trough and they fired freely on the surface and the batteries.

The ISD have no dual turbolaser they are single. The problem is if they didn't attack big astroids people will mistaken that they can't blow up big astroids. DS1 is not shielded i thought he means Ventors.

**Kittamaru** · 04-04-08, 06:59 PM

Originally Posted by SkywalkerJedi

I said REPUBLIC COMMANDOS and SPACETROOPERS.

I hain't seen em in the movies bud. These are the ground forces we have witnessed... supposedly some of the empires best...

**Kittamaru** · 04-04-08, 07:00 PM

Originally Posted by SkywalkerJedi

keywork: Studying not invented. If so why are the dominions stranded in Alpha Qudrant, acroding to you they can go to Gamma Qudrant in a few days

Cause the Dominion suck? I dont' know much about em as I've missed most of DS9... didn't even know they HAD Quantum Slipstream or anything like that...

Oh, and the wormhole was covered by an anti-matter MINEFIELD... so they couldn't use that. DUh.

**Kittamaru** · 04-04-08, 07:01 PM

Originally Posted by SkywalkerJedi

Nope, if they did, when the ship got taken over by a allien race in one episod, their crew members need medical help, acording to you they can use use the personal emmiter.

Have you even WATCHED Voyager??? Dear god!

**Kittamaru** · 04-04-08, 07:02 PM

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cysCX5qi9qQ

Watch that you nimrod... those are ALL HOLOGRAMS! ALL OF THEM!

**Kittamaru** · 04-04-08, 07:04 PM

Why Trek > Wars

They have FUN!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X024n...eature=related

**~~Saquist~~** · 04-04-08, 07:22 PM

Originally Posted by SkywalkerJedi

Well yes.

There is a problem. Star Wars never attack a planet with turbolaser ( they do have the range in the novles about the Clone Wars ) so it is hard to perdict the damage it will do to a planetary surface and Star Wars don't measure their turbolaser affect.

But we can measure and compare.
destruction of a small asteroid is equivalent to the Enterprise blast the cube.
The asteroid was no longer than 40 meters wide. If it was a hundred metters wide then it's position in front of the ISD was deceptive as it clearly was far smaller than the fighter bay under the ship. And if it was supposed to be closer it should appear at least twice the size of the corellian corvette which we see from similar angles and we know fits in side the fighter bay quite snuggly at 150 meters long.

There appears to be no justification for that asteroid being larger.
For the Turbo laser being more powerful as the Federation starship destroyed an amount of material far exceeding the asteroids mass and that mass 10 times denser than the asteroid.

It's a close and shut case.

Skywalker is almost the force itself.

Unless it says...he's omnipotent there is no contest.

**Kittamaru** · 04-04-08, 07:24 PM

SkywalkerJedi is another TWScott like boob... present him with facts, he walks around them. It's getting tiresome. Bring on some REAL, HONEST wars fans that would do the saga HONOR and JUSTICE!

**SkywalkerJedi** · 04-04-08, 07:26 PM

Originally Posted by Kittamaru

I hain't seen em in the movies bud. These are the ground forces we have witnessed... supposedly some of the empires best...

This is empire's best

501st legion( vader's fist )

**SkywalkerJedi** · 04-04-08, 07:27 PM

Originally Posted by Kittamaru

Cause the Dominion suck? I dont' know much about em as I've missed most of DS9... didn't even know they HAD Quantum Slipstream or anything like that...

Oh, and the wormhole was covered by an anti-matter MINEFIELD... so they couldn't use that. DUh.

Yes they did. Acording to you they can do fine without a wormhole.

**SkywalkerJedi** · 04-04-08, 07:27 PM

Originally Posted by Kittamaru

Have you even WATCHED Voyager??? Dear god!

Yes i have every week

**Kittamaru** · 04-04-08, 07:37 PM

And you haven't seen the EMH leave the sick bay??? Or the countless times he's left the SHIP?

And those suits, other than the blue stripes, look EXACTLY the same as the first and third pictures I posted... except for having still smaller eye slots (and thus even LESS peripheral vision and probably NO depth perception... no wonder they can't hit anything) and a slightly leaner build. I love the exposed thigh joints... phaser blast there would finish that trooper off real quick!

**Kittamaru** · 04-04-08, 07:37 PM

I never said the Dominion have any of this technology btw... I said the Federation have been working on them for years and, as the future federation has it, they get it at some point!

**SkywalkerJedi** · 04-04-08, 07:46 PM

Originally Posted by Saquist

But we can measure and compare.
destruction of a small asteroid is equivalent to the Enterprise blast the cube.
The asteroid was no longer than 40 meters wide. If it was a hundred metters wide then it's position in front of the ISD was deceptive as it clearly was far smaller than the fighter bay under the ship. And if it was supposed to be closer it should appear at least twice the size of the corellian corvette which we see from similar angles and we know fits in side the fighter bay quite snuggly at 150 meters long.

There appears to be no justification for that asteroid being larger.
For the Turbo laser being more powerful as the Federation starship destroyed an amount of material far exceeding the asteroids mass and that mass 10 times denser than the asteroid.

It's a close and shut case.

Unless it says...he's omnipotent there is no contest.

Once he is a force ghost he is omnipotent. Skywalker is the most powerful.

**SkywalkerJedi** · 04-04-08, 07:47 PM

Originally Posted by Kittamaru

And you haven't seen the EMH leave the sick bay??? Or the countless times he's left the SHIP?

And those suits, other than the blue stripes, look EXACTLY the same as the first and third pictures I posted... except for having still smaller eye slots (and thus even LESS peripheral vision and probably NO depth perception... no wonder they can't hit anything) and a slightly leaner build. I love the exposed thigh joints... phaser blast there would finish that trooper off real quick!

Yes I have. I didn't see every episode i only started last month.

**SkywalkerJedi** · 04-04-08, 07:48 PM

Originally Posted by Kittamaru

I never said the Dominion have any of this technology btw... I said the Federation have been working on them for years and, as the future federation has it, they get it at some point!

Well yes and star wars can make 0.0001 class hyperdrive by the time they made transwarps ( the lower the class the faster )

**SkywalkerJedi** · 04-04-08, 07:50 PM

[QUOTE=Saquist;1807594]But we can measure and compare.
destruction of a small asteroid is equivalent to the Enterprise blast the cube.
The asteroid was no longer than 40 meters wide. If it was a hundred metters wide then it's position in front of the ISD was deceptive as it clearly was far smaller than the fighter bay under the ship. And if it was supposed to be closer it should appear at least twice the size of the corellian corvette which we see from similar angles and we know fits in side the fighter bay quite snuggly at 150 meters long.

There appears to be no justification for that asteroid being larger.
For the Turbo laser being more powerful as the Federation starship destroyed an amount of material far exceeding the asteroids mass and that mass 10 times denser than the asteroid.

It's a close and shut case.[/QOUTE]
Turbolaser is no weaker then Phasers depending on Phaser and the Turbolaser class.( There are alot better turbolasers )

**SkywalkerJedi** · 04-04-08, 07:54 PM

Originally Posted by Kittamaru

SkywalkerJedi is another TWScott like boob... present him with facts, he walks around them. It's getting tiresome. Bring on some REAL, HONEST wars fans that would do the saga HONOR and JUSTICE!

I am not a fast typer, this is my brother's accont I am only 10. I need time, I have school and you guys keep storming me with arguments day and night, if I take my time and find some proof, you guys are gonna say " He don't have a answer for this we win."